Why Seeds From Some Trees Pop In High Heat - Bay Nature (2024)

I was standing under a big Monterey Pine on Friday at Stinson Beach when the temperature was 100 degrees. I heard a continuous popping sound, like popcorn…could it have been the cones popping open in the extreme heat? I didn’t see any evidence of seeds drifting down, or cones falling off the tree. — Liz, Oakland

Standing on the back lawn of Tilden Nature Area Environmental Education Center on Labor Day weekend when the temperature soared to 104 degrees, I heard a similar sound coming from the crowns of our nearby Monterey pines. Although you and I didn’t see any seeds falling to the ground accompanying these “pops,” the cones were in fact opening, and the seeds were waiting for their attachment points to dry, which releases them to the wind.

Monterey pine,Pinus radiata,shares an adaptive trait with two other Californian conifers that evolved long ago to live with fire. Rather than opening their cones each year and dropping seeds into a crowded forest understory, these trees keep their cones glued shut with a sticky resin. Seeds can remain stored in these cones for many years, protected from predation or disease, until conditions below the tree become favorable for seed dispersal and germination. Conifers that employ this reproductive strategy are known as “closed-cone,” since their cones neither open nor detach from the tree when the seeds are ripe. The technical term for this ecological adaptation is serotiny.

After a forest fire, the understory is barren, full of freshly available nutrients and ideal for seed germination. Closed-cone pines have evolved to use the heat from a forest fire as a trigger to opening their cones. The extreme heat melts the resinous sap, allowing the cone to open and exposing the seeds to the outside world. The seeds then quickly dry and detach from inside the cone scales and are dispersed by wind, gravity, and wildlife. In contrast, “open cone” conifers rely on ambient moisture inside the cone to hold the seeds in place until weather cues signal that conditions are right for dispersal.

Unlike our other two closed-cone conifers (bishop and knobcone pines), Monterey pine is not strictly dependent on forest fires for cone opening and seed dispersal. Extremely hot weather can also melt the resin and allow the cones to open, permitting a slower drying, detachment, and dispersal of some of the seeds. Cones opened this way can reportedly close again when temperatures drop. Time can take its toll on the serotinous cones as well: the tissues within the cone lose their strength with age and the cones will eventually open unprompted by heat, although this can take over a decade.

Why do Monterey pine need these different ways to open cones and disperse seeds? Think of it as built-in redundancy to give them a better chance at reproducing. While a forest fire creates the ideal conditions for seed dispersal, opening the cones on hot days allows these trees to release small amounts of seeds, slowly replenishing the seed bank and encouraging regeneration without relying on fire as a catalyst. This is fortuitous for a tree whose native range has seen not only a massive decrease in fire frequency over the past hundred years, but also unprecedented high temperatures this summer.

Today, Monterey pine is widely planted for timber, pulp, and aesthetics. It is commonly quoted as being the most widely planted tree in the world. Growing from Australia to Chile, it has vastly outgrown its small native range on the California coast and Baja islands. But its adaptations remain, and on very hot days it may just pop a few cones open and slowly shower us with ripe seeds.

Why Seeds From Some Trees Pop In High Heat - Bay Nature (2)

Ask the Naturalistis a reader-funded bimonthly column with theCalifornia Center for Natural Historythat answers your questions about the natural world of the San Francisco Bay Area. Have a question for the naturalist?Fill out our question formor email us atatn at baynature.org!

Why Seeds From Some Trees Pop In High Heat - Bay Nature (2024)

FAQs

Why Seeds From Some Trees Pop In High Heat - Bay Nature? ›

Closed-cone pines have evolved to use the heat from a forest fire as a trigger to opening their cones. The extreme heat melts the resinous sap, allowing the cone to open and exposing the seeds to the outside world.

What causes the cones from a lodgepole pine tree to drop their seeds? ›

This cone can remain in the tree's branches for decades, until the heat of a passing fire melts the resin that seals it and allows the cone to open, dropping its seeds. To the left is a mature lodgepole pine forest.

Why do pine trees crackle? ›

On sunny winter days, tree bark will warm from solar energy. This causes cells to expand in the bark and the sapwood under the bark. When the sun goes down, the temperature drops very quickly causing the bark to contract. However, the sapwood under the bark doesn't cool as fast, causing the bark to crack.

Can you hear pine cones opening? ›

If you are in luck, you may hear the snapping sound of the cones popping open naturally to release the seeds. Pinecone seeds must be released from their cones before the keys can be transported on the winds. Big Idea: Plants have distinct characteristics.

What pines have serotinous cones? ›

Lodgepole pines, ubiquitous across much of the West, are one of the first species to grow after a fire because of their serotinous cones.

What does it mean when a pine tree has lots of pine cones? ›

Aside from weather-related stresses, botanists have speculated that heavy pinecone production may also be a defense mechanism that the tree uses to prevent insect infestations. Insects prey on the seeds dropped by trees and will “camp out” beside a dubious source of sustenance.

What do pine cone seeds look like? ›

A white pine seed looks a bit like a maple seed lodged inside the cone, with a papery tail extending the length of the scale. This tail acts like a kite. During rainy weather, the moisture-sensitive scales of a pine cone close to keep the seeds dry and protect them from rot.

What does it mean if you hear a tree creaking? ›

Creaking, moaning, or groaning sounds could indicate that your tree is under stress from wind, drought, or disease.

What do open pinecones mean? ›

The inner layers of a pine cone expand like a sponge, causing the scales to close. When the weather is warm, dry, and right for growing, pine cones open their scales to release their seeds. The inner layers of the pine cone shrink, causing the scales to open.

Is it OK to pick up pine cones? ›

Several forest products may be gathered without a permit—pine cones, mushrooms, fruits and nuts—in small quantities and for personal use only.

What temperature do pine cones open? ›

Step 5: Preheat your oven to 200 degrees on a convect setting if you have it. If not, you can raise the temperature to 225 degrees. The pine cones will take several hours to completely dry out and reopen. Just stop by the oven every 45 minutes to an hour to rotate them.

Why do pine cones close when raining? ›

It's simply so that the seeds are free to disperse when conditions are best for winds to carry them far and wide which is when it is dry. Wet weather dampens dispersal and so the cone closes up when wet to protect the seeds.

What is the most fire resistant tree? ›

Yellow pine is the most resistant, followed by sugar pine, white fir and incense cedar, substantially in the same order as for burning down.

What pine cones only open in a fire? ›

The serotinous cone of a lodgepole pine, opened by the flames of the Maple Fire. Lodgepole pine is an evergreen conifer tree that ranges from Alaska to Mexico. Generally, it grows in dry montane and subalpine forests in the Rocky Mountains to near the Pacific Ocean.

Can a burnt tree grow back? ›

A tree that has lost part or all of its leaves or needles because of heat from a fire may or may not recuperate depending on the species and degree of the fire damage. Healthy, deciduous trees can be resilient after being partially burned and may produce new leaves and stems, as well as sprouts at the base of the tree.

Will open the cones of lodgepole pines to release their seeds? ›

But, fire is a part of the lodgepole pine ecosystem. Fire removes old trees, trees affected by insects or disease and opens cones to release seeds for a new forest. Lodgepole pine likes open sunny areas and reseeds quickly in burned-over areas.

How do pine trees drop seeds? ›

After seeds have developed, pine cones open in dry weather, and seeds are dispersed by wind. If you hold a freshly dropped female cone with the pointy bit facing up, you'll see the seeds sitting close to the stem, just above the pine cone scales – those individual woody pieces that give the cone its shape.

What helps lodgepole pines spread their seeds pinecones )? ›

The seeds of many pines come equipped with little wings called samaras, which aid them in their dispersal. Upon maturity, pine cone scales open and release the seeds.

Why do pine cones open and close their seeds? ›

It's simply so that the seeds are free to disperse when conditions are best for winds to carry them far and wide which is when it is dry. Wet weather dampens dispersal and so the cone closes up when wet to protect the seeds.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jerrold Considine

Last Updated:

Views: 5457

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jerrold Considine

Birthday: 1993-11-03

Address: Suite 447 3463 Marybelle Circles, New Marlin, AL 20765

Phone: +5816749283868

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Air sports, Sand art, Electronics, LARPing, Baseball, Book restoration, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Jerrold Considine, I am a combative, cheerful, encouraging, happy, enthusiastic, funny, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.