What is Renters Insurance, and Do You Need It in New York City? (2024)

Choosing whether or not to purchase renters insurance in New York City is a hugely personal decision. You should consider factors such as your budget, belongings, and individual risk tolerance. The terms of your lease can also dictate your decision to opt for coverage: while some landlords require tenants to purchase renters insurance before move-in, others do not. And don’t even get us started on weather and environmental considerations! To help you decide, we put together this handy guide. Read on to learn the ins and outs of renters insurance in NYC.

What is renters insurance?

Renters insurance is a protective policy that ensures monetary support and reimbursem*nt to renters who experience certain covered perils in their rental property. Possible examples of these covered perils include theft, vandalism, smoke, fire, explosions, or other unexpected damaging events, such as plumbing failures, certain weather events, and accidents. Renters insurance can be paid annually, semi-annually, or monthly, depending on the specific policy.

What does renters insurance cover?

Should you experience a covered peril in your rental property, renters insurance can provide monetary support to help replace your personal property, reimburse living expenses, and cover personal liability charges.

Personal property

In general, these are the types of personal property that can be replaced via a renters insurance policy:

• Furniture
• Clothing and accessories
• Bedding, towels, pillows, and other soft goods
• Electronics
• Appliances and kitchen gadgets
• Recreational equipment, such as bicycles, treadmills, and other exercise tools
• Artwork
• Other home goods, such as books and decorative items

Living expenses

If your apartment becomes uninhabitable due to a covered peril, renters insurance can reimburse the costs associated with living elsewhere while you’re waiting for the damage to be fixed in your rental home. Be sure to save all receipts for your accommodations, meals, and transportation during this time.

Personal liability

Renters insurance can provide monetary support in the unfortunate event that someone sustains an injury in your apartment. Eligible expenses could include medical bills, hospital visits, and ambulance rides. A policy can also potentially help with repairs and/or reimbursem*nt to a visitor’s personal belongings that are accidentally damaged inside your home. Legal fees and settlement costs may also be covered should someone sue you for damages arising out of use of the apartment.

What does renters insurance NOT cover?

Certain renters insurance policies may include pet damages under the banner of personal liability. This would be helpful should your pet chew on your friend’s couch leg or otherwise damage someone else’s property. However, it does not encompass any damages your furry friend may inflict upon your own rental. Additionally, while some renters insurance policies can cover dog bites, certain breeds are explicitly exempt.

While windstorms and lightning are often considered covered perils in renters insurance policies, other natural disasters — such as floods or earthquakes — are not. You might want to consider signing up for supplemental insurance if you live in an area that’s prone to these events. More on this below.

Finding the right policy for you — and your budget

If you do decide to sign up for a renters insurance policy, there are plenty of affordable options out there. Some of the most popular companies that offer renters insurance in NYC include Lemonade, Geico, Allstate, Progressive, Nationwide, and Travelers. Many of these companies offer free quotes upon completion of a short home survey.

Another way to potentially save when signing up for renters insurance: check with providers of any other type of insurance you have, and see if there are incentives or discounts for bundling multiple policies. For example, if you have auto insurance through State Farm, you could contact an agent and see what it would cost you to add renters insurance to your existing account.

Other types of specialty insurance to consider in NYC

Here are some other types of insurance that New Yorkers in particular may want to consider.

Flood insurance

As mentioned, damage caused by flooding is not covered in standard renters insurance policies. Purchasing extra coverage may prove beneficial in the event of flooding from large-scale rainstorms and hurricanes. According to the NYC Department of City Planning, New York City is “highly vulnerable to flooding from coastal storms due to its intensively used waterfront and its extensive coastal geography.” Pro tip: You can check the NYC Flood Hazard Map to assess your personal risk by borough and neighborhood.

Jewelry and personal valuables insurance

While valuables are technically covered under a renters insurance policy, there’s often a monetary limit determined at the time of your signing. Supplemental policies may be advisable if you keep highly valuable items in your apartment — such as jewelry, family heirlooms, furs, or fine art — that are worth more than your coverage ceiling.

So, do you need renters insurance in NYC?

Renters insurance can be a good idea, but some people still may choose to forgo it. Even if you don’t own a lot of expensive possessions and feel secure in your home, you may value the peace of mind that renters insurance can provide. Or, you may not — everyone has a different threshold for risk. Renters insurance is not required by law in New York City, thus the decision to sign up for a policy is purely voluntary, to be discussed with your roommates, partners, or landlords.

^{Disclaimer: This content is not intended to provide legal, financial, or real estate advice. It is for information purposes only, and any links provided are for the users’ convenience. Please seek the services of a legal, accounting, or real estate professional before any real estate transaction.}

^{Any product names, logos, brands, and other trademarks referred to herein are the property of their respective trademark holders. These trademark holders are not affiliated with Zillow Group and nothing herein shall be construed to reflect any sort of endorsem*nt, sponsorship, or partnership.}