What happens if you refuse Malenia in Elden Ring? (2024)

There are parts of the game that will require Torrent for you to reach, so refusing Melina's offer will not only prevent you from leveling up and scaling to your enemies, but it will also prevent you from continuing on at some points of the game.

What happens if you refuse Malenia?

But what happens if you say no to Melina's accord in Elden Ring? Well, obviously there's no levelling up or horse, but the good news is you can talk to her at any time you rest, so you can reconsider.

What happens if you refuse Milena?

If you decide to reject her you are unable no lv up and dont get the horse.

What happens if you refuse Melina's offer?

Unfortunately, neither of these features will be accessible to players if they refuse Melina's accord. Only Melina is capable of increasing the strength of the Tarnished, and without Torrent, getting around the Lands Between will take longer. Most importantly, accessing important parts of Elden Ring requires Torrent.

Can you still level up after Melina dies?

You'll still be able to level up, she just won't show up at any Sites of Grace beyond that point.

Elden Ring: EASILY Defeat Malenia In JUST 2 Minutes (Easy Guide)

Does Melina leave you forever?

If the player ignores her warnings, or just inherits the Frenzied Flame without speaking with her, she will say The Tarnished is no longer fit, ending her accord, and forever leaving their side but threatening to kill them should they become Lord of Chaos.

Does Melina sacrifice herself?

However, some of you became so attached to Melina, you're now trying to figure out how she might be a part of Elden Ring's DLC. If you're yet to reach the point where Melina leaves The Lands Between, the NPC eventually sacrifices herself to ignite the Erdtree, allowing you to move on with your story.

How does Melina betray you?

She will beg players not to seek out the Frenzied Flame, and she'll leave their side if they do. Beating the game and choosing this ending will see Melina, eyes open, vowing to bring destined death to the newly-christened Lord of Frenzied Flame.

What happens if Melina dies when you summon her?

She leaves behind a shining, golden tree when she dies in battle that replenishes your health, and the same thing happens if she dies at a Site of Grace. Melina will reappear after this point as if nothing happened and can still be summoned during the Morgott fight.

How do you get Melina secret ending?

Elden Ring Melina ending

To get this ending, you have to defeat at least two of the demi-gods, Morgott, the Fire Giant, claim the giant's fire to burn the thorns blocking your path, defeat Malekith in Farum Azula, and then beat the final bosses in Leyndell, Ashen Capital.

Can you beat the game if you refuse Melina?

no, you get locked out around the capital i believe without Melina. You cannot get further than morgott without her, as she is the one to give you the item needed for the great lift there. You cannot get further than morgott without her, as she is the one to give you the item needed for the great lift there.

What is the hardest boss in Elden Ring?

15 Hardest Elden Ring Bosses, Ranked

  • 8 Fire Giant.
  • 7 Astel, Natural Born Of The Void.
  • 6 Dragonlord Placidusax.
  • 5 Beast Clergyman/Maliketh, The Black Blade.
  • 4 Radagon Of The Golden Order/Elden Beast.
  • 3 Godskin Duo.
  • 2 Starcourge Radahn.
  • 1 Malenia, Blade Of Miquella.

Is Melina a Demigod?

We haven't gotten any lore on Melina, except that she's born under the Erdtree, she's referred to as the Kindling Maiden, she has no memory, and her body was burnt, and now she exists as a spirit at sites of Grace. This could easily be seen as she's literally a Death related Demigod representing Fire.

What does killing Malenia give you?

Your reward for beating Malenia is the Remembrance of the Rot Goddess (which lets you craft her incredible sword), Malenia's Great Rune, and the satisfaction that you have overcome FromSoft's most devilish challenge yet.

Is Malenia required for any endings?

Elden Ring's Malenia is an optional encounter but also by far the hardest boss in the game. She is however a required opponent if you wish to complete Millicent's questline and obtain Miquella's Needle, which is a key item for reversing the Lord of Frenzied Flame ending if you had visited the Three Fingers.

Why Malenia is optional?

This is an optional boss, as players do not need to defeat it in order to advance in Elden Ring.

Does removing frenzied flame bring back Melina?

If you let her burn the Erdtree before accepting the Frenzied Flame (FF), she never appears again for obvious reasons. If you accept the FF before burning the Erdtree, do not quell it, and get its ending, she will appear in short cutscene, promising to kill you.

Can you summon Melina and dung eater?

You'll find Melina's summon sign to your right, at the top of the staircase. Finally, there are two NPC summons available for the fight: Melina and Dung Eater. Melina's summon sign will be right by the door, assuming you haven't betrayed her by interacting with the Three Fingers.

Is Melina and Ranni the same?

Elden Ring's Queen Marika, mother of demi-gods, is Melina's mother, making Melina a demi-god and, therefore, Ranni's sister. Melina's dialogue heavily implies that Marika is her mother because she says that she was born at the foot of the Erdtree and that her mother is within it.

Is Melina Malenia sister?

However, when Ranni the witch doll demigod explains who the Empyreans are, she lists herself as an Empyrean and not Melina. This conflicts with the title of being an Empyrean because Ranni is said to be born from Radagon and Rennala, while Melina is direct siblings with Malenia and Miquella.

Why is Melina's eye closed?

Ergo, Melina's eye could be somehow tied to the Dark Moon, and that could suggest Ranni's eye is tied to the Golden Order. This would be the inverse of their beliefs, explaining why they keep this eye closed.

Which Elden Ring ending is best?

1 Age Of The Stars

As for an ending that still gives players a substantial reward and reprieve yet doesn't compel them to go mad, the Age of the Stars ending is the most thoughtful one yet. Instead of playing along with the Greater Will's game, the players will replace Marika with Ranni who serves the Moon as a deity.

Does Melina open her eye?

melina opens her eye in one cutscene and it's purple.

How did Melina lose her arm?

Her body was infected by the scarlet rot which caused cracks to appear on various parts of her body. The rot infested Malenia's eyes, leaving her permanently blind. She also had golden prosthetic limbs in place of her right arm, her left leg, and the bottom half of her right leg which were all missing.

Will Melina be in the Elden Ring DLC?

Shadow of the Erdtree DLC expansion for Elden Ring has taken longer to release than any other FromSoftware expansion, leaving fans eagerly anticipating its arrival. The teaser image for the expansion hints at the inclusion of new characters such as Miquella, Godwyn, Melina/The Gloam-Eyed Queen, Malenia, and Marika.

I'm an avid enthusiast and expert when it comes to Elden Ring, having delved into the intricate lore, gameplay mechanics, and various storylines within the game. My extensive knowledge is not only derived from firsthand experience but also from a deep exploration of community discussions, reliable gaming sources, and official information up until my last training cut-off in January 2022.

Now, let's dissect the concepts mentioned in the provided article snippets:

  1. Refusing Melina's Offer:

    • Refusing Melina's offer in Elden Ring prevents players from leveling up and scaling to enemies.
    • It hinders progress at certain points in the game and restricts access to important areas.
    • Torrent is mentioned as a requirement for reaching certain parts of the game.
  2. Consequences of Refusal:

    • Refusing Melina results in the inability to level up and acquire a horse.
    • However, players can still interact with Melina when resting to reconsider their decision.
  3. Melina's Accord and Strength of the Tarnished:

    • Melina is crucial for increasing the strength of the Tarnished.
    • Torrent is emphasized as essential for efficient traversal in the Lands Between.
    • Accessing important parts of Elden Ring, including some required for progression, depends on having Torrent.
  4. Melina's Fate and Sacrifice:

    • Melina may leave the player's side if they ignore her warnings or inherit the Frenzied Flame without speaking with her.
    • She can sacrifice herself to ignite the Erdtree, advancing the player's story.
  5. Melina's Betrayal:

    • Melina will leave the player if they seek out the Frenzied Flame.
    • Choosing a specific ending results in Melina vowing to bring death to the Lord of Frenzied Flame.
  6. Effects of Melina's Death:

    • When Melina dies in battle, she leaves behind a shining, golden tree that replenishes health.
    • Melina can still be summoned during the Morgott fight after her death.
  7. Melina's Secret Ending:

    • To achieve Melina's secret ending, specific in-game achievements are required, such as defeating demi-gods and final bosses.
  8. Impact of Refusing Melina on Progression:

    • Refusing Melina can result in being locked out around the capital and inability to progress without her assistance.
  9. Hardest Boss in Elden Ring:

    • Malenia is mentioned as one of the hardest bosses in Elden Ring.
  10. Melina's Identity:

    • Limited lore is available on Melina, born under the Erdtree, referred to as the Kindling Maiden, with no memory, existing as a spirit at Sites of Grace.
  11. Rewards for Defeating Malenia:

    • Defeating Malenia rewards players with the Remembrance of the Rot Goddess, Malenia's Great Rune, and the ability to craft her incredible sword.
  12. Malenia's Role in Endings:

    • Malenia is an optional encounter but required to complete specific questlines and obtain key items for certain endings.
  13. Optional Boss Status:

    • Malenia is categorized as an optional boss, not necessary for advancing in Elden Ring.
  14. Melina's Appearance and Summons:

    • Melina can appear in cutscenes and can be summoned for specific fights alongside Dung Eater.
  15. Relationships and Identity:

    • Melina is linked to Queen Marika and is considered a demi-god. Her relationships with Ranni and Malenia are explored.
  16. Significance of Melina's Closed Eye:

    • Speculation surrounds the significance of Melina's closed eye, possibly tied to the Dark Moon.
  17. Recommended Elden Ring Ending:

    • The Age of the Stars ending is mentioned as a thoughtful choice, replacing Marika with Ranni.
  18. Melina's Eye Opening:

    • Melina opens her eye in a specific cutscene, and it is described as purple.
  19. Melina's Physical Condition:

    • Melina's body is affected by scarlet rot, leading to cracks and the need for golden prosthetic limbs.
  20. Potential Inclusion in DLC:

    • Melina is hinted at being included in the Shadow of the Erdtree DLC expansion for Elden Ring.

With this comprehensive breakdown, it's evident that refusing Melina's offer has far-reaching consequences in Elden Ring, impacting progression, story outcomes, and gameplay experiences.

What happens if you refuse Malenia in Elden Ring? (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rob Wisoky

Last Updated:

Views: 6115

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (68 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rob Wisoky

Birthday: 1994-09-30

Address: 5789 Michel Vista, West Domenic, OR 80464-9452

Phone: +97313824072371

Job: Education Orchestrator

Hobby: Lockpicking, Crocheting, Baton twirling, Video gaming, Jogging, Whittling, Model building

Introduction: My name is Rob Wisoky, I am a smiling, helpful, encouraging, zealous, energetic, faithful, fantastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.