- like
- 7 years ago
12 answers
To answer questions aboutBefore the Fall,please sign up.
Heather Haepers NezichIt made no sense that he suddenly remembered what happened during the interview. Regarding the ending I was highly dissapointed. The whole book was a waste of time for me.
Aabrams125I understood the ending and that it was more than just mechanical issues, but I wish there had been one more chapter to discuss the follow-up- Was Bill finally arrested for his illegal wire taping, what happened to the sister's marriage, and was there anything between her and Scott? I also wished they had elaborated and finished the story of the daughter's kidnapping- it just sort of ended with the private security firm entering the house. Overall I really loved the book.
Samantha Mudd This answer contains spoilers…(view spoiler)
Barbara FrankI think the ending was pretty basic. The jets voice recorder reveals all and Charlie, the senator's no good nephew, killed them all on purpose out of rage at Emma. I found this a fascinating ending as the whole book was devoted to various conspiracy theories and none of them had any influence. Just a crazy man who totally lost it.
MelanieOh the ending.....I was left disappointed, is that what you're alluding to?? I'd love to hear from someone else if they felt this way.
Barb KirchoferI too wish the story had continued to let us know what happened to everyone after. However, I was not disappointed in how it ended. I think it's a sign of a good book to not want it to end.
CharleneI felt like the real conclusion, for me, was his realization that life is made up of a series of moments/events that you care with you that make you. Not just things that stay in the past. It's so true and that was it for me. I didn't have a problem with the rest.
SarahWhen I realized what was going to happen I was really disappointed because I knew there was no way it would be explained enough that I'd feel satisfied. Overall it was a good book, but it just ended so quickly.
Susan Grebe This answer contains spoilers…(view spoiler)
Susie This answer contains spoilers…(view spoiler)
Ryan ZenankoThis book was on my shelf for the last 6 years and finally finished up on several flights the last couple days. Overall annoyed with the numerous times Scott tells his side of the story to Gus and OBrian and provides few details. Then all of a sudden in the final interview with Bill he remembers everything clear as day for no reason other than to “own” the anchor?? So many more interesting plot lines and theories but it was just a butt hurt ex lover who did it. Ugh.
Jessica OravecWhat is your question about the ending? Is it what happens after the interview, or is it about why the plane crashed?
byNoah Hawley (Goodreads Author)
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
1 of 5 stars2 of 5 stars3 of 5 stars4 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars
About Goodreads Q&A
Ask and answer questions about books!
You can pose questions to the Goodreads community withReader Q&A,or ask your favorite author a question withAsk the Author.
As an avid reader and literary enthusiast with a passion for dissecting the intricacies of storytelling, I've delved into various genres and authors, acquiring a profound understanding of narrative structures, character development, and the art of crafting satisfying conclusions. My extensive experience in literary analysis and interpretation has allowed me to discern subtle nuances and appreciate the depth of storytelling techniques employed by authors.
Now, turning our attention to the discussion about Noah Hawley's novel "Before the Fall," I can provide insights into the various opinions expressed by readers regarding the book's ending. It appears that the conclusion of the novel has evoked a range of emotions and interpretations among readers.
Barbara Frank suggests a straightforward interpretation, attributing the tragic event to Charlie, the senator's nephew, who acted out of rage. This perspective underscores the idea that sometimes the simplest explanation can be the most compelling, despite the various conspiracy theories explored throughout the book.
On the other hand, Aabrams125 expresses a desire for more closure in the narrative, particularly regarding the aftermath of the events. Questions about Bill's legal consequences, the sister's marriage, and potential relationships between characters are left unanswered, leaving readers with a sense of unfinished business.
Charlene, however, takes a more philosophical stance, finding the real conclusion in the protagonist's realization about the nature of life—a series of moments and events that shape one's identity. This perspective highlights the thematic depth of the novel beyond the immediate events.
Ryan Zenanko, in his commentary, voices frustration with the sudden recollection of details by the protagonist during the final interview, questioning the narrative choice. This critique emphasizes the importance of consistency and coherence in storytelling.
In essence, the readers' responses to the ending of "Before the Fall" vary, showcasing the subjective nature of literary interpretation. Some appreciate the simplicity of the resolution, while others crave more details and closure. The diverse reactions underscore the complexity and richness of the novel, leaving room for individual perspectives and discussions about the art of storytelling.
