What Is Gift Guilt and How to Deal With It? - Rebi Simple Living (2024)

With the holiday season approaching gift guilt becomes a regular occurrence in our lives. It is too bad that gift guilt is not widely discussed, since it impacts a lot of people.

In this article, I want to shed a light on different aspects of this phenomenon and give you tips on how to deal with gift-receiving and gift-giving anxiety.

Jump Through Article

What Is Gift Guilt?

Guilt is a negative emotion that one experiences because they are convinced they have caused harm to the other.

Related to this, gift guilt occurs when we feel we didn’t deserve a received gift or we didn’t give a good enough gift.

How to Recognize Guilt?

Guilt sometimes manifests itself in physical symptoms such as insomnia, digestive issues, stomach pain, muscle tension, head pain, and/or tearfulness. Those symptoms easily resolve themselves when you deal with the issue that is causing a feeling of guilt.

This feeling can happen on many different occasions in your everyday life and to help you cope with these situations we have compiled a comprehensive guide containing different sorts of problems and solutions to them.

This article will talk about two types of gift guilt separately so in order to read about the type that applies to you click on the appropriate link below.

  1. Gift Receiving Anxiety
  2. Gift Giving Anxiety

You Feel Uncomfortable Receiving Gifts (Gift Receiving Anxiety)

From an early age, we are taught to feel grateful when we receive a gift. We also are expected to give something in return in the future.

Thus we are conditioned to feel like we owe something to a person that has done something good for us. This often leads to a feeling of guilt if we don’t manage to return a favor.

You really shouldn’t feel bad in these situations, because most often the other person doesn’t expect anything in return and is doing this just to make you feel good.

This is exactly how you should feel – happy and good!

To clarify this, let’s take a look at an example:

You are meeting Emily for a coffee. Emily is an acquaintance from your previous job that you stayed in touch with but are not close to. Emily comes to your meeting bringing a gift (a candle and some chocolates) because she remembered that you recently had a birthday. You thank her for this gift but feel uneasy because you didn’t expect it. You were never that type of friends to give gifts to each other and now you feel the pressure to remember her birthday, meet with her for that occasion, and buy her a gift. This is a textbook example of gift guilt. Emily is probably just being polite and is happy to see you after a long while. Enjoy the coffee and let go of the guilt.

Most people like the act of giving by itself. They love to shop for a gift, wrap it up, and see the smile on other person’s face when opening it. They are doing it just to be nice, and the fact that you have trouble receiving a gift might be in your self-esteem.

Why Do You Have Trouble Receiving Gifts?

Sometimes the problem lies in your self-esteem. You feel like you don’t deserve this gift. If that’s the case you should start to work towards a more positive self-image.

The bigger problem is when gift-receiving leaves you with the feeling of owing. You feel you have to reciprocate the gift, but don’t want to. The solution for this can only be in open communication but more about this later in the article.

How to Accept an Unexpected Gift

If you find yourself in a situation when you have to receive an unexpected gift, simply say thank you.

There is no other way to be polite.

Don’t mention things like you didn’t give them anything or that they spent a lot of money on the gift. Just be happy and enjoy the time with them.

By giving thanks you show the other person respect and acknowledge their effort.

This is all they wish for really.

How to Refuse a Gift Without Gift Guilt

The bad news is there is no way to politely refuse a gift at the time of receiving a gift.

But the good news is that by open communication you can refuse all the future gifts from that person.

If you don’t want to get any more presents from that person in the future you should talk to them in private.

Explain that you really appreciate the time you spend with them and that is something you value more than receiving gifts.

If you are on your minimalist and declutter journey, clarify that.

Try to reach a mutual understanding of what it is you want to receive and give in the future. If that is just time, ask for that. If you feel like gift cards are a better solution for presents, share that with them.

The best way is to be respectful, open, and understanding.

Letting Go Off Gifts

We tend to hold on to gifts we don’t like especially because of gift guilt.

This causes us to have homes full of stuff we don’t want because we don’t want to appear ungrateful.

Don’t feel bad if you want to declutter gifts you don’t like!

Marie Kondo, the queen of decluttering, says this:

“The true purpose of a present is to be received, because gifts are a means of conveying someone’s feelings for you. When viewed from this perspective, there is no need to feel guilty about parting with a gift that ultimately doesn’t spark joy.”

The received gift has already fulfilled its purpose.

There is always an option to find another person who might need or want that item to pass it onto them.

Your Opinion Shouldn’t Cause Gift Guilt

I have to put this here for all times. Don’t feel guilty or bad if you don’t like the present you receive!

Your opinion means something. If you receive a gift that is not to your taste don’t hold on to it just because of gift guilt. Pass it on to somebody else who will appreciate it more.

There is no use in holding on to stuff you will never use. This is how you end up with a cluttered home overfilled with stuff.

Gift Giving Just for the Purpose of Gift Giving

I know that I mentioned that most people like to give gifts to make somebody happy.

However, some people give gifts just for the purpose of gift-giving. These are people who either have gift guilt or want to get rid of a received gift they don’t like.

You will instantly recognize those gifts because they will be something opposite of what you like. Imagine if you receive a bag of coffee and you never drink coffee!

You will politely accept this gift in these instances, but please don’t continue this circle of guilt!

There is absolutely no need for you to return the gift in the future, especially if that person is not close to you.

If it is, give them a meaningful gift they will like, and maybe that will teach them a lesson.

The Stress of Gift Giving (Gift Giving Anxiety)

This one is familiar to all of us, I think.

Holidays are approaching and you have no idea where to start on planning the perfect gifts for your close ones.

Some plan months in advance what they will give for Christmas! Do you really want to live with that kind of pressure?

The point of holidays, and any other important days, is not in the gift-giving. It is in the time you spend together, the joy, the experience. For some, it is also of great religious importance.

Read on to find tips on how to manage gift-giving anxiety.

Gift Giving Expectations

I already covered this one in the Gift Receiving Anxiety part, but I will touch on it also here.

You feel obliged to give a gift to someone. This is more of a chore for you than a joy.

The best example of this is when you are given a present by someone who is not close to you and you feel you owe them to return the favor.

Unfortunately, there are societal expectations to give gifts to acquaintances such as co-workers, relatives, your partner’s friends and family, etc.

This phenomenon is based on tradition and it is often hard to fulfill all of the expectations on a daily basis.

Gift-giving requires time and money which you might not always have. It is best to mutually come to an agreement that gifts come with no strings attached.

Is Your Gift Good Enough?

Sometimes you might feel like you didn’t spend enough money on gifts. Or you think you should have bought more presents.

More physical things cannot be an excuse for what you really want to give more of. More time, more laughter, more happy memories.

This is a special type of gift guilt and is especially common among parents.

You have to remind yourself that you are doing the best that you could and that MORE is not a gift.

Give your children (or anybody else) the most important gift. The real and present you. Give them your full attention, your happy self, and it will always mean more than better toys!

RELATED ARTICLE:

Reduce Your Gift Giving List

Reduce the number of people on your gift-giving list. Keep only the people who are the closest to you, who you deeply appreciate in your life.

The number of people on this list is individual to your circ*mstances.

Maybe you have a bigger family or bigger gift-giving budget so your list will be longer. Or you only have few closest people and decide you will only give gifts to them.

Have difficult conversations with the people you want to remove from the list.

Come to a mutual understanding. Sometimes it won’t go according to your plan, but it is important to focus on your end goal. It is to keep to your budget and reduce stress and gift-giving anxiety.

Remember you want to keep your life simple, not make it more complicated.

RELATED ARTICLE: 55 Amazing Christmas Gifts for Minimalists: Gift Guide

How to Choose an Appropriate Gift

Even after reducing the list and having those difficult conversations, sometimes you end up in situations where you have to give gifts.

How to choose an appropriate gift then?

  • Determine a spending limit.
  • Agree beforehand on what to give to each other.

If you plan on buying something pricey, see if you can organize it as a group gift. Ask other people if they want to participate in buying that gift with you.

You can also organize a Secret Santa gift exchange in bigger groups. In that way everyone gets something and nobody breaks the bank.

Buy something people will actually use in their everyday life.

If you need ideas on what to give find our list below!

Please note that this article contains affiliate links, and that means that I may earn a small commission if you buy something at no additional cost to you. Read my full disclosure here.

Ideas for Useful Presents

Here you can find some ideas for useful and more sustainable presents. I also compiled a gift guide for minimalists packed with great ideas for presents.

  • Gift cards – similar to money, but less controversial. If you don’t like the idea of giving money, gift cards for their favorite store are always a good idea.
  • Food and drinks – good chocolate, fine wine, everybody loves that, right? And you know that it won’t go to waste! My favorite chocolates are Ferrero Rocher, have you tried them?
  • Subscription boxes – help them start a new hobby! Green Craft Subscription Box for Kids, Self-Care Book Box, and Succulents Box are just some great examples of the subscription boxes available.
  • DIY gift – if you feel creative you can always opt-in for making a gift on your own. Here is a tutorial for a plant terrarium, something I enjoy creating for my friends.
  • Flowers – they smell nice, are a beautiful decoration, and don’t cost much.
  • Ask them! – Do you know how you will never be wrong? Simply ask them what they want. Most of the time your close ones will share what they want or need. This is my favorite way of handling my gift-giving anxiety!

Looking for perfect non-clutter gifts for your kids? Check out the gift guide 23 Minimalist Gifts for Kids of Different Ages!

Pin for later:

What Is Gift Guilt and How to Deal With It? - Rebi Simple Living (1)

Get Rid Of Gift Guilt for Good

Here are the main takeaways from this article:

  • Have open conversations
  • Agree that gifts come with no strings attached
  • Don’t feel guilty when decluttering gifts
  • Give simple and useful gifts
  • Determine a spending limit
  • Reduce your list
  • Give your time and energy not things
  • You are enough
  • Your opinion is valuable

Have you ever felt the feeling of gift guilt? Share with us your experience in the comments!

Did you enjoy this post? Know someone else who might like it? Please take a moment to share on Pinterest, Facebook or Twitter. Thank you!

Posted By: Rebecca · In: Minimalism

What Is Gift Guilt and How to Deal With It? - Rebi Simple Living (2024)

FAQs

What is gift guilt? ›

Guilt is a negative emotion that one experiences because they are convinced they have caused harm to the other. Related to this, gift guilt occurs when we feel we didn't deserve a received gift or we didn't give a good enough gift.

Why do I feel guilty getting gifts? ›

Most commonly, experiences of gift guilt occur when: You are unexpectedly receiving a gift, thus were not prepared for reciprocation. You aren't particularly fond of the gift you've received. You feel indebted to the person (often seen in situations where the gift has a higher value, whether monetary or otherwise).

What do you do when someone gives you a gift? ›

If you are presented with the gift in person, smile and thank the gift giver. If you receive a gift by mail, call the gift giver as soon as you can to alert them that the gift has arrived. You should also send hand-written thank-you notes whenever possible.

How can I get better at receiving gifts? ›

How to Accept a Gift
  1. Think About the Gift Giver First. One way we can really focus on being authentic when receiving a gift is thinking about who is giving us the present. ...
  2. Don't be Self Deprecating. ...
  3. Don't Fib. ...
  4. When to Open. ...
  5. Cash/Check or Gift Card.
15 Dec 2021

Do people give gifts out of guilt? ›

It is not uncommon for people to give gifts as substitutions for their time and presence. Parents, especially divorced ones, may buy extravagant gifts for their children because they feel guilty they're not spending more time with them.

What are the types of guilt? ›

There are three basic kinds of guilt: (1) natural guilt, or remorse over something you did or failed to do; (2) free-floating, or toxic, guilt—the underlying sense of not being a good person; and (3) existential guilt, the negative feeling that arises out of the injustice you perceive in the world, and out of your own ...

How do you deal with feeling guilty about everything? ›

How to stop feeling guilty all the time
  1. Identify your triggers for guilt. Figuring out when you feel guilty and why can help give you some clarity. ...
  2. Practice self-awareness. ...
  3. Write it out. ...
  4. Talk it out. ...
  5. Practice self-compassion. ...
  6. Learn from your mistakes.

How do I stop feeling guilty for small things? ›

Here's how to overcome guilt and start practicing acceptance of yourself and others.
  1. Identify your feelings. Guilt is often a mask for other feelings, like inadequacy, low self-esteem or even jealousy or resentment. ...
  2. Forgive yourself. ...
  3. Change your self-talk. ...
  4. Seek objectivity. ...
  5. Take action. ...
  6. Learn from your mistakes.

Why do I feel guilty about good things? ›

'” Happiness guilt can occur if, like Cadet, you've gone through both positive and negative experiences, and are struggling to balance your joy with your grief. But even if nothing great has happened to you, you may feel guilty if nothing really bad has occurred in your life this year either.

Why is gift-giving important? ›

We often give gifts to re-confirm or establish our connection with others, which means that they're a reflection of both the giver and the receiver, as well as their unique relationship. Giving a gift to someone we care about allows us to communicate our feelings and appreciation for them.

Is gift-giving an act of love? ›

For people with gifts as a love language, the act of giving a gift serves as a gesture of affection and care because it shows the person was thinking about you while you weren't around and wanted to find a way to make you smile. The gift also becomes a physical token memorializing a moment, experience, or feeling.

Is gift-giving a love? ›

In general, it means that you feel the best and most loved when you're giving and receiving gifts. “If your primary love language is gift-giving, it means that you express your love by giving others presents,” Guerra says. “The gift is an overt demonstration of your love and appreciation for the person receiving it.”

What makes gift giving difficult? ›

“One of the central challenges in gift giving is that you are trying to get something that's ideal for another person, and what seems ideal to you — what's going on in your mind as a gift giver — might be quite a bit different from a gift receiver,” said Nicholas Epley, a behavioral science professor and the director ...

Why is it difficult to accept gifts? ›

Why is that? A hurt or a pain from the past makes it difficult to receive a gift -- whether it's a compliment or a present. A person who has trouble receiving a gift has likely been betrayed, struggles to feel worthy of someone's goodness, or they don't want to feel like they're a burden and owe someone a favor.

Why is gift giving difficult? ›

Key points. Gift giving can detract from the pleasure of togetherness during holidays. Gift giving can be used unintentionally to create pressure and competition between givers and receivers. Gift giving can cause disappointment and hurt feelings in either the giver or the receiver.

Does giving gifts make you happy? ›

Releases Endorphins

We tend to feel a greater sense of happiness when we see the recipient gleam with joy as they open our gift. This releases endorphins into our brain which gives us the same euphoric feelings we experience when we are falling for someone or achieving something great.

Can others make you feel guilty? ›

We often think that others are responsible for making us feel guilty. This is not true. Others may try to manipulate us by saying certain things to make us feel guilty and at times they are very effective in causing us self-doubt.

What causes guilt? ›

In its true sense, guilt is a feeling of remorse or sadness over a past action, experienced when we think we've caused harm or breached our moral code. It's our moral compass. Our values and how we process our emotions will all inform the way we react to certain situations.

What is guilt example? ›

For example, a child may feel guilty for eating the last cookie on a plate because they knew their sibling wanted it. On the other hand, the child may feel shame, or ashamed of themselves, for taking that cookie because they believe that they are a "bad" person for doing so.

How does guilt affect your life? ›

Guilt and shame can lead to depression, anxiety, and paranoia, but they also nudge us to behave better, says Sznycer. “When we act in a way we are not proud of, the brain broadcasts a signal that prompts us to alter our conduct.”

How do I stop living with guilt? ›

10 tips to stop feeling guilty
  1. Acknowledge it exists. ...
  2. Eliminate negative self-talk. ...
  3. Find out if there's a reason to feel guilty. ...
  4. Remind yourself of all that you do. ...
  5. Realize it's OK to have needs. ...
  6. Establish boundaries. ...
  7. Make amends. ...
  8. Understand what you can control.

How do you let go of shame and guilt? ›

Steps to Letting Go of Guilt and Shame
  1. Take ownership of your part in the situation. ...
  2. Manage your expectations of yourself. ...
  3. Are you taking responsibility for others' feelings? ...
  4. Make amends. ...
  5. Forgive yourself. ...
  6. Identify the way in which you have INTERPRETED the situation.
25 May 2016

Why do I feel guilty for living a good life? ›

You Worry Success Came Too Easily

But sometimes, we get lucky, and we find success before many years of hard work have passed. This can lead to feelings of guilt, because you might worry that you did not put in enough time or effort to be deserving of the success you've achieved.

What is the true meaning of a gift? ›

The actual definition of a 'gift' is the transfer of something without the expectation of payment. Although gift-giving might involve an expectation of reciprocity, a gift is meant to be free.

How important are gifts in a relationship? ›

A gift isn't just a normal thing sometimes it creates the bond the feeling which a person wants to keep it is as a memory. A genuine way of appreciating your partner your relations is a sweet gesture to make or have a smile on their face a gift is the sweetest thing or a memory you can give to your partner.

How do I stop excessive gift-giving? ›

4 Tips to Getting Family to Stop Giving Too Many Christmas Presents
  1. DON'T WAIT UNTIL DECEMBER! I feel like I need to say that again. ...
  2. It Starts With You Friend. You have to make a dramatic shift in the way you purchase for your own children first. ...
  3. Allow For a Gradual Approach. ...
  4. Offer Proof of Joy. ...
  5. Companion Gifts.
26 Sept 2019

What are the four types of gift? ›

Parents pledge to give their offspring just four presents: Something they want, something they need, something to wear and something to read.

Does everyone have a gift in life? ›

Everyone has a gift, but not every person recognizes what his or her gift is. Being able to identify it is the key to fulfilling the unique purpose of your life. However, don't confuse a gift with talent. Anyone can learn a talent, but a gift is something you're born with.

How many gifts do you get from true love? ›

Typically at the end of the 12 days, you would have received 12 partridges in pear trees, 22 turtle doves, 30 French hens, 36 calling birds, 40 gold rings, 42 geese laying eggs, 42 swans, 40 milking maids, 36 dancing ladies, 30 leaping lords, 22 piping pipers and 12 drumming drummers from your true love, but with the ...

Can someone love without giving? ›

“You can give without loving, but you can never love without giving. The great acts of love are done by those who are habitually performing small acts of kindness. We pardon to the extent that we love. Love is knowing that even when you are alone, you will never be lonely again.

What are the three stages of gift-giving? ›

According to this model, the gift-giving process has three stages -- gestation, prestation, and reformulation.

Is giving a gift selfish? ›

When giving is more about you than it is the other person, it is selfish. No matter how generous the gift, if your intention is for the other person to reciprocate, both of you are better off without it. Sometimes selfishness comes disguised as generosity. It is sneaky and hard to question.

How do you accept a gift you don't want? ›

One of the easiest ways to deal with an unwanted gift is to simply return it. Most retail locations will accept returns without a receipt, providing you with a store credit (read: a gift card). You can then take that gift card and purchase something at the same retail location or sell it.

How do I turn on accepting gifts? ›

Click the silhouette icon to open the Account and Privacy tab. In the Content section, locate Can Receive Gifts, and click the arrow to select Yes or No.

How do you say not accepting gifts? ›

"Saying something like 'Your presence is all that I/we wish for. Please save gifts for the next wedding or party you attend! ' is a warm way to make the request.

What happens in your brain when you give a gift? ›

Giving is scientifically proven to reap more personal happiness than receiving. The act of gift giving releases endorphins and dopamine within your brain. These natural chemicals are part of the body's reward system, and are designed specifically to make you feel good.

Are people more selfish after giving gifts? ›

We found that givers (vs. nongivers) wrote significantly less polite messages to their friend. In Study 3, we tested real gifts that people give to friends and found givers (vs. nongivers) subsequently made more selfish decisions at their friends' expense.

What is the psychology of giving gifts? ›

Empathy is one of the pillars of the psychology of gift-giving. When you're giving a gift, you want to delight the recipient – whether it's a lovely surprise or some well-needed support. Looking for a present implies trying to understand that person. In this, gift and psychology go hand in hand.

What are the four types of guilt? ›

In his reflections, Jaspers establishes four types of guilt, viz. criminal, political, moral, and metaphysical.

Why do Toxic people give gifts? ›

Specifically, narcissists give gifts with an eye to maintaining a relationship with the giver and to maintaining control in that relationship. You don't get expensive gifts from a narcissist because they think you are awesome; you get valuable gifts because they want you to continue to think that they are awesome.

Who said guilt is the gift that keeps on giving? ›

Quote by Erma Bombeck: “Guilt: the gift that keeps on giving.”

How do you handle guilt? ›

10 tips to stop feeling guilty
  1. Acknowledge it exists. ...
  2. Eliminate negative self-talk. ...
  3. Find out if there's a reason to feel guilty. ...
  4. Remind yourself of all that you do. ...
  5. Realize it's OK to have needs. ...
  6. Establish boundaries. ...
  7. Make amends. ...
  8. Understand what you can control.

How do you stop guilt? ›

Offer a genuine and sincere apology without defending yourself, accept responsibility and do what is reasonable to make it right. Make peace with yourself. Choosing to hold onto your guilt forever will only make a bad situation worse over time. Think about the mistake long enough to learn from it, but move past it.

What are two causes of guilt? ›

Some common causes of guilt include: surviving trauma or disaster. conflict between personal values and choices you've made. mental or physical health concerns.

What kind of parent raises a narcissist? ›

Cramer (2011) showed that children raised by authoritative and permissive parents (high responsiveness) exhibited more adaptive narcissistic tendencies, such as superiority and grandiosity, whereas children raised by authoritarian parents (low responsiveness) were less likely to exhibit such traits.

Why do some people not want to accept gifts? ›

Blocks to receiving may reflect protection from being in someone's debt. We may suspect their motives, wondering “What do they want from me?” Presuming that compliments or gifts are attempts to control or manipulate us, we pre-emptively defend ourselves from any sense of obligation or indebtedness.

Can narcissists do nice things? ›

Narcissists can sometimes be helpful and caring. However, more often than not, they only pretend to have these qualities. Moreover, even when they act giving and helping, they are not motivated by empathy because they severely lack it, and as a result, their help is often not very productive.

What does it mean the gift that keeps on giving? ›

gift that keeps on giving (plural gifts that keep on giving) (idiomatic) Something with continuous (typically positive) consequences.

What is the gift that never stops giving? ›

“I testify that Jesus Christ is the perfect gift—the gift that never stops giving.”

Where did the gift that keeps on giving come from? ›

The term, “the gift that keeps on giving,” apparently originated, at least in the United States, in the mid-1920s as a slogan advertising the newly invented phonograph.

What are the different types of gifts? ›

Types of Gifts
  • Unrestricted Gifts.
  • Designated Gifts.
  • Memorial and Tribute Gifts.
  • Matching Gifts.
  • Annual Giving.
  • Planned Giving.
  • Special Events.
  • Capital Campaign.

What are the five sense gifts? ›

The concept of a “five senses gift” is to buy or create gifts that appeals to the basic senses of the human body: sound, touch, taste, smell and sight. Whether you choose to give each gift at once, or space them out over the holidays, five senses gifting is a great way to spoil your loved ones!

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Delena Feil

Last Updated:

Views: 6395

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Delena Feil

Birthday: 1998-08-29

Address: 747 Lubowitz Run, Sidmouth, HI 90646-5543

Phone: +99513241752844

Job: Design Supervisor

Hobby: Digital arts, Lacemaking, Air sports, Running, Scouting, Shooting, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Delena Feil, I am a clean, splendid, calm, fancy, jolly, bright, faithful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.