BBC NEWS | Business | Q&A: The pros and cons of debt relief (2024)

BBC NEWS | Business | Q&A: The pros and cons of debt relief (1)

BBC News Online looks at the debate on debt relief and some of the thorny issues involved.

Why is debt relief so contentious?

Campaigners like Oxfam and Jubilee Research (which ran the "Drop the Debt" campaign) have long urged lenders to write off debt owed by poor countries.

They argue that heavily indebted countries are forced to spend more on servicing their debt than feeding or educating their children.

Multilateral lenders like the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank are not against debt relief, but prefer to tie it to certain conditions.

Western governments are also becoming more open to debt relief and have agreed to increase the amount they write off.

However, there are concerns that debt relief might be seen as a perverse reward for countries that lack financial discipline.

"What about the good guys?" says Charles Harvey, a fellow of the Institute of Development Studies in Sussex, UK.

"Why should they keep paying if we let off the bad guys?"

Why are the World Bank and the IMF more cautious about writing off debts?

They are reluctant to cancel debt if the country in question does not have good governance or a credible government.

Countries like Somalia and Liberia are heavily indebted but will not qualify for debt relief from the World Bank anytime soon.

In addition, the World Bank and the IMF like to have a commitment from the country to re-allocate the money saved to areas such as healthcare and education.

Often countries are also expected to initiate programmes of economic reform, such as cutting budget deficits.

BBC NEWS | Business | Q&A: The pros and cons of debt relief (2)

Egypt receives the most aid in Africa

How do lenders decide which countries to give debt relief to?

The World Bank administers debt relief through its heavily indebted poor countries (HIPC) initiative, set up in 1997.

"HIPC is a financial operation that is designed to bring the countries down to an easily manageable debt level," says Tony Gaeta, a senior operations officer at HIPC.

Currently, about 37 countries are eligible for debt relief, but about 10 of them - such as Liberia - don't meet the World Bank conditions.

The aim of the programme is to help any country with debt that is worth more than one-and-a-half times their annual export revenues.

HPIC provides relief to enable these countries to reduce their debt below this level - which is believed to be sustainable.

In 1999, the G8 leaders meeting in Cologne promised to write off $100bn in debt.

BBC NEWS | Business | Q&A: The pros and cons of debt relief (3)

Japan is the top international donor

So why does the World Bank still attract criticism?

Oxfam argues that the HIPC process can take too long and impose too many complex conditions.

Marlene Barrett, an education campaign manager at Oxfam, also says that more needs to be done on "working out what a sustainable amount of debt is".

The charity maintains that even HIPC countries are still spending more on debt than healthcare, for example.

Ms Barrett adds that the World Bank often risks using inflated projections of a country's export revenues.

For example, after Uganda completed the HIPC programme, its coffee exports were hit by a downturn in the market.

This increased its debt costs to above the one-and-a-half times threshold - or in other words to unsustainable levels.

However, the World Bank has recently proposed using one-off, top-up payments to counter any sudden dips in a country's export revenues.

How does the lending system for poor countries work?

Currently, a three-pronged system exists.

  • The IMF is like a credit co-operative, where member countries pay a subscription according to the size of their GDP.

    That money is then available for a member to borrow if it has problems.

  • The World Bank has two lending arms - the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD) and the International Development Association (IDA).

    The IBRD borrows money in the financial markets and then lends it to middle-income countries and creditworthy poorer countries at a relatively low commercial rate.

    The IDA, which gets its funding from international donors such as governments, lends to the really poor countries.

    It only charges borrowers about three-quarters of a percent, which means the loans are almost like grants.

    Effectively only about $7 in every $100 is charged at a commercial rate.

  • Bilateral donors include countries that lend directly to other countries.

    Unlike the banks, bilateral donors have more freedom to offer debt relief to their borrowers.

    Most donor countries belong to both the IMF and the World Bank.

BBC NEWS | Business | Q&A: The pros and cons of debt relief (4)

The European Union is the biggest lender to Africa

Are grants better than loans?

The US government argues that the IDA should make more use of grants - where countries do not have to repay the money at all - rather than loans.

But the UK opposes this plan because it believes that grants would "seriously undermine the IDA's future financial viability".

Although IDA loans are cheap, the borrowers do pay back about 25%, which is then re-lent to other countries.

BBC NEWS
 | Business
 | Q&A: The pros and cons of debt relief (2024)

FAQs

What are the disadvantages of debt relief? ›

Disadvantages of Debt Relief Orders

If your circ*mstances change, you may still be required to repay your creditors. Your debt relief order will appear on your credit file for six years. This may affect your ability to get credit in the future.

What are the benefits of debt relief? ›

Improved credit score and access to better financial opportunities. Successfully navigating debt relief programs often involves negotiating with creditors and developing structured repayment plans. As you fulfill your obligations and make consistent payments, your credit score will begin to improve.

What is the debt relief program? ›

Debt relief or settlement companies are companies that say they can renegotiate, settle, or in some way change the terms of a person's debt to a creditor or debt collector.

What does debt reduction mean? ›

Debt relief refers to measures to reduce or refinance debt in order to make it easier for the borrower to repay it. Options for debt relief include forgiving a portion of the debt, lowering the interest rate, stretching payments over a longer period, or consolidating multiple debts into a single, lower-interest one.

Is it worth doing a debt relief program? ›

Debt relief will also often give you a fixed payment plan and a set payoff date, which can also make it worth considering — as streamlining your payments can make it easier to manage while helping you save money on interest. "One of the biggest advantages of going through a debt relief program is the savings.

What are the dangers of debt forgiveness? ›

Downsides of debt forgiveness

Forgiven debt of more than $600 may be considered taxable income, potentially resulting in a hefty tax bill. Engaging with debt relief companies could lead to additional fees, exacerbating financial difficulties.

Will debt relief hurt my credit? ›

Debt relief services may have a negative impact on your credit score, but that impact may not be as big as you think — and in some cases, it can help your credit. How these services impact your credit depends on the debt relief option you choose.

Do it yourself debt relief pros and cons? ›

Understanding the Process of Debt Settlement
Pros of DIY Debt SettlementCons of DIY Debt Settlement
Total control of the processTotal responsibility for the process
Potential faster repayment of debtRequires more time, patience, effort, and negotiating skill than you may have at hand
2 more rows

Can I buy a house after debt settlement? ›

If their credit scores are good enough, a home buyer can qualify for a conventional mortgage while still in debt settlement,” says Dan Green, CEO of Homebuyer.com. “There's no designated waiting period like with a bankruptcy or recent short sale.”

How long does debt relief hurt your credit? ›

As with most other negative credit report entries, settled accounts stay on your credit reports for seven years.

How long does debt relief stay on your credit report? ›

Debt relief can be a lifeline to help you get out from under unaffordable debt—but it can also damage your credit. So, if you're considering a form of debt relief, you'll want to bear in mind its effect on your credit report, where the information can stay for up to 10 years.

Can I still use my credit card after debt settlement? ›

If a credit card account remains open after you've paid it off through debt consolidation, you can still use it. However, running up another balance could make it difficult to pay off your debt consolidation account.

What happens when you do a debt relief program? ›

It typically involves hiring a debt relief company to employ one or more strategies that help you get debt under control, such as by reducing the amount you owe, lowering your interest rate, or securing better terms. Learn how debt relief programs work and whether they may be right for you.

What are the pros and cons of debt settlement? ›

Debt settlement pros and cons
ProsCons
Might be able to settle for less than what you oweCreditors might not be willing to negotiate
Pay off debt soonerCould come with fees
Stop calls from collection agenciesCould hurt your credit
Could help you avoid bankruptcyDebt written off might be taxable

What is the best debt relief company? ›

National Debt Relief is the best overall debt settlement company, according to our research. National Debt Relief's low-cost fee structure and referral service make it a top option for people struggling with debts. Our highest-rated debt settlement companies all charge similar fees, ranging from 15% to 25% of the debt.

Is debt relief bad for your credit? ›

Debt relief services may have a negative impact on your credit score, but that impact may not be as big as you think — and in some cases, it can help your credit. How these services impact your credit depends on the debt relief option you choose.

Is debt settlement better than not paying? ›

Despite the potential downside, settling a debt by making partial repayment is better for your credit (and peace of mind) than neglecting it and leaving it unpaid. If you ignore a debt, the creditor will typically turn it over to a collection department or third-party collection agency.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Zonia Mosciski DO

Last Updated:

Views: 6281

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Zonia Mosciski DO

Birthday: 1996-05-16

Address: Suite 228 919 Deana Ford, Lake Meridithberg, NE 60017-4257

Phone: +2613987384138

Job: Chief Retail Officer

Hobby: Tai chi, Dowsing, Poi, Letterboxing, Watching movies, Video gaming, Singing

Introduction: My name is Zonia Mosciski DO, I am a enchanting, joyous, lovely, successful, hilarious, tender, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.