Renting vs. Buying: How to Decide What’s Right for Your Budget | The Budget Mom (2024)

When we’re kids, we have an idealistic image of what adulthood will look like. We imagine we’ll grow up to own a beautiful house with a yard, white picket fence, and have two paid-for cars in the garage, one for ourselves and the other for our spouse.

If only life were that simple!

A record-high 36% of all households now rent instead of own their home.

Of course, it’s still possible to achieve homeownership, but the journey to get there is more difficult than ever before.

This raises multiple questions: Should I rent or should I buy? When is the right time to switch over to homeownership? Is renting really just throwing money away?

In this article, we’ll cover the budget-based factors to help you consider which options may be right for you. In addition to your budget, we’ll also discuss the lifestyle considerations that you should factor into your decision. So, let’s get started!

Why Renting Could Be Better Than Buying

Conventional wisdom is that buying is better than renting because you are building equity in something you tangibly own.

However, this isn’t always the case.

According to Forbes, it can take 3-7 years to simply break even on your home purchase, depending on where you live.

With that being said, renting is likely better if:

• You see yourself moving soon
• You’re only temporarily living somewhere (i.e. for school, residency, etc.)
• You’re looking for new jobs or might be transferring locations
• You don’t feel established yet in your career

There’s this misperception that renting is just “throwing money away.” For some people, however, renting is actually “paying” for flexibility that doesn’t come with homeownership.

Think about it: with renting, you can easily move to a new city, accept a job across the country, and even move to a new rental unit without worrying about a commitment to a property. You don’t have to worry about taking a loss or breaking even on your home purchase. Instead, you can simply pick up your belongings and move.

The biggest benefit of renting is flexibility.

Plus, it doesn’t hurt that renting is often much cheaper than homeownership. For example, if an appliance breaks or repairs are needed, your landlord or apartment manager will take care of the issues. Compare this to homeownership, where you are financially on the line for any repairs.

Homeowners also have to pay property taxes, which can increase substantially based on local policies or an increase in home value.

To recap, the benefits of renting can be summed up as:

• Flexibility.
  It’s much easier to end a lease than to sell a house. You can easily move, accept new job offers, or upgrade your living space based on your current needs.
• Fewer financial responsibilities.
  If appliances break as part of regular use, most landlords and apartment units will eat up that cost. They’ll coordinate the repairs and pay for the fixes. Homeowners, on the other hand, are responsible for all costs incurred on their property. If you are not in a position to handle the financial side of property upkeep, then renting is likely better.
• Smaller upfront costs.
  With renting, you usually have to pay an application fee or an initial deposit. This is much smaller than the down payment for a home, appraisal fees, and loan origination fees. There are also other costs associated with first-time homeownership such as new furnishings and purchasing tools for general maintenance (i.e. a lawnmower).
• More cash to save and invest.
  It’s important to take advantage of your time as a renter. Because the costs of renting are less than the cost of owning a home, then use this time to build up your savings and investments. You should also be saving for specific long-term goals such as the down payment on your first home!

Buying a home is a great goal to have, but it doesn’t mean that it’s a goal you need to accomplish immediately. First, focus on finishing school and getting settled into your degree. During this time, begin preparing and strategizing your budget for the future so that when it’s time to make the leap into homeownership, it’s as smooth as possible!

Why Buying a Home Could Be Better Than Renting

On the other hand, there are many instances when buying a home is a better option than renting.

You should evaluate both your financial preparedness as well as your lifestyle needs.

Financially, owning a home isn’t just about “how much mortgage can I afford?” There are other monetary factors including, but not limited to:

• Your current debt-to-income ratio
• How much of a down payment you have saved up
• Ability to handle repairs and maintenance
• Planning for annual property taxes

In other words, just because you can afford a mortgage payment, it doesn’t necessarily mean that you can afford a home. However, if you have a stable income and are able to handle these considerations, then it may make more financial sense for you to purchase a home.

But a house isn’t only a financial decision. It’s an emotional one, too.

Think about it: a house isn’t just a piece of property. It’s a home.

This is where you’ll live, spend time with your loved ones, and maybe even raise a family.

So it’s important to also consider your lifestyle. If you are at a point where you want to place down roots, then it definitely makes sense to buy a home. Consider the local community as well. Are the people next-door folks you’re comfortable being neighbors with? Are the local school systems right for your kids? Do your values align with the community’s values? If so, then it might be a good idea to buy where you are!

When it comes to lifestyle, the most important question you can ask yourself is: do I see my life changing dramatically any time in the near future?

If the answer is “no” and your income is very secure, then buying is likely better than renting. If your answer is “yes,” then renting is probably the better option.

What are the Pros and Cons of Renting vs. Buying?

When it comes to the question of whether or not it’s better to rent or buy a home, only you can answer that question.

Be sure that your decision is yours — and yours alone.

Don’t be swayed by what you think others expect you to do. Ignore the temptation to try to “keep up with the Joneses” or compare yourself to the progress some of your friends are making.

Instead, consider your unique financial situation as well as your current and projected lifestyle needs.

To help, here’s a brief recap of what we discussed above.

The pros of homeownership include:

• The opportunity to build equity
• Stable and predictable mortgage payments (with a fixed-rate mortgage)
• Tax deductions
• Potential for your home to increase in value

The cons of homeownership include:

• Your home can potentially decrease in value
• Higher property taxes with new policies
• More responsibility for maintenance and repairs
• Expensive upfront costs
• Less flexibility compared to renters
• Must purchase homeowners insurance

Though there is a perception that renting is “throwing money away,” that isn’t necessarily the truth. It’s all dependent on your current financial situation as well as your lifestyle.

The pros of renting include:

• Much more flexibility to end a lease, move, etc.
• Your landlord will handle maintenance and repairs
• Lower upfront costs compared to buying a home
• More extra cash to save, invest, and plan for the future

The cons of renting include:

• Rent prices can increase yearly
• Bad experiences with landlords or apartments
• No ability to build equity

Whether you decide to rent or buy a home, the most important thing you can do for your finances today is to have a strategic and intentional budget. To learn more about budgeting, feel free to read my previous budgeting posts here!