5 signs your carton of milk has gone bad, according to a food safety expert (2024)

  • Old milk will give off an unpleasant odor.
  • The best way to check to see if your carton of milk is bad is to smell it, according to food safety expert Theodore Labuza.
  • Be wary of the date listed on the carton of milk, as it is just a guess to the lifespan of the product, per Labuza.

5 signs your carton of milk has gone bad, according to a food safety expert (1)

NEW LOOK

Sign up to get the inside scoop on today’s biggest stories in markets, tech, and business — delivered daily. Read preview

5 signs your carton of milk has gone bad, according to a food safety expert (2)

Thanks for signing up!

Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go.

5 signs your carton of milk has gone bad, according to a food safety expert (3)

Advertisem*nt

Got milk? Perhaps you remember the slogan from the popular '90s dairy campaign. But, if you've actually got milk, do you know how to tell when it goes bad?

There are a few obvious signs to look for when trying to decide if your carton of milk is no longer good. Theodore Labuza, a food safety expert and professor at the University of Minnesota's Department of Food Science and Nutrition, has been studying the shelf life of food and beverages for nearly 50 years. Here's are the five signs your carton of milk is bad, according to Labuza.

The milk has surpassed the sell-by date

The date listed on your carton of milk isn't necessarily an expiration date. It may also be a sell-by date or best-used-by date. The timeframe should be viewed as a barometer of how long the milk may possibly be good for. This is why it's important to be familiar with the other signs that may indicate a carton of milk is no longer drinkable.

"The companies who put dates on milk or other products are just guessing," said Labuza. "When they put a date on the package of food or carton of milk, that's a guess. They don't know what temperature your refrigerator is at. Everybody's refrigerator isn't set to the same single temperature."

Advertisem*nt

The milk hasn't been consistently refrigerated at the right temperature

Coincidentally, refrigeration temperature has a lot to do with the sell-by date listed on the milk carton, per Labuza.

"The biggest problem with the shelf life of a product is that the date does not take into account that the refrigerators cycle in temperature," Labuza told INSIDER. "Everybody's refrigerator is not the same temperature. The higher in temperature your refrigerator is set to, the shorter the shelf life of the carton of milk becomes."

5 signs your carton of milk has gone bad, according to a food safety expert (4)

Labuza recommends 32 degrees Fahrenheit as a safe bet to ensure the longevity of your milk. Don't worry, he said it's not going to freeze.

Related stories

"Once the refrigerator reaches the lower set temperature, it shuts off," said Labuza, who keeps his refrigerator set to run between 31 and 33 degrees Fahrenheit. "At some point, the temperature of the refrigerator goes up to the upper limit and that kick starts the refrigerator into cooling back down to the lower temperature."

Advertisem*nt

The milk has a foul odor

Give your carton of milk the sniff test. If your milk doesn't smell like milk, it's likely expired. Milk that's gone bad exudes a foul odor — and it will be very obvious upon taking a whiff. Labuza said this is the best procedure for determining if your milk has gone bad.

"The odor is very obnoxious. If you drank it, it would attack your nasal sensors and tell you this is bad. Your nose is a very very sensitive tool and it gives you something that says the milk is no good at that time," said Labuza, who said he has worked with NASA and the military on food safety.

"If you drank it, you'd probably throw up. It's not food poisoning but it's food objection. The organisms in there produce various kinds of compounds that have an objectional odor. It definitely smells like bad milk."

There are changes to the texture and consistency

When you unscrew the lid on a carton of milk, the white liquid should appear smooth and free of any particles. If you open up a gallon of milk and notice clumps and curdling, it's time to toss it out.

Advertisem*nt

Why does this happen? As Labuza explains, it all has to do with enzymes in the milk reacting with one another.

"If the milk is bad, it will curdle. It's spoiling because the microbes produce certain enzymes," said Labuza. Milk is mostly composed of fat, protein, and sugar. "The acid produced by the organisms will cause the milk to precipitate out and curdle."

5 signs your carton of milk has gone bad, according to a food safety expert (5)

It's lost its pearly white color

Unless you're drinking chocolate milk, the color of plain old milk should always be white. If you crack open a carton of milk and notice anything different, that's a sign that the dairy product is no longer good.

"The other enzymes impact the protein in the milk, so it breaks down the protein into amino acids and that will have different bad flavors," said Labuza. "The same reaction that produces browning on a piece of toast — the Maillard reaction— that's a reaction between the protein molecules and the sugar in the milk. That causes a browning color and flavor in the milk."

5 signs your carton of milk has gone bad, according to a food safety expert (2024)

FAQs

5 signs your carton of milk has gone bad, according to a food safety expert? ›

Spoiled milk has a distinct sour odor, which is due to lactic acid produced by bacteria. Other signs of spoilage include a slightly yellow color and lumpy texture (15). Signs that your milk has spoiled and may not be safe to drink include a sour smell and taste, change in color, and lumpy texture.

How can you tell if carton milk is bad? ›

Regardless of the printed date, the best way to determine whether milk is spoiled is with a simple sniff test. Spoiled foods develop an off odor, flavor or texture due to naturally occurring spoilage bacteria. If milk exhibits any characteristics of spoilage, it should be thrown out.

How to know if the milk is spoiled? ›

Texture/Color: Fresh milk is smooth, thin, and white. Spoiled milk may be lumpy, thick, and/or slightly yellow. Odor: Sour milk smells, well, sour. Fresh milk has barely any odor — and what odor it does have is not unpleasant.

How can you determine a glass of milk spoiled or not? ›

Signs your milk has spoiled

The scent is hard to miss and gets stronger with time. The taste also begins to change, as the natural sweetness of fresh milk is quickly replaced by a somewhat acidic or sour flavor. With enough time, the texture and color of milk that has spoiled will change as well.

How to tell if milk is bad in the microwave? ›

Pour some of the milk into a microwavable container and pop it in the microwave for a minute. If the milk comes out of the microwave looking smooth and white, then it's still fresh enough to drink. But if it comes out looking slightly lumpy and/or has changed color, then the milk has gone off and should be thrown away!

How do you know if liquid milk is spoiled? ›

Spoiled milk has a distinct sour odor, which is due to lactic acid produced by bacteria. Other signs of spoilage include a slightly yellow color and lumpy texture (15). Signs that your milk has spoiled and may not be safe to drink include a sour smell and taste, change in color, and lumpy texture.

What is the milk carton rule? ›

What's The Milk Carton Rule? It says that instead of dwelling on what you can't change, focus on what you can.

How to tell if raw milk is bad? ›

Spoiled Milk

It will taste and smell bad and will most likely upset your stomach if you try to drink it. Raw milk may sour slightly faster than if your milk is pasteurized, but it generally doesn't spoil, it just changes.

How bad does milk go bad? ›

Milk can often be consumed after its expiration date, generally for up to three days for opened milk and up to seven days for unopened milk. Before consuming, it's best to look for signs of spoilage. You can tell if milk is bad by checking the smell, color, consistency and taste.

How to tell if milk is spoiled by boiling? ›

If the milk becomes lumpy or gooey after being heated, that's a sign that it's gone bad. Milk curdles because the high acidity in the soured milk causes proteins in the milk to bond together, creating lumps. It's normal for the milk to have a thin skin on top when heated.

What are the indicators of milk spoilage? ›

Types of “spoilage of milk”
Kind of defectsRelated microorganism
Rancidity and bitternessBacillus spp.
SourLactic acid bacteria
Ropy or slimyColiforms, Bacillus subtilis
Colour changePseudomonas syncyanea, Flavobacterium spp,
2 more rows

How to test if milk is good or bad? ›

Considering the harmful health effects, knowing how to check adulteration in milk is important. Put one drop of the milk on an inclined surface. Pure milk stays in the same place or flows slowly, leaving a trail behind. Adulterated milk with water will start flowing immediately, leaving no trail behind.

Does milk last longer in glass or carton? ›

Glass is upheld as the optimal material for preserving the flavour of fluid milk, although HDPE and PET are also identified as effective materials when storing milk in dark environments. Conversely, paperboard cartons are thought to impact the freshness of the product due to flavour migration and scalping.

How to tell when milk has gone bad? ›

Spoiled milk will produce a sour smell as the bacteria produce lactic acid. The smell will intensify after the milk becomes unsafe for consumption. A yellowy color, crusts around the edges, and lumps in the milk also indicate that it is off.

Has most of the milk _____ gone bad? ›

Based on the first revision of your question, the answer would be: Most of the milk has gone bad.

What dairy lasts the longest? ›

Shelf-life of dairy products
  • Pasteurised whole milk: 12–14 days. ...
  • Yoghurt: 4–6 weeks.
  • Hard and semi-hard cheeses: Depending on the type, it may be kept for several weeks to months.
  • Cottage cheese, ricotta and cream cheese: 1–2 weeks.
  • Butter (salted): A shelf-life of about 4 weeks.

Can boxed milk go bad? ›

Organic Valley's site states shelf-stable milk can last six to nine months (that's about 270 days). Once open, shelf-stable milk should be stored in the refrigerator and is best for 5 to 7 days after opening.

Can milk go bad without smelling bad? ›

Your sense of smell and taste are your best friends here, and they'll give you the best indication of whether the milk is ok to drink – if it doesn't smell, look strange (lumpy or separated), and it tastes just fine, then you're okay to drink it.

How long can carton milk last? ›

Cornell University's Department of Food Science estimates that unopened milk will last two to five days past its sell-by date, though experts say you should be fine for a week. The university recommends drinking an opened container of milk as soon as possible (say, within a few days) for the freshest taste.

Is milk bad if the carton is puffy? ›

Carothers says it's not worth risking potentially getting sick. She says, "We here at FSIS err on the side of caution and recommend when observing swollen, puffy packages, it's best to not use, as they are potentially spoiled and therefore risky or unsafe."

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duncan Muller

Last Updated:

Views: 5472

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duncan Muller

Birthday: 1997-01-13

Address: Apt. 505 914 Phillip Crossroad, O'Konborough, NV 62411

Phone: +8555305800947

Job: Construction Agent

Hobby: Shopping, Table tennis, Snowboarding, Rafting, Motor sports, Homebrewing, Taxidermy

Introduction: My name is Duncan Muller, I am a enchanting, good, gentle, modern, tasty, nice, elegant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.