Gold bars vs. gold IRA vs. gold ETF: Experts pick the best option (2024)

We may receive commissions from some links to products on this page. Promotions are subject to availability and retailer terms.

MoneyWatch: Managing Your Money
Gold bars vs. gold IRA vs. gold ETF: Experts pick the best option (2)

There are many reasons you might want to buy gold — particularly in today's economic climate. For one, it's long been considered a smart hedge against inflation, which has remained stubbornly high for the last two years. It's also a good portfolio diversifier, allowing you to spread your wealth across different asset classes and protecting it in the event of a downturn in other sectors you're invested in.

Still, there are lots of ways to buy gold. You can purchase physical gold bars and bullion, or you can invest in gold ETFs. You can even open a gold IRA and use it to save for retirement. Not sure which gold investment is right for your needs? We asked some experts to weigh in.

Start exploring your gold investing options here today and take advantage of this unique opportunity.

Gold bars vs. gold IRA vs. gold ETF: What the experts think

We asked a few experts to weigh in on these three gold investing choices. Here's what they think about each.

Gold bars

The old standard is to purchase physical gold, by way of gold bars, coins and bullion. This can be a good choice if you want to keep your investment liquid, as you can easily sell the gold at any time and turn it into cash. It's also easier and more private than other options.

"When you own physical gold, you don't have to rely on any financial institution or counterparty to fulfill your investment," says Alex Ebkarian, co-founder of Allegiance Gold. "Transactions can be relatively discreet."

The big downside is that owning physical gold won't result in income — as dividend-yielding gold stocks might — and that there are often "transaction costs, dealer markups, and assay fees," according to Ebkarian.

You will also have costs associated with transporting and storing the gold bars or coins. This might mean renting a safety deposit box or installing a safe in your home.

Finally, physical gold comes with the potential risk of fraud. As Ebkarian explains, "There's a risk of encountering counterfeit gold bars and coins, especially if you purchase them from unverified sources. Do your due diligence. Ensure authenticity."

Learn more about investing in gold bars and coins here now.

Gold IRAs

Another option is agold IRA, which is a wise move if you're looking to use gold to grow your retirement savings.

"A gold IRA can act as a form of insurance for your retirement savings," Ebkarian says. "If financial markets suffer a significant downturn, the price of gold may rise which would help preserve the value of your retirement accounts."

There also may be tax benefits to having a gold IRA. Depending on what type of account you have, you may enjoy tax-deferred growth of your money or, in retirement, tax-free withdrawals.

The major drawback is that IRAs have age limits. If you withdraw money from an IRA before you're 59.5, you'll face a 10% penalty.

Gold IRAs also require more set-up, have maintenance and storage fees, and you have to hand the reins over to a custodian (you can't just open and manage the account yourself).

"Managing a gold IRA can involve a few more steps to set up than a traditional retirement account," Ebkarian says. "You will need to find a custodian who specializes in precious metals."

Gold ETFs

Gold ETFs are a smart option if you want to invest in gold but not hold it physically. There is no storage or transport involved, there's no potential counterfeit risk, and you can spread your investment across the wider gold sector. These also tend to be fairly liquid.

"You can purchase and sell them easily," says Collin Plume, founder of Noble Gold Investments. "They prove to be good investment options for short-term and medium-term investors."

Gold ETFs come with maintenance fees and transaction fees, though, and you could owe capital gains taxes on your profits. Finally, there's also risk that your investment will lose value. In fact, Plume actually calls gold ETFs "the riskiest" of all three gold-buying strategies.

"Your investment depends on the company and not gold itself," Plume says. "Gold prices could be going up, but if the company you are investing in fails, your investment fails."

Learn more about gold bars, gold IRAs and gold ETFs here to determine which is best for you.

Which gold investment is best?

The right gold investment choice really depends on your goals and timeline. If you're willing to take on some risk in exchange for potential growth, a gold ETF may be a good option. It also might be smart if you want more liquidity and easier access to your funds. If you're thinking long-term and want a safer bet, a gold IRA may be the best option.

"It's all about perspective and objective," Plume says. "If you're investing in gold because you want a hedge so that when you retire, you have that one asset that will go against your traditional assets, then it's better to have it in an IRA. If you want the security of knowing you will have gold no matter what, then it's good to get it delivered to you."

Gold bars vs. gold IRA vs. gold ETF: Experts pick the best option (2024)

FAQs

Gold bars vs. gold IRA vs. gold ETF: Experts pick the best option? ›

If you're willing to take on some risk in exchange for potential growth, a gold ETF may be a good option. It also might be smart if you want more liquidity and easier access to your funds. If you're thinking long-term and want a safer bet, a gold IRA may be the best option.

Is it better to buy gold or a gold ETF? ›

Whether to hold physical gold or invest in gold exchange-traded funds requires examining the trade-offs with each, including their liquidity, costs, returns, risks, and the practicalities involved. In general, gold ETFs offer some tax advantages and lower costs over time than trading physical gold.

What is the best option to buy gold? ›

Gold futures are a good way to speculate on the price of gold rising (or falling), and you could even take physical delivery of gold, if you wanted, though physical delivery is not what motivates speculators. The biggest advantage of using futures to invest in gold is the immense amount of leverage that you can use.

Which form of gold is best to invest? ›

Instead, the average gold investor should consider gold-oriented mutual funds and ETFs, as these securities generally provide the easiest and safest way to invest in gold. Larger investors seeking direct exposure to the price of gold can buy gold directly through bullion.

Is it a good idea to invest in a gold IRA? ›

Gold can be a portfolio diversifier to traditional stock and bond investing, and sometimes it is considered a safe-haven investment during market turmoil. Gold investors cite how it can be a hedge against inflation since it retains value over time. That longevity can make gold suitable for a retirement account as well.

What is the number one gold ETF? ›

Compared to buying and storing physical gold bullion, a gold ETF offers lower transaction fees, better liquidity and access to a brokerage account. Our pick for the best overall gold ETF goes to SPDR Gold MiniShares Trust (GLDM).

Why not gold ETF? ›

Physical gold provides a higher level of security than Gold ETFs, as it eliminates counterparty risk. Gold ETFs may not perform as well as physical gold during times of economic uncertainty or geopolitical instability.

What is the smartest way to buy gold? ›

It's best to buy from a reputable source to ensure that you are buying precisely what is represented. You also can purchase physical gold from online gold dealers. They sell high-quality physical gold and ship it to your home or store in a secured vault.

What is the most profitable way to buy gold? ›

Investing in a gold stock, ETF or mutual fund is often the best way to get exposure to gold in your portfolio. In order to buy a gold stock or fund, you'll need a brokerage account, which you can open with an online broker (here's a step-by-step guide to opening a brokerage account).

What is the most reputable place to buy gold? ›

  • Our Top Picks.
  • APMEX (American Precious Metals Exchange)
  • JM Bullion.
  • BGASC.
  • Money Metals Exchange.
  • SD Bullion.
  • Golden Eagle Coins.
  • See More (3)

Which gold plan is best? ›

Best Gold Savings Scheme in India – 2024
  • Tanishq Golden Harvest.
  • Kalyan Jewellers Yearly Gold Savings Scheme.
  • Malabar Gold Investment Scheme.
  • Bhima Jewellery's Golden Key EMA Plan.
  • Jos Alukkas' Easy Buy Gold Purchase Plan.
Jun 7, 2024

What is the most tax efficient way to invest in gold? ›

Avoid making investments in the physical metal and you can minimize your capital gains taxes to the ordinary long-term capital gains rate. And when possible, hold on to your gold investments for at least one year before selling to avoid higher income tax rates.

What type of gold holds its value best? ›

Gold Bars. This is the form of gold bullion that has the most value. Gold bars can range from 1 ounce to a few kilos. One can get as much value in a gold bar as one can afford.

Do you pay tax on gold IRA? ›

Once you reach age 59 ½, you can take distributions from your Gold IRA at any time, in any amount, without penalty. The withdrawal will be taxed as ordinary income for Traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRAs. For Roth IRAs, withdrawals are tax-free if you've held the account for at least 5 years.

Can I cash out gold IRA? ›

Key Withdrawal Rules for Investors

Withdrawals from a traditional Gold IRA before the age of 59 ½ are subject to a 10% penalty in addition to being taxed as ordinary income. However, Roth IRAs offer tax-free withdrawals, provided the account has been open for at least five years and the owner is over 59 ½ years of age.

Can I store my gold IRA at home? ›

The idea is that investors can open a self-directed IRA and keep the gold at home, rather than store it elsewhere. While that may sound like a strategy that saves money and gives investors more control over their assets' location, it's not allowed, according to Internal Revenue Service rules.

Is gold ETF better than digital gold? ›

Better Returns: Digital Gold has the potential to generate better returns compared to Gold ETFs, even after considering the 3% GST on Digital Gold purchase.

Which is best gold bond or gold ETF? ›

Gold ETFs are more liquid compared to SGBs as they can be traded in the open market at the free will of the investors as it does not have any lock-in period. Thus Gold ETFs can be used for the short term, medium-term, or long term investment objectives as desired.

Is it better to buy physical gold or gold stocks? ›

The choice between physical gold and gold stocks ultimately depends on your investment goals, risk tolerance and preferences. If you value owning a tangible asset and are comfortable with the responsibilities of secure storage, physical gold might be appealing.

Is it better to buy digital gold or physical gold? ›

While digital gold allows better short-term investment and does not have the storage hassle, physical gold is better suited for the long term. Also, those preferring liquidity should go for digital gold, but risk-averse investors should choose physical gold.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ouida Strosin DO

Last Updated:

Views: 6543

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (76 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ouida Strosin DO

Birthday: 1995-04-27

Address: Suite 927 930 Kilback Radial, Candidaville, TN 87795

Phone: +8561498978366

Job: Legacy Manufacturing Specialist

Hobby: Singing, Mountain biking, Water sports, Water sports, Taxidermy, Polo, Pet

Introduction: My name is Ouida Strosin DO, I am a precious, combative, spotless, modern, spotless, beautiful, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.