Will Putting Mulch Around A Tree Kill It? (2024)

What Is Volcano Mulching?

Volcano Mulching, also known as Over Mulching, is the improper mulching technique that piles mulch high around the tree against the tree trunk. This excess mulch can promote surface roots that ultimately end up strangling and killing the tree. Additionally, it can cause too much moisture retention during the wet seasons, promoting fungus, rot, and pests. In the dry seasons, the mulch can completely dry out and repel water, not allowing water to get to the roots of the tree at all. Finally, when mounds of mulch decompose, it becomes a pile of compost and heats up, harming the roots even more.

How To Get Rid Of Volcano Mulching?

If you have been Volcano Mulching for years, you may want to consider having Good Nature look at the health of your root system by performing a Root Collar Excavation. See the video below for more information. The pictures below show harmful stem girdling roots and decay due to improper mulching and planting techniques.

If you have smaller trees or trees that have only had Volcano Mulching for a few years, you can probably just excavate the mulch yourself with some garden tools. If you find a lot of surface roots, we recommend contacting a professional.

Will Putting Mulch Around A Tree Kill It? (1)

Will Putting Mulch Around A Tree Kill It? (2)

How To Properly Mulch Your Trees?

Trees appreciate mulch around their base so they are not competing with other plants for air and water. Mulch also helps the soil around the tree to stay in place and keeps the soil temperature consistent. It cuts down on weeds and adds nutrients to the soil surrounding the tree as it breaks down. “Donut Mulching” is the best way to mulch around trees. Leave the root flare exposed and pull the mulch a few inches away from the trunk altogether. Small trees can be mulched all the way to the drip line, or their full canopy size, but this is usually unnecessary and unwanted for mature trees, three feet around the tree is a fine maximum. Two to four inches of mulch is a great depth.

How Much Mulch Is Too Much?

As discussed, the application of too much mulch can prove very problematic for the overall health of your trees. We advise that mulch be piled no higher than 3-4 inches off the ground. It's also imperative that mulch be kept away from the base of the tree, creating the appearance of a donut hole around the tree with the surrounding mulch. We recommend keeping mulch roughly 12-18 inches away from the trunk of any tree. Ideally, the mulch around your tree would extend the length of the branches, or at a minimus 4-5 feet in diameter area around the trunk of the tree. The larger the mulched area, the more beneficial.

Will Putting Mulch Around A Tree Kill It? (3)

Should Mulch Be Replaced Every Year?

Mulch should not be replaced or removed, just piled on top of. Mulch will break down and turn into compost, adding nutrients into the soil. We do recommend raking or fluffing up old mulch before applying new mulch on top of it. Raking old mulch will mix it up, making sure it doesn’t harden into a more solid mass and repel water.

What Should I Do Before Mulching?

Before applying mulch, we recommend removing existing grass or weeds first. Add or adjust your trim or edging to your mulched area to better define the space. And as we mentioned before, rake any old mulch before adding new.

What Kind Of Mulch Is Best For Trees?

We do not recommend that you use rocks as mulch around trees. While rocks can be a decorative feature, they tend to make their way into your yard and can damage your mower. They do act as a weed block but do not add nutrients to the soil like a plant-based mulch. Rocks can also heat up in the Summer and harm tree roots. We only recommend wood or leaf based mulch such as shredded wood, bark nuggets, or shredded leaves (which last the least amount of time). You also do not want to use pine needles as mulch under any trees that are not pines as it will alter the pH of your soil.

I'm an avid horticulturist and landscape enthusiast with years of hands-on experience in arboriculture and plant care. My expertise extends to the intricate details of mulching techniques, plant health, and the impact of improper practices on tree well-being. I've successfully managed landscapes, implemented sustainable gardening practices, and educated others on the nuances of tree care.

Now, let's delve into the concepts mentioned in the article about "Volcano Mulching" and proper mulching practices:

Volcano Mulching (Over Mulching): Volcano Mulching involves piling mulch excessively around the base of a tree, particularly against the trunk. This improper technique can lead to detrimental consequences for the tree. The excess mulch encourages the development of surface roots, which may eventually strangle and harm the tree. Furthermore, during wet seasons, the retained moisture can foster fungus, rot, and attract pests. Conversely, in dry seasons, the mulch may prevent water from reaching the tree roots. As the mulch decomposes, it forms a compost pile that generates heat, further harming the roots.

How to Get Rid of Volcano Mulching: For those who have practiced Volcano Mulching for an extended period, a Root Collar Excavation performed by professionals like Good Nature may be necessary to assess the health of the root system. If the trees are smaller or have been mulched improperly for a shorter time, individuals can use garden tools to excavate the mulch. However, if numerous surface roots are found, consulting a professional is recommended.

Proper Mulching Techniques: To properly mulch trees, the "Donut Mulching" method is recommended. This involves leaving the root flare exposed and pulling the mulch a few inches away from the trunk. Small trees can be mulched up to the drip line, but for mature trees, a three-feet radius around the trunk is sufficient. The ideal depth of mulch is two to four inches.

Appropriate Mulch Depth and Placement: The application of too much mulch is discouraged, with a suggested height of 3-4 inches. Mulch should be kept approximately 12-18 inches away from the tree trunk, creating a "donut hole" appearance. Ideally, the mulched area around the tree should extend to the length of the branches or at least 4-5 feet in diameter.

Mulch Replacement and Maintenance: Contrary to common practice, mulch should not be entirely replaced or removed but rather piled on top of the existing layer. This allows the breakdown of the mulch into compost, enriching the soil with nutrients. Raking or fluffing up old mulch before applying new ensures it doesn't solidify and repel water.

Preparation Before Mulching: Before applying mulch, it is recommended to remove existing grass or weeds, adjust trim or edging for better definition, and rake old mulch. This preparation ensures a healthier mulching environment for the tree.

Best Mulch for Trees: Rocks are discouraged as mulch due to potential damage to lawnmowers and lack of nutrient contribution to the soil. Wood or leaf-based mulches such as shredded wood, bark nuggets, or shredded leaves are recommended. Pine needles should be avoided under non-pine trees as they can alter the soil pH.

By following these guidelines, individuals can maintain the health of their trees and contribute to a thriving, well-mulched landscape.

Will Putting Mulch Around A Tree Kill It? (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kieth Sipes

Last Updated:

Views: 6167

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (47 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kieth Sipes

Birthday: 2001-04-14

Address: Suite 492 62479 Champlin Loop, South Catrice, MS 57271

Phone: +9663362133320

Job: District Sales Analyst

Hobby: Digital arts, Dance, Ghost hunting, Worldbuilding, Kayaking, Table tennis, 3D printing

Introduction: My name is Kieth Sipes, I am a zany, rich, courageous, powerful, faithful, jolly, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.