What is the difference between proprietary trading and modern prop trading? (2024)

The term proprietary trading has been historically used to refer to the practice of a bank or other financial institution investing on behalf of its own account, with its own funds. Today, a different alternative, a “modern” form of prop trading is becoming increasingly common.

Traditional proprietary trading is a very interesting way for financial institutions to increase their profits and achieve much higher returns compared to only trading commissions for clients. Although the 2007 - 2008 financial crisis has seen a significant reduction in proprietary trading opportunities, particularly for banks, it is still a relatively profitable activity that generates substantial profits for companies.

Tempting offer

Equally, it is still an attractive opportunity for traders who want to operate in the financial market and do not have access to their own substantial capital amounts. The prospect of a big company, the ability to trade with really large amounts of money and access to tools and information, that an average trader has no chance of accessing, is appealing to many potential traders. However, because it is a highly competitive and profit-driven environment, it is not easy to get a job at a proprietary trading firm. Firms have relatively high expectations of their potential candidates.

What is the difference between proprietary trading and modern prop trading? (1)

Nothing comes for free

Investment companies that use proprietary trading methods will not and cannot provide money for trading to just anyone. Since the financial market is quite heavily regulated today, institution often impose very strict requirements on employees who execute trades on their behalf. Such employees often have to pass tests to obtain certain certifications, have to possess higher education or undertake psychology testing. Without fulfilling these requirements, which are not easy to pass and may even cost a considerable amount of money, a potential trader cannot practice as a trader in a proprietary trading firm.

In addition, applicants for a trader position must have a certain history or should be able to demonstrate a track record of trading. In the financial market, profits come first and firms are generally not very interested in people who do not have trading experience. If a trader is able to demonstrate a long enough history of good trading results, they may be of interest to a trading firm.

The demands are high

In addition, firms require their candidates to have a fairly broad knowledge of how financial markets operate, as well as mathematics, statistics, probability theory and many other disciplines that are not at first glance relate to trading. Many proprietary trading firms today use complex strategies and approaches that may not suit every trader.

Nor does the mere acceptance of a proprietary trader’s position necessarily mean that the trader has won. It is a highly competitive environment where only success is judged. The trader has to deal with a stressful environment and has to take into account that, especially at the beginning, it can be very difficult for him. Traders in firms are evaluated by results, and the split of profits between the trader and the firm can be quite unfavourable for the trader, so it may happen that the trader ends the month with earnings which are below average.

Modern prop trading

An interesting alternative to classic proprietary trading is the recent offer of prop trading firms, including FTMO. These firms offer potential traders the opportunity to find out whether they have what it takes to become a real trader, but without some of the restrictions we mentioned above.

Modern prop firms are companies which goal is to find aspiring traders and provide them with the tools, education and the environment to experiment with their trading abilities.

For this purpose, modern prop firms each have developed their own way to objectively identify and educate potential traders in the ranks of those interested in trading, without the risk of financial loss on the part of clients. During this course clients get access to online training programs, analytical applications and an online platform that allows simulated trading in various financial instruments. This helps prop firms identify clients with the best potential for trading in real markets.

With a prop trading firm such as FTMO, all a client needs to do is sign up, try the Evaluation Course and the client can start experimenting with trading with the desired fictional account size. There is no need to document any trading history, only the actual results are important.

A lot of music for a little money

It is not free here either, of course, but the conditions are clear to all in advance and relatively simple. The client will pay a small fee, which will be refundedin case of first payout if he or she manages to meet the conditions of the Evaluation Course.

What is the difference between proprietary trading and modern prop trading? (3)

The biggest benefit for the client is, of course, the ability to try out trading without the risk of actual losses and with various account sizes. With FTMO account, the clients have up to $200,000 fictional capital at their disposal to experiment with, which is already a sum with which an actual trader could earn very good money each month.

Freedom to trade

A big advantage for most clients is the independence that using a prop trading firm offers them. No specific trading strategies are required from clients when using a prop trading firm and client can also use automated trading systems. Of course, there is also a fairly wide selection of trading instruments to choose from on the demo account. For many aspiring traders, the fact that they can try what it feels like to trade from anywhere is also an advantage.

The main condition a client has to watch out for is the risk management and Trading Objectives in the form of Maximum Loss and Maximum Daily Loss. These conditions force clients to use FTMO services responsibly and help them in improving discipline, which is also very important for consistent trading.

In addition, at FTMO, the client receives very good services in the form of customer support in up to 18 languages. Since we know that psychology is very important in trading, we also offer our clients in the FTMO Account stage services of a performance psychologist who can help them achieve even better results.

What is the difference between proprietary trading and modern prop trading? (2024)

FAQs

What is modern prop trading? ›

Modern prop trading is a company model that offers traders the opportunity to trade in accounts with large capital (belonging to the company) and share any profits.

What is the difference between proprietary trading and speculative trading? ›

We identify two types of traders: 1) speculators, sometimes referred to as proprietary traders, who earn money trying to anticipate the direction of future price movements; and 2) customer-based traders, usually called market makers, who earn money on the bid-ask spread without speculating on future prices.

What is the difference between proprietary trading and trading? ›

Prop firms specialize in trading strategies and financial instruments such as equities, commodities, or options. On the other hand, traditional trading pertains to traders who trade using their capital. These traders can be individuals operating from home or professionals working in institutions or hedge funds.

What is considered proprietary trading? ›

Proprietary trading, or “prop trading,” occurs when a financial firm or commercial bank uses its own money — and not that of its clients — to trade stocks, bonds, mutual funds or other securities. In other words, the firm puts up their own funds to earn a profit instead of relying on client fees and commissions.

Why is prop trading illegal? ›

The Volcker Rule is one of the more controversial pieces of legislation to emerge from the financial crisis. Attached to the Dodd-Frank Act, the rule was intended to limit banks' ability to make speculative investments that do not benefit their customers.

What are the downsides of prop trading? ›

Losses negatively impact a trader's profit-sharing agreement and, in extreme cases, result in the termination of trading privileges. Financial loss – the deposit of prop traders is not insured and may be exposed to fraud and other business risks.

Why is FTMO the best prop firm? ›

They offer traders the opportunity to trade with their own capital, as well as access to additional capital from FTMO. This means that traders can potentially earn higher profits while still having the support and resources of a prop firm. Additionally, FTMO offers flexible profit splits for their traders.

Do banks still do prop trading? ›

Since the 2008 financial crisis, that has become somewhat less true. In the US, proprietary trading, as a business for big banks, has been more or less outlawed for a decade by the Volcker Rule.

Do I need a license to prop trade? ›

Do proprietary trading firms need a license? Prop trading firms are less heavily regulated than regular brokerages and broker-dealers. However, if such laws apply, you must still properly register your business and get licensed.

Which prop firm is the best? ›

The most popular prop trading firms and funded programmes
  • Axi Select.
  • FTMO.
  • The Forex Funder.
  • E8 Markets.
  • True Forex Funds.
  • The 5%ers.
  • Funded Next.

Is proprietary trading risky? ›

Although commonly viewed as risky, proprietary trading is often one of the most profitable operations of a commercial or investment bank.

What is similar to FTMO prop trading? ›

FunderPro: FunderPro is the most popular alternative to FTMO. It has a similar two-step challenge process, but the requirements are slightly more lenient. For example, the FunderPro Challenge requires a 10% profit target in 30 days, while the FTMO Challenge requires a 12% profit target.

Is proprietary trading legal in the USA? ›

Prop trading operates within a complex legal and regulatory framework. Key to understanding this is the Volcker Rule, part of the 2010 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. This rule significantly restricts banks from engaging in proprietary trading.

How do proprietary traders get paid? ›

Prop traders make all or most of their income from splitting profits they generate in financial markets with the prop firm that provides them with capital. Prop traders face the same challenges as other traders but benefit from access to capital, technology, and interaction with other skilled traders.

How much money do you need to start a prop firm? ›

To summarize, the amount of money you need to open a prop firm can range from $10,000 to $1 million, depending on the type of prop firm, the technology, the registration, the liquidity, and the CRM tool.

What is prop trading and how does it work? ›

Proprietary trading occurs when a financial institution trades financial instruments using its own money rather than client funds. This allows the firm to maintain the full amount of any gains earned on the investment, potentially providing a significant boost to the firm's profits.

Is prop trading a good idea? ›

While prop trading is one of the most profitable opportunities, it is affected by asymmetric risk. This means that the profit-sharing ratio may be from 75% to 90%, but you bear 100% of the risk of your trades. When becoming a prop trader, you often need to deposit an amount of money known as your risk contribution.

Do prop traders make money? ›

Prop traders make all or most of their income from splitting profits they generate in financial markets with the prop firm that provides them with capital.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jeremiah Abshire

Last Updated:

Views: 6092

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jeremiah Abshire

Birthday: 1993-09-14

Address: Apt. 425 92748 Jannie Centers, Port Nikitaville, VT 82110

Phone: +8096210939894

Job: Lead Healthcare Manager

Hobby: Watching movies, Watching movies, Knapping, LARPing, Coffee roasting, Lacemaking, Gaming

Introduction: My name is Jeremiah Abshire, I am a outstanding, kind, clever, hilarious, curious, hilarious, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.