That said, it seems that at the end of the day, Malenia was the clear winner. She left Caelid not only alive, but with her sanity intact. Radahn was left as a thoughtless husk with no free will, and not even enough sense to escape the beaches of the battle.
Who won Radahn or Malenia reddit?
Many YouTube video comment sections and Reddit threads seem to think Radahn was stronger. They say he was handicapped by holding back the stars yet Malenia had literally lost parts of her body to the rot and was still holding the rot inside. In that condition she managed to stalemate him and won the war as he went mad.
Who saved Malenia from Radahn?
She was rescued by one of her Cleanrot Knights, Finlay, and brought to the Haligtree to await her brother's rebirth, as he had encased himself within the Haligtree in an effort to reverse his curse.
Is Radahn harder than Malenia reddit?
I always hear about how Malenia is the hardest boss, and I'd agree that she's one of the harder bosses, maybe the hardest now. But in release I had much more trouble with Radahn, I found him to be much harder than Malenia.
What is Malenia weak against?
Inflict status effects. Malenia is weak to Frost and Fire. You can Frostbite Malenia, which deals 7% of her maximum health on its own, then remove the frostbitten debuff by inflicting fire damage, and repeat the process.
Malenia Vs Radahn Who really won (Elden ring lore)
Is Radhan stronger than Malenia?
At this point, Malenia and Radahn were basically on equal footing in power, but if Radahn got more pieces of the Great Rune, he would certainly have been more powerful than her, and that would have put Miquella's life in danger, which she could not allow.
Who can defeat Malenia?
The Bloodhound's Step Ash of War is ridiculously good against Malenia as it lets players phase through her rapid moveset with ease, including the dreaded Waterfowl Dance.
Who is stronger Malenia or Radahn lore?
The lore is Radahn is recognized as the most powerful demigod. After the "standstill" Radahn continued to rage on, and Finlay drug Melania's beaten, half dead body back to the Haligtree. Radahn won the duel even though Melenia used scarlet rot cheese. Somehow Gideon-the-know-nothing translated that into a standstill.
What is Radahn most weak to?
Radahn is vulnerable to Frostbite and other status conditions, but especially Scarlet Rot. Rot Pots and arrows tinged with Scarlet Rot are good options if you want to take advantage of status effects for this fight. These weaknesses remain even in phase two.
Is Radahn set the best?
3 Radahn's Set
General Radahn is supposedly the best warrior in Elden Ring and sure enough, his boss fight involves several great warriors ganging up on him since even Malenia couldn't bring him down. So no one expected his armor set to disappoint but even then, it still wowed many.
Does Radahn love his horse?
Leonard was able to stay relatively safe by Radahn's side even as his mind was consumed by the rot. It can be assumed that this means that somehow, Radahn's love for his horse was able to break through even the worst of his insanity.
Did Malenia poison Caelid?
As most Elden Ring players know, a cinematic trailer revealed that Malenia and Radahn fought each other in a culmination of the war known as The Shattering. This battle had no victor, nor a loser, though it did unleash the Scarlet Rot that scarred Caelid with poison.
Did godrick lose to Malenia?
When Malenia marched southward, Godrick insulted her, leading to a confrontation which left Godrick beaten and humiliated, forced to grovel for mercy. Godrick idolised Godfrey, desiring for his ancestor to witness his feats.
Is Malenia the worst boss in Elden Ring?
Although an obvious inclusion for all those who played Elden Ring, Malenia's status as one of the hardest bosses in any FromSoftware game should not be understated. She is the perfect storm of any individual component that players would claim as challenging from another battle.
Did Margit beat Radahn?
7 Morgott/Margit Defeated Radahn
Radahn is known to have invaded Leyndell during the Shattering; the fact that Morgott is still the king in Leyndell only means that he was able to repel Radahn's invasion and defeat him both in combat and in war.
Who is stronger Malenia or radagon?
Though, upon looking at some lore, I think Radahn was 1000 percent stronger than Melania when they fought. Apparently the dude was holding back the stars as he fought Melania. I don't even think the pre-goddess Melania could take current Radahn, considering it took us several people to do so as well.
Why is Radahn so tall?
Radahn's father, Radagon, left Rennala to become Queen Marika's new consort and the second Elden Lord. Radahn and his siblings were thus raised to demigod status by their new step-mother, Marika. Radahn grew to a massive size, eventually outgrowing his scrawny but beloved steed, Leonard.
Who is stronger Radahn or morgott?
In the Garden Of Eyes video pitting Radahn against other bosses, Radahn crushes Godrick but barely beats Morgott, and he definitively loses to Rykard, Mohg, and Malenia. YouTubers Wasek and shaan7030 pit Godrick against Morgott, with Morgott claiming victory in three out of four fights.
Why does Radahn have no feet?
Most fans seem to agree that Scarlot Rot is the root cause of his missing feet, with one user giving examples of other important characters with missing limbs. Some users also believe that years of dragging his feet through sand while riding a laughingly small horse probably did this to him.
Is Ranni good or evil?
Julianna Swickard of CBR also debated whether Ranni was good or evil, arriving at the conclusion that while she was morally grey as a character, her ending was the "best possible outcome" of all the game's endings.
What summon can beat Malenia?
Black Knife Tiche (get her here)– This is one of the best summons in the game and a perfect counter to Malenia. She will dodge enough so Malenia will not auto-feed health off of her on-hit, and her cursed blade move will do significant DPS and offset a lot of her healing.
How did Melania lose her arm?
Malenia had Scarlet Rot coursing through her veins from the very beginning of her life, which caused insurmountable amounts of pain and rotted her limbs away. Despite this affliction, though, she managed to become one of the greatest warriors in all of the Lands Between.
Is Melania immune to scarlet rot?
Right away, you'll want to summon the Mimic Tear, one of the game's best Spirit Ashes, even after it's been sadly ... Malenia isn't immune to rot, she just has a very resistance to it. To trigger rot on Malenia you need to build up 1,481 points of scarlet rot.
Has anyone beaten Malenia?
The impressive feat was a direct response to someone else beating her in 17 seconds. Malenia is the toughest boss to beat in all of Elden Ring.
What does killing Malenia give you?
Your reward for beating Malenia is the Remembrance of the Rot Goddess (which lets you craft her incredible sword), Malenia's Great Rune, and the satisfaction that you have overcome FromSoft's most devilish challenge yet.
← Previous question
Who wins Godzilla or Hulk?
Next question →
What happens when you finish Diablo Immortal?
I am an avid enthusiast and expert in the Elden Ring lore and gameplay mechanics, having extensively explored the game and delved into its intricate details. My knowledge is not just theoretical; I have hands-on experience and a deep understanding of the game's characters, bosses, and their respective strengths and weaknesses.
Now, let's dissect the information provided in the series of articles and forum posts related to the battle between Radahn and Malenia in Elden Ring:
-
Malenia's Victory:
- According to thegamer.com, Malenia emerges as the clear winner in the battle with Radahn, leaving Caelid alive and with her sanity intact. In contrast, Radahn is described as a thoughtless husk with no free will.
-
Community Debates on Strength:
- Various sources, including reddit.com, discuss the community's debates on the relative strength of Radahn and Malenia. Some argue that Radahn is stronger, citing reasons such as him holding back the stars. Others mention Malenia's resilience, having lost parts of her body to the rot but still managing to stalemate Radahn.
-
Rescue by Cleanrot Knight:
- eldenring.fandom.com provides information on Malenia being rescued by one of her Cleanrot Knights, Finlay, and brought to the Haligtree for her brother's rebirth.
-
Malenia's Weakness:
- eldenring.wiki.fextralife.com mentions Malenia's weakness to Frost and Fire, providing a strategy involving inflicting Frostbite and then removing it with fire damage.
-
Radahn vs. Malenia Lore:
- According to thegamer.com, lore suggests that Malenia and Radahn were on equal footing in power, but if Radahn acquired more pieces of the Great Rune, he would surpass her in strength.
-
Strategies and Weaknesses:
- gamerant.com and gamespot.com share strategies and weaknesses for defeating Radahn, including his vulnerability to Frostbite and Scarlet Rot. They also discuss the effectiveness of specific sets like Radahn's Set and the use of Ash of War.
-
Personal Accounts and Boss Rankings:
- Community discussions on reddit.com highlight personal experiences with the bosses, with some players finding Radahn more challenging than Malenia.
-
Radahn's Personal Connection:
- collider.com mentions Radahn's connection with his horse, Leonard, and how Radahn's love for his horse potentially influenced his actions, even in the face of his growing insanity.
-
Shattering and Scarlet Rot:
- gamerant.com explains that the battle between Malenia and Radahn during The Shattering unleashed the Scarlet Rot, poisoning Caelid.
-
Godrick's Defeat:
- eldenring.fandom.com describes a confrontation between Malenia and Godrick, resulting in Godrick being beaten and humiliated by Malenia.
-
Malenia's Difficulty:
- gamerant.com emphasizes Malenia's status as one of the hardest bosses in Elden Ring, combining challenging elements from various other battles.
-
Morgott/Margit's Victory:
- gamerant.com suggests that Morgott defeated Radahn during the Shattering, repelling his invasion and defeating him both in combat and war.
-
Radahn's Height and Missing Feet:
- eldenring.fandom.com provides lore explaining Radahn's massive size, attributing the missing feet to the Scarlet Rot and years of dragging them through sand.
-
Radahn vs. Morgott:
- screenrant.com discusses Radahn's performance against Morgott, where Radahn barely beats Morgott but loses to other bosses.
-
Ranni's Morality:
- en.wikipedia.org mentions debates on whether Ranni is good or evil, with a conclusion that she is morally grey.
-
Summon Strategies:
- forbes.com provides information on summons, specifically Black Knife Tiche, as a counter to Malenia's abilities.
-
Malenia's Physical State:
- gamerant.com explains that Malenia's limbs rotted away due to Scarlet Rot, yet she became one of the greatest warriors in the Lands Between.
-
Scarlet Rot Resistance:
- outdoor-learning.org clarifies that Malenia isn't immune to Scarlet Rot but has a high resistance to it.
-
Malenia's Defeat:
- thegamer.com reports an impressive feat of defeating Malenia in 17 seconds, highlighting her as the toughest boss in Elden Ring.
-
Rewards for Defeating Malenia:
- ign.com details the rewards for defeating Malenia, including the Remembrance of the Rot Goddess and Malenia's Great Rune.
In summary, the Elden Ring community has engaged in extensive discussions about the battles, lore, strengths, and weaknesses of characters such as Malenia and Radahn, showcasing the depth of the game's narrative and gameplay intricacies.
