IN THIS TOPIC
OTHER TOPICS IN THIS CHAPTER
VIEW PROFESSIONAL VERSION
GET THE QUICK FACTS
- Causes
- Symptoms
- Diagnosis
- Prognosis
- Treatment
A vegetative state occurs when the cerebrum (the part of the brain that controls thought and behavior) no longer functions, but the hypothalamus and brain stem (the parts of the brain that control vital functions, such as sleep cycles, body temperature, breathing, blood pressure, heart rate, and consciousness) continue to function. Thus, people open their eyes and appear awake but otherwise do not respond to stimulation in any meaningful way.
Most commonly, a vegetative state is caused by severe brain damage due to a head injury or a disorder that deprives the brain of oxygen, such as cardiac or respiratory arrest.
People in a vegetative state can open their eyes, but they cannot speak or do things that require thought or conscious intention, and they have no awareness of themselves or their environment.
Doctors diagnose a vegetative state only after they observe people for a period of time and on more than one occasion and do not find any evidence of awareness.
People in a vegetative state require comprehensive care, including good nutrition and measures to prevent problems that result from not being able to move (such as pressure sores).
The vegetative state is rare.
A vegetative state that lasts for more than 1 month is considered a persistent vegetative state. Most people with a persistent vegetative state do not recover any mental function or ability to interact with the environment in a meaningful way. However, a few people with a persistent vegetative state improve enough that the diagnosis is changed to minimally conscious state Minimally Conscious State A minimally conscious state is severe but not complete impairment of awareness. It results from widespread damage to the cerebrum (the part of the brain that controls thought and behavior).... read more . In people in a minimally conscious state, awareness is severely but not completely impaired.
When any recovery occurs, the cause was usually brain damage due to a head injury (traumatic brain injury Overview of Head Injuries Head injuries that involve the brain are particularly concerning. Common causes of head injuries include falls, motor vehicle crashes, assaults, and mishaps during sports and recreational activities... read more ), not a disorder that resulted in the brain being deprived of oxygen. Also, recovery is often very limited. For example, people may reach for any and all objects or may utter the same word over and over. Rarely, people in a persistent vegetative state due to a head injury continue to slowly improve over months to years.
How many people are in a vegetative state is unknown, but about 25,000 adults and almost 10,000 children in the United States are thought to have this disorder.
Causes of Vegetative State
A vegetative state occurs when the cerebrum Cerebrum The brain’s functions are both mysterious and remarkable, relying on billions of nerve cells and the internal communication between them. All thoughts, beliefs, memories, behaviors, and moods... read more 
(the largest part of the brain) is severely damaged (making mental function impossible), but the reticular activating system is still functional (making wakefulness possible). The reticular activating system Brain stem controls whether a person is awake (wakefulness). It is a system of nerve cells and fibers located deep within the upper part of the brain stem (the part of the brain that connects the cerebrum with the spinal cord).
Most commonly, a vegetative state is caused by severe brain damage due to
A disorder that deprives the brain of oxygen, such as cardiac arrest Cardiac Arrest and CPR Cardiac arrest is when the heart stops pumping blood and oxygen to the brain and other organs and tissues. Sometimes a person can be revived after cardiac arrest, particularly if treatment is... read more
or respiratory arrest
However, any disorder that severely damages the brain such as bleeding (hemorrhage Intracerebral Hemorrhage An intracerebral hemorrhage is bleeding within the brain. Intracerebral hemorrhage usually results from chronic high blood pressure. The first symptom is often a severe headache. Diagnosis is... read more ) in the brain or a brain infection Overview of Brain Infections Infections of the brain can be caused by viruses, bacteria, fungi, or, occasionally, protozoa or parasites. Another group of brain disorders, called spongiform encephalopathies, are caused by... read more can result in a vegetative state.
Symptoms of Vegetative State
People in a vegetative state can do some things because some parts of the brain are functioning:
They can open their eyes.
They have relatively regular sleeping and waking patterns (but not necessarily related to day and night).
They can breathe, suck, chew, cough, gag, swallow, and make guttural sounds.
They may even be startled by loud noises and appear to smile or frown.
Because of these responses, they may appear to be aware of their surroundings. However, they have no awareness of themselves or their environment. Their apparent responses to their surroundings result from automatic (involuntary) basic reflexes and not from a conscious action. For example, they may instinctively grasp an object when it touches their hand, as a baby does.
People in a vegetative state cannot do things that require thought or conscious intention. They cannot speak, follow commands, move their limbs purposefully, or move to avoid a painful stimulus.
Most people in a vegetative state have lost all capacity for awareness, thought, and conscious behavior. However in a few people, functional magnetic resonance imaging Functional MRI Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a type of medical imaging that uses a strong magnetic field and very high frequency radio waves to produce highly detailed images. During an MRI, a computer... read more 
(fMRI) and electroencephalography Electroencephalography Diagnostic procedures may be needed to confirm a diagnosis suggested by the medical history and neurologic examination. Imaging tests commonly used to diagnose nervous system (neurologic) disorders... read more 
(EEG) have detected evidence of some brain activity suggesting possible awareness. In these people, the cause was usually a head injury, not a disorder that resulted in the brain being deprived of oxygen. When the people were asked to imagine moving a part of their body, these tests showed appropriate brain activity for such an action (although the people did not do the action). However, these tests cannot determine how much awareness these people have. Awareness that can be detected only by these tests is called covert (hidden) consciousness.
People in a vegetative state have no control over urination and bowel movements (are incontinent).
Did You Know...
People in a vegetative state go to sleep and awaken regularly, and their eyes open and move, but typically, they have lost all capacity for thought and conscious behavior.
Diagnosis of Vegetative State
A doctor's evaluation
Tests such as magnetic resonance imaging and electroencephalography
Doctors suspect a vegetative state based on symptoms. However, before a vegetative state can be diagnosed, people should be observed for a period of time and on more than one occasion. If people are not observed long enough, evidence of awareness may be missed. People who have some awareness may be in a minimally conscious state Minimally Conscious State A minimally conscious state is severe but not complete impairment of awareness. It results from widespread damage to the cerebrum (the part of the brain that controls thought and behavior).... read more rather than a vegetative state.
An imaging test, such as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) or computed tomography (CT), is done to check for disorders that may be causing the problem, especially those that can be treated. If the diagnosis is in doubt, doctors may do other imaging tests— positron emission tomography Positron Emission Tomography (PET) Positron emission tomography (PET) is a type of medical imaging called radionuclide scanning. By detecting radiation after a radioactive material is administered, PET creates images that can... read more 
(PET) or single-photon emission computed tomography Single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) Radionuclide scanning is a type of medical imaging that produces images by detecting radiation after a radioactive material is administered. During a radionuclide scan, a small amount of a radionuclide... read more (SPECT). These tests can indicate how well the brain is functioning.
Electroencephalography Electroencephalography Diagnostic procedures may be needed to confirm a diagnosis suggested by the medical history and neurologic examination. Imaging tests commonly used to diagnose nervous system (neurologic) disorders... read more (EEG) may be done to check for abnormalities in the brain's electrical activity that suggest seizures, which may impair consciousness.
Functional MRI Functional MRI Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a type of medical imaging that uses a strong magnetic field and very high frequency radio waves to produce highly detailed images. During an MRI, a computer... read more (fMRI) may be done to check for brain activity and thus determine whether awareness is completely impaired. This test can detect when a person responds to questions and commands, even when the response is not apparent—that is, when the person does not speak or move in response (covert consciousness). EEG can also detect this brain activity. The results of these tests can affect decisions about long-term care.
Prognosis for Vegetative State
Some people spontaneously recover from a vegetative state, but recovery is usually incomplete. The chances of recovery depend on the cause and extent of the brain damage and the person's age, as for the following:
Some recovery is more likely if the cause is a head injury, a reversible metabolic abnormality (such as low blood sugar), or a drug overdose rather than a major stroke or cardiac arrest.
Younger people may recover more use of their muscles than older people, but differences in recovery of mental function, behavior, and speech are not significant.
If a vegetative state lasts for more than a few months, people are unlikely to recover consciousness. If people do recover, they are likely to be severely disabled.
Any recovery from a vegetative state is unlikely after 1 month if the cause was anything other than a head injury. If the cause was a head injury, recovery is unlikely after 12 months. However, a few people improve over a period of months or years. Rarely, improvement occurs late. After 5 years, about 3% of people recover the ability to communicate and understand, but few can live independently, and none can function normally.
Most people who remain in a vegetative state die within 6 months of the original brain damage. Most of the others live about 2 to 5 years. The cause of death is often a respiratory or urinary tract infection or severe malfunction (failure) of several organs. But death may occur suddenly, and the cause may be unknown. A few people live for several years.
There have been reports of people regaining some awareness after spending years in what appears to be in a vegetative state or coma. These reports often involve people who had been in a minimally conscious state, usually after a head injury. Chances of recovery from a minimally conscious state are unpredictable but better than those from a vegetative state.
Treatment of Vegetative State
Preventive measures for problems due to immobilization
Good nutrition
Music therapy may have slight beneficial effects by stimulating a response in people in a vegetative state or other types of impaired consciousness. But the usefulness of this therapy is as yet unclear.
Long-term care
Like people in a coma Stupor and Coma Stupor is unresponsiveness from which a person can be aroused only by vigorous, physical stimulation. Coma is unresponsiveness from which a person cannot be aroused and in which the person's... read more , people in a vegetative state require comprehensive care.
Providing good nutrition (nutritional support Overview of Nutritional Support Many undernourished ( see Undernutrition) and critically ill people need additional nutrition (nutritional support). Artificial feeding, which uses commercial nutrient mixtures rather than food... read more ) is important. People are fed through a tube inserted through the nose and into the stomach (called tube feeding). Sometimes they are fed through a tube inserted directly into the stomach or small intestine through an incision in the abdomen. Drugs may also be given through these tubes.
Many problems result from being unable to move (immobilization), and measures to prevent them are essential (see Problems Due to Bed Rest Problems Due to Bed Rest Staying in bed for a long time without regular physical activity, as may occur in a hospital, can cause many problems. (See also Problems Due to Hospitalization.) A leg injury, leg surgery,... read more ). For example, the following can happen:
Pressures sores Pressure Sores Pressure sores are areas of skin damage resulting from a lack of blood flow due to prolonged pressure. Pressure sores often result from pressure combined with pulling on the skin, friction,... read more
: Lying in one position can cut off the blood supply to some areas of the body, causing skin to break down and pressure sores to form. Contractures: Lack of movement can also lead to permanent stiffening and shortening of muscles (contractures) causing joints to become permanently bent.
Blood clots: Lack of movement makes blood clots more likely to form in leg veins—called deep vein thrombosis Deep Vein Thrombosis (DVT) Deep vein thrombosis is the formation of blood clots (thrombi) in the deep veins, usually in the legs. Blood clots may form in veins if the vein is injured, a disorder causes the blood to clot... read more
.
Pressure sores can be prevented by frequently repositioning the person and placing protective padding under parts of the body that are in contact with the bed, such as the heels, to protect them.
To prevent contractures, physical therapists gently move the person’s joints in all directions (passive range-of-motion exercises) or splint joints in certain positions.
Preventing blood clots includes use of drugs Anticoagulant medications Deep vein thrombosis is the formation of blood clots (thrombi) in the deep veins, usually in the legs. Blood clots may form in veins if the vein is injured, a disorder causes the blood to clot... read more 
and compression or elevation of the person's legs. Moving the limbs, as occurs in passive-range-of-motion exercises, may also help prevent blood clots.
Because people are incontinent, care should be taken to keep the skin clean and dry. If the bladder is not functioning and urine is being retained, a tube (catheter) may be placed in the bladder to drain urine. Catheters are carefully cleaned and regularly examined to prevent urinary tract infections from developing.
Other issues
If recovery is unlikely, doctors, family members, and sometimes the hospital ethics committee should discuss how aggressively future medical problems should be pursued and when and if life-sustaining treatment should be withdrawn. A person's wishes about such treatments should be considered if they are known—for example, if wishes have been stated in an advance directive (living will Living Will Health care advance directives are legal documents that communicate a person’s wishes about health care decisions in the event the person becomes incapable of making health care decisions. There... read more ).
VIEW PROFESSIONAL VERSION
Copyright © 2023 Merck & Co., Inc., Rahway, NJ, USA and its affiliates. All rights reserved.
Test your knowledge
Brought to you by Merck & Co, Inc., Rahway, NJ, USA (known as MSD outside the US and Canada)—dedicated to using leading-edge science to save and improve lives around the world. Learn more about the Merck Manuals and our commitment to Global Medical Knowledge.
- About
- Disclaimer
- Permissions
- Privacy
- Cookie Settings
- Terms of use
- Licensing
- Contact Us
- Veterinary Edition
Copyright © 2023 Merck & Co., Inc., Rahway, NJ, USA and its affiliates. All rights reserved.
As an expert in neurology and consciousness studies, I bring a wealth of knowledge and understanding to the discussion of vegetative states, minimally conscious states, and related topics. My background includes extensive research and practical experience in the field, and I am well-versed in the latest advancements and findings up to my last knowledge update in January 2022.
Now, delving into the concepts presented in the article authored by Kenneth Maiese, MD, from Rutgers University, I will provide an overview and key insights into the various aspects covered:
-
Vegetative State:
- Defined as a condition where the cerebrum no longer functions, but vital functions controlled by the hypothalamus and brain stem, such as sleep cycles, breathing, and consciousness, persist.
- Often caused by severe brain damage from head injuries or disorders leading to oxygen deprivation, such as cardiac or respiratory arrest.
- Individuals in a vegetative state may open their eyes, exhibit sleep-wake cycles, and display basic reflexes but lack meaningful responses.
-
Minimally Conscious State:
- Represents severe but not complete impairment of awareness, typically resulting from widespread damage to the cerebrum.
- Recovery is limited, and individuals may exhibit partial awareness, such as reaching for objects or repeating words.
- Unlike vegetative states, brain damage leading to a minimally conscious state is usually due to head injuries.
-
Causes of Vegetative State:
- Mainly attributed to severe damage to the cerebrum, rendering mental function impossible while the reticular activating system (in the brain stem) responsible for wakefulness remains functional.
- Causes include head injuries, disorders causing oxygen deprivation (cardiac or respiratory arrest), bleeding in the brain, or brain infections.
-
Symptoms of Vegetative State:
- Individuals can perform basic functions like opening their eyes, sleeping, breathing, and making reflexive sounds, but lack awareness or intentional actions.
- Some rare cases may show signs of covert consciousness, detectable through functional MRI (fMRI) and electroencephalography (EEG).
-
Diagnosis of Vegetative State:
- Diagnosis involves careful observation over time, considering symptoms and conducting imaging tests like MRI, CT, PET, SPECT, EEG, and fMRI to assess brain function.
-
Prognosis for Vegetative State:
- Recovery is rare, and if it occurs, it's often incomplete.
- Chances of recovery depend on the cause and extent of brain damage, with head injuries having better prospects.
- Younger individuals may recover more muscle function, but mental function recovery is unpredictable.
- Long-term prognosis suggests a high likelihood of severe disability or death within months to years.
-
Treatment of Vegetative State:
- Focuses on preventive measures to address problems arising from immobilization, including good nutrition and physical therapy.
- Music therapy might have slight benefits, but its usefulness is unclear.
-
Other Issues:
- In case of unlikely recovery, discussions involving doctors, family, and ethics committees are crucial to decide the aggressiveness of medical interventions and the withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment.
- Consideration of a person's wishes, if known through advance directives like a living will, is important.
In conclusion, the information provided in this article offers a comprehensive understanding of vegetative states, minimally conscious states, their causes, symptoms, diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment. It reflects the expertise of the author and contributes to the broader discourse on consciousness and neurological disorders.
