Student loan debt. Will you have to make a choice between owning a home and education? - Spendaholics Anonymous (2024)

Disclosure: Some of the links below are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, I will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase .

Have you considered how your student loan debt might negatively impact your life when it comes to buying your first home? There may be a few more things to consider before you saddle up and ride off to that fancy college of yours!

Most graduates today expect to enter the workforce straight out of school, earning more than the average “Joe” but students need to be thoughtful about their career path, especially while they are still in school.

The sooner they start considering the steps they need to take to help find a job after graduation the better. These steps include asking professors for advice and seeking out internships.

Student loan debt. Will you have to make a choice between owning a home and education? - Spendaholics Anonymous (1)

New graduates who take a job that does not require a degree (as their first job out of school) can find themselves in lower-paid positions than their educated Peers, even five or ten years later. Corporate pay structures start from the position you enter at – not the one you are qualified for.

These underemployed graduates will also likely be stuck in positions that do not use their education and a recent study showed that about two-thirds of these same graduates, whose first jobs do not require a degree, will still be underemployed five years later.

So, what impact will this have five years after you’ve graduated University? It is likely that by this time you will be thinking towards Home Ownership and here’s where it can get tricky.

Student loan debt has become a major barrier to home ownership in America.

Because graduates are leaving Uni with massive amounts of debt, entering into the workforce at less than their educated capacity (underemployed) and having had almost no time to establish themselves financially, they are finding that the monthly student loan payments can eat up a large slice of their income, threaten to push down their credit scores and make saving nearly impossible — all huge impediments, of course, to landing a house.

For every 10 percent in student loan debt a person holds, their chance of home ownership drops between 1 and 2 percentage points during their first five years after school, according to the Federal Reserve.

Having competing influences,such as greater access to education versus the reduced ability to buy a home because of student loan debt, can be weighed and measured and the possibility of offsetting some of the financial distress can be mitigated by the probability of access to higher earnings.

There are three challenges to consider if you are in this situation:-

1. Debt to equity ratio (or income ratio)

Simply put: What a person owes (in debt) versus how much they make (and hold in assets)

Almost a fifth of all mortgage applicants fail at this first hurdle.

An underwriter wants to see that your overall expenditures on housing and debt — including student loans and car payments — is not more than 36 percent of your income.

Some will advocate that student loan debt is “Good” debt.

The banks will class it as unsecured (the same as your credit card!)

2. Credit Score.

Eight percent of student loan borrowers are denied a mortgage because of their credit score.

When you can’t find an entry level position for your qualification so you take any job you can just to make some money, pretty soon you can’t make the payments on the loans, especially if you’re “above the average” loan balance of $55,000, (Law degrees and Medical degrees run into the hundreds of thousands) and so, you default.

By the year 2023 (according to the Brookings Institute) 40% of borrowers are expected to be in this position and to be defaulting on their student loans.

Read: Credit scores – 5 steps you can take today to improve your FICO

3. Finding the down-payment.

85 percent of student loan borrowers say difficulty in saving has delayed their ability to buy a house, according to the National Association of Realtors.

If you consider the median cost of a home in America is somewhere in the region of $250,000 and here in BC (especially where I’m based) it’s closer to $350,000 then coming up with that initial 20% deposit, making your debt payments and still being able to eat is no mean feat!

What happens when there’s an unexpected bill. The Head Gasket goes on the Van, the boiler craps out? Those couple of thousand dollars you did manage to scrape together are gone in an instant and so the cycle begins again.

Did you think you wouldn’t be eating Ramen again once you graduated?

Part of the epidemic is that employers have increasingly come to expect more from graduates, somewhat unfairly. For example, many advertisem*nts for positions that normally would be perfect for recent graduates now ask for years of experience. This is now making people challenge whether actually obtaining a degree in the first place is worth the time, effort and cost? Families need to think seriously about the level of investment.

Is it the system that’s broken?

The big assumption that is drilled into our heads during school is that people need to work for other people. So, when you exit school, you get a job and our financial system is centeredaround this flawed model.

I spent a whole afternoon with a careers counselor(I know, right?), deciding what my aptitude was and what job I should apply for in the four weeks left until I graduated (not that we “graduate” in England) High School. I told him not to worry about me because at the time I was so lost I was just going to join the army. Honestly, that was my plan. I didn’t realize I would have almost two years to wait until I was old enough and by that time I had a clerks position in an accountancy firm, an apartment and a fiance (waay too young for the latter!)

Today they have Career planning, a course that spans a whole year! It teaches resumes and cash flows / budgeting, bursary and loan applications, how to write a killer college application letter. College was never even considered for the likes of me.

Looking back I was so lucky to attend my local technical college and start on (the next ten years) learning Business & Finance followed by Accountancy.

When I look at the costs of education in other areas of the World I’m left wondering why the US and Canada is so expensive? Are we deliberately trying to dumb down our population?

Why would we do that?

AI is progressing so quickly that perhaps the only positions left in that brave new world will be the most menial ones or the highly talented, art like positions.

Now, I consider myself a well rounded parent and have taken steps to ensure #onechild can attend school for two years and study her passion (Costume Design & Construction) and she will leave without a penny of student debt. Where she goes from there is not my problem!

#Twochild may not fair so well (a PHD is looming…..). Whilst I’m happy to keep going and to provide justly for #2 child I can’t help wondering who will have the most success (however you gauge that)?

Will it be my artsy, fartsy glitter covered fairy girl or my lineal nerd with a penchant for outer space?

Only time will tell and when it’s all said and done, will they be able to afford any kind of home of their own or will it back home to live with Mother!!!

Read: Tiny homes – are they the answer?

If you have debt and need a way out consider signing up for the Spendaholics Anonymous 12 Step program to becoming debt free.

Let me leave you with a small ray of sunshine..

10 countries that offer FREE (or almost free) University Education to International Students.

Student loan debt. Will you have to make a choice between owning a home and education? - Spendaholics Anonymous (2)

Go get em tiger!

XO

Anna

Student loan debt. Will you have to make a choice between owning a home and education? - Spendaholics Anonymous (2024)

FAQs

Is it possible for people with student loan debt to become homeowners? ›

Like with any type of loan, your ability to qualify for a home loan depends on your credit score and ability to repay. Simply having student loan debt doesn't necessarily hurt your credit score. One of the key factors that lenders look for, and that student loans will impact, is your debt-to-income ratio.

Can the government take your home if you default on student loans? ›

The federal government won't take your home because you owe student loan debt. However, if you default and the U.S. Department of Education cannot garnish your wages, offset your tax refund, or take your Social Security Benefits, it may sue you.

Can student loan debt take my house? ›

Student loans are a form of unsecured debt not backed by collateral. So, your home or car cannot be seized if you fail to make payments.

How does student loan debt affect personal choices of adults? ›

Key Takeaways. Carrying student debt can affect your ability to buy a home if your debt-to-income ratio is too high. If you have too much student loan debt, you won't be able to save as much for retirement. Student loan debt can lower your credit score, especially if you fail to make on-time payments.

How does owning a home affect financial aid? ›

Equity in your home

Home equity is the difference between the market value of your home and the amount you owe on it. This amount is NOT counted as an asset on the FAFSA, but it is included on the CSS Profile form, which caps it at 2-3 times income.

Are college graduates more likely to own a house? ›

Despite student loan debt being a hurdle for many potential homebuyers, those with a college degree are more likely to be homeowners than those who don't have one.

What happens if you never pay off your student loans? ›

Eventually, your student loans will be put into default and you may lose federal loan benefits, have your wages garnished, get barred from federal student aid among other consequences. Your loan holder may sue you, as well. If you ignore the court date or the court's orders — that could land you in jail.

Will my student loans be forgiven if they are in default? ›

Defaulted loans are not eligible for any of our student loan forgiveness programs. But if you take advantage of Fresh Start, you'll get out of default status. Then you'll regain the ability to apply for forgiveness programs, including Public Service Loan Forgiveness.

Can you get student loan forgiveness if in default? ›

Are Direct Loans that are in default eligible for Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF)? Defaulted Direct Loans are not eligible for PSLF. However, a defaulted loan may become eligible for PSLF if you resolve the default. Learn how to resolve the default through rehabilitation or consolidation.

Do student loans disappear after 7 years? ›

Do student loans fall off your credit report? Both federal and private student loans fall off your credit report about seven years after your last payment or date of default. You default after nine months of nonpayment for federal student loans, and you're not in deferment or forbearance.

What happens if you don't pay off student loans in 25 years? ›

Any borrower with ED-held loans that have accumulated time in repayment of at least 20 or 25 years will see automatic forgiveness, even if the loans are not currently on an IDR plan. Borrowers with FFELP loans held by commercial lenders or Perkins loans not held by ED can benefit if they consolidate into Direct Loans.

Can student loans seize your bank account? ›

Lenders can garnish your bank account to recover student loan debt, and they can do it in different ways depending on whether your student loans are federal or private.

Do student loans cause mental health issues? ›

Higher student debt was correlated with higher stress. In short, “if you have more student debt and you feel like things are unstable, you have higher levels of stress and anxiety,” Lindgren explains.

How does student loan debt affect your life? ›

Student loans can delay borrowers' ability to achieve life goals such as getting married, having children, buying a home, pursuing further education, or finding an excellent job in their preferred field. Here's a closer look at how student debt can affect your life—and what you can do to limit that impact.

How to avoid student loan debt? ›

Tips to avoid or reduce student loan debt
  1. Enroll at a community college.
  2. Consider attending a no-loan school.
  3. Estimate college costs.
  4. Maximize other funding sources.
  5. Start a side hustle or get a part-time job.
  6. Limit living expenses.
  7. Borrow only the amount needed.
  8. Understand the payments.

Can you get a mortgage with 100k in student loans? ›

It's not uncommon for a first-time home buyer to have anywhere from $30,000 to $100,000 in student loan debt and still qualify for a mortgage, Park says. “We approve people with student loan debt all the time,” Argento adds.

How many homeowners have student debt? ›

Among recent home buyers, nearly one-quarter of all home buyers, and 37% of first-time buyers, have student loan debt, with a typical amount of $30,000.

What credit score is needed to buy a house? ›

The minimum credit score needed for most mortgages is typically around 620. However, government-backed mortgages like Federal Housing Administration (FHA) loans typically have lower credit requirements than conventional fixed-rate loans and adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs).

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ray Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 5634

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ray Christiansen

Birthday: 1998-05-04

Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

Phone: +337636892828

Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.