Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (2024)

The stock market is soaring high with abundant liquidity keeping the market buoyant even as companies have struggled to put on a good show. Both foreign and domestic investors have pumped in truck-loads of money over the past one year. However, contrary to the past trends, this time, domestic investors have taken the lead in boosting the market. While foreign institutional investors (FIIs) have bought equities worth Rs 58,268 since July last year, domestic institutional investors (DIIs) have made a bigger splash in the market with net inflows of Rs 84,825 crore. In fact, DIIs have emerged net buyers in the equity market for each month since August last year.

For 196 of the 200 firms in the BSE200 Index, non-promoter foreign institutional ownership increased marginally from 19.18% in June last year to 19.56% at the end of June 2017. Meanwhile, DII holding in the same basket rose from 10.71% to 11.48% during this period.

More interestingly, both sets of investors have taken different paths while buying and selling stocks. Our study of the shareholding pattern of the BSE200 basket of companies shows that there is not a single company in which both DIIs and FIIs have simultaneously shored up holdings or cut their stake over the past four quarters.

Meanwhile, there are eight companies where the two have taken a sharply divergent view—where one set has increased stake consistently, the other has simultaneously pared down ownership. To clear the situation, we delve deeper and find out how analysts are placed on each of these stocks where the big investors have taken a contrasting stand.

Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (1)

Blue Dart Limited: Growth visibility
One of the largest courier players in India, Blue Dart has an extensive air and ground support network. It is expected to emerge a big beneficiary of the Goods and Services Tax regime (GST), as manufacturers are likely to outsource their entire supply chain logistics to third-party players. Although analysts had anticipated the firm’s revenue growth to moderate as it transitioned to the GST regime, the impact turned out to be much higher. Subdued revenue growth—7% year-on-year (y-o-y)— coupled with its fixed cost model led to a sharp 600 basis points decline in Blue Dart’s operating margins. However, this is expected to be a one-off event, attributable to the impact of the GST roll-out, and should not impact the entire financial year. Analysts note that the company’s earnings are depressed because of structural changes in its business-to-business segment because of the impact of GST and in the business-to-consumer segment because of the consolidation in the e-commerce industry. The stock’s premium valuation is also a concern. “Until growth visibility improves, the stock is likely to underperform the broader markets,” says Harshvardhan Dole, IIFL. However, any weakness in the stock price provides a good entry point, he adds.


Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (2)


Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (3)

CESC Earnings: Growth to continue
Power utility CESC will soon undergo restructuring, aimed at segregating the group’s power generation and distribution activities. The planned demerger into four independent businesses is expected to unlock value for the company, with the distribution business likely to get re-rated on reduced volatility in earnings. Analysts estimate that CESC’s Haldia plant generated core RoE of over 25% in 2016-17, among the highest in the industry. Subsidiary Dhariwal turned EBITDA-positive in 2016-17 owing to the commencement of power purchase agreements. Meanwhile, its retail subsidiary, Spencer, is on the verge of a turnaround. The supply chain optimisation under GST will reduce operating cost while independent management focus will drive growth, possibly leading to a re-rating. “Earnings growth momentum to continue. Have upgraded PAT estimates for 2018-20 by 13-15%, driven by Dhariwal and Spencer,” say analysts at Motilal Oswal.

Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (4)
Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (5)

Crompton Greaves: Valuations are expensive
Electrical appliance maker Crompton Greaves reported a weak set of numbers in the April-June quarter, owing to destocking in the transition to the GST regime. Analysts reckon Crompton would face challenges in scaling up its appliances business because of fragmented sub-categories and high dependence on aftersales service network. A chunk of the firm’s revenue comes from the fans segment, which is facing stagnation in growth, in addition to higher competition. The company has a weak presence in retail lighting and water heaters, where it has focused on standard products despite faster growth in the premium segment. Reports suggest the firm is looking to enhance its home appliances portfolio with Rs 1,500-crore acquisition of Kenstar. However, its valuation is not cheap, trading at just a 5% discount to Havells—a market leader with a presence in multiple categories. “We reiterate ‘Sell’, given Crompton is the most exposed to the increase in competitive intensity in the fans segment— a matured market, growing in mid-single digits. Expensive acquisition of Kenstar is also a risk—if it goes through,” says Bhargav Buddhadev, Analyst, Ambit Capital.

Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (7)

GSK Pharma Industry: Leading return ratios
The pharma major suffered in the April-June quarter, with net profit falling 63.4% from a year ago. Sales fell 14.4% to Rs 587 crore y-o-y. The firm has been unable to grow profits meaningfully over the past few years owing to price control on 30% of its drugs portfolio and supply bottlenecks. The company plans to counter this by assessing new products from its global respiratory and vaccines pipeline for launch in India. GSK also plans to increase its presence in the chronic drugs space, which provides more sustainable revenues. Besides, its upcoming state-of-the-art facility in Karnataka—entailing investment of Rs 1,000 crore— is expected to start operations in the fourth quarter of 2018. The management has indicated that it is likely to seal the deal on selling its 60-acre land parcel in Thane by the end of this year, which could unlock Rs 500-600 crore. The sharp cut in its share price provides a good entry point, reckon some analysts. “We believe GSK Pharma has a strong parent support, superior brand portfolio (competitive advantage), high payout ratio ( more than 100%) and industry-leading return ratios,” say analysts at Motilal Oswal.

Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (8)
Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (9)

Reliance Industries: Expected to rise further
The company put in a blockbuster show in the April-June quarter, clocking robust operating performance in both its core segments—refining and petrochemicals. Gross refining margin at $11.9 (Rs 758) per barrel was the highest since September 2009 while petrochem EBIT (earnings before income and taxes) margin at 16.5% was the highest since September 2010. However, the oil and gas segment continued to bleed due to the fall in production because of the natural decline in output from fields and weak domestic gas realisations. With capital expenditure on its core business bottoming out, RIL’s earnings profile should improve substantially. Positive sentiment on the stock has been further boosted by the strong traction in its telecom business. Jio active subscriber base by May-end was around 89 million, with a large chunk opting for the higher tariff plan. This is likely to get a further boost with the launch of the 4G-enabled JioPhone which opens up a large market, but at lower average revenue per user. Analysts remain positive about a further upside in the stock. “Against the backdrop of a strong performance, along with scaling-up new projects in the core business and tremendous value creation potential of its telecom business, we maintain our ‘buy’ rating with an upward revision in estimates and target,” says Prayesh Jain, Analyst, IIFL Wealth Management.

Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (10)
Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (11)

Gujarat Pipavav: Port Possibility of a turnaround
The port operator has been losing business to peers over the last few years. Also, a weak container shipping market and the appreciating rupee dented the company’s performance last year. Reportedly, the promoter, APM Terminals, is looking to exit its 12-year investment. However, positives are emerging for the company with improving container volumes on the west coast, while diversification to the crude and car segment and the cargo division should produce results. The company may also benefit from the upcoming Dedicated Freight Corridor (DFC) with Pipavav Rail Corporation preparing to connect the port with the DFC. Amit Agrawal, Kotak Securities, expects the next few years to be the turnaround years for the company: “With the high operating leverage nature of the business and an expected container volume CAGR of 7.5 % over 2017-19, operating margins likely to remain healthy, improving the return ratios.”

Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (12)
Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (13)

Tata Communications: Margins to remain under pressure
For Tata Communications, the higher margin data segment has been playing a larger role in business growth for the past few years. Revenue contribution of the data business has increased from 40% in 2013-14 to 58.7% in 2016-17. However, data revenue growth remained in single digits for a third consecutive quarter in April-June 2017. Also, the voice business continues to remain under pressure from heightened competition and irrational pricing but, with its capex over, it will generate stable free cash flows now. The company plans to go for a major digital transformation, eyeing the internet of things, managed security, cloud and artificial intelligence domains. Investment in these newer services along with ongoing transformation of internal processes would involve substantial capital and operating expenditure, and keep margins under pressure. “We have lowered margin expansion estimates as investments in new services and digital transformation may restrict the margins in the medium term,” says Bhupendra Tiwary, Analyst, ICICI Direct. Meanwhile, any progress on demerger of its land parcel will boost the stock’s performance.

Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (14)

Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (15)

TVS Motor: Margins expected to rise gradually
The GST regime has reduced the effective rate of taxation on two-wheelers, and the company has passed on the entire benefit of tax cuts to its customers. It has slashed prices by an average 1.5-2%. While TVS Motor has successful brands, their market share is significantly lower than that of the market leader in the respective segments. While the company surpassed Hero Motocorp in scooter sales in the June quarter, Honda Motor still rules the scooter market. The company intends to prioritise market share gains over near-term margins, by ramping up its flagship brands Jupiter (scooter) and Apache (motorcycle) through focused marketing and regular product interventions. It plans to launch a scooter and a motorcycle in the 125cc segment this year. This would keep marketing spends higher in the near term, and margins muted. The company will also invest Rs 500 crore this year to ramp up production capacity towards the new products and development of new engines. “While the company’s margins are likely to rise gradually, double-digit margins should be achievable only during 2018-19,” says Chirag Jain, Analyst, SBICap Securities.

Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (16)
Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (17)
Stock market: Contrarian views on Reliance Ind, Crompton, Tata Communications, 5 other stocks: Should you invest? (2024)

FAQs

Is contrarian investing good? ›

Note that contrarian investing can be risky. Areas are often out of favor for a reason, such as a history of underperformance. Contrarian investment ideas may continue to underperform for extended periods.

Who is the best contrarian investor? ›

Buffett has been one of the best at spotting undervalued companies and investing in them when others are selling or holding. Another famous contrarian investor is Sir John Templeton, founder of the Templeton Growth Fund.

What are the contrarian indicators of the stock market? ›

Commonly used contrarian indicators for investor sentiment are Volatility Indexes (informally also referred to as "Fear indexes"), like VIX, which by tracking the prices of financial options, gives a numeric measure of how pessimistic or optimistic market actors at large are.

What is contrarian investing in the stock market? ›

Contrarian investing involves a strategy where investors intentionally go against prevailing market trends. This means that instead of following the crowd, contrarians seek opportunities in undervalued or unpopular assets, anticipating a future reversal in sentiment.

What does Warren Buffett recommend investing in? ›

Key Points. Warren Buffett made his fortune by investing in individual companies with great long-term advantages. But his top recommendation for anyone is to buy a simple index fund. Buffett's recommendation underscores the importance of diversification.

Is contrarian trading profitable? ›

The contrarian sees buying opportunities in stocks that are currently selling for below their intrinsic value. Being a contrarian can be rewarding, but it is often a risky strategy that may take a long period of time to pay off.

Who is the most successful contrarian investor? ›

1. Warren Buffett: Perhaps the most famous contrarian investor of all time, Warren Buffett has built his fortune by taking positions in undervalued companies when others were selling. One notable example is his investment in American Express during the 1960s.

Who is the most successful stock investor of all time? ›

Warren Buffett is widely considered the greatest investor in the world.

Who is the No 1 investor in world? ›

Warren Buffett is widely considered to be the most successful investor in history. Not only is he one of the richest men in the world, but he also has had the financial ear of numerous presidents and world leaders.

What is a strong bullish contrarian indicator? ›

A Contrarian Indicator

An extremely high put-call ratio means the market is extremely bearish. To a contrarian, that can be a bullish signal that indicates the market is unduly bearish and is due for a turnaround. A high ratio can be a sign of a buying opportunity to a contrarian.

What indicators does Warren Buffett use? ›

The so-called Buffett indicator compares the total market capitalization (share prices times outstanding shares) of all U.S. stocks with the quarterly output of the U.S. economy.

How to do contrarian trading? ›

In terms of investing, a contrarian investor is someone who trades against prevailing market sentiments. When the market buys, the contrarian sells, and vice-versa. Contrarian investors look for opportunities to buy in a bear market and opportunities to sell in a bull market.

What does Warren Buffett look at when buying stocks? ›

Over the decades, Buffett has refined a holistic approach to assessing a company—looking not just at earnings, but its overall health, its deficiencies as well as its strengths. He focuses more on a company's characteristics and less on its stock price, waiting to buy only when the cost seems reasonable.

What is the 1% rule in stock trading? ›

The 1% risk rule means not risking more than 1% of account capital on a single trade. It doesn't mean only putting 1% of your capital into a trade. Put as much capital as you wish, but if the trade is losing more than 1% of your total capital, close the position.

Which investment is the riskiest for investors? ›

The 10 Riskiest Investments
  1. Options. An option allows a trader to hold a leveraged position in an asset at a lower cost than buying shares of the asset. ...
  2. Futures. ...
  3. Oil and Gas Exploratory Drilling. ...
  4. Limited Partnerships. ...
  5. Penny Stocks. ...
  6. Alternative Investments. ...
  7. High-Yield Bonds. ...
  8. Leveraged ETFs.

Is investing $1,000 good? ›

While starting with $1,000 may not sound like much in the grand scheme of things, you can grow your money over time and create a better financial future for yourself and your loved ones. In fact, it's never been cheaper or easier to be a new investor, and you have many great ways to start.

What is the rule #1 of value investing? ›

Rule #1, as famed investor Warren Buffett will tell you, is don't lose money. Through an intriguing process that I'll clarify in this book, not losing money results in making more money than you ever imagined.

Do contrarian investors consider a high put call ratio? ›

A high ratio suggests that there is a greater volume of puts, indicating that investors are possibly hedging or speculating on a market decline. However, contrarian investors often read this as an overly pessimistic sentiment and anticipate a potential market turnaround or rally, hence deeming it a bullish signal.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Zonia Mosciski DO

Last Updated:

Views: 5659

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Zonia Mosciski DO

Birthday: 1996-05-16

Address: Suite 228 919 Deana Ford, Lake Meridithberg, NE 60017-4257

Phone: +2613987384138

Job: Chief Retail Officer

Hobby: Tai chi, Dowsing, Poi, Letterboxing, Watching movies, Video gaming, Singing

Introduction: My name is Zonia Mosciski DO, I am a enchanting, joyous, lovely, successful, hilarious, tender, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.