Reader Question: What Is the Best Thing to Do With an Old 403(b)? - Good Financial Cents® (2024)

Well, whether you need PROFESSIONAL professional help is up for debate, but when it comes to your finances, don’t rely on Google.

You need someone who knows what they’re doing.

Consider this example:

I am 45 years old with 3 young children. My biggest concern is that in about 10-12 years, they will be going to college. I have a good job and currently make $75,000 per year.

I don’t have college savings plans set up for them at the moment. I’m considering opening a Roth IRA and maxing it out every year so they use it for college.

I also have an old 403b just sitting there doing nothing. I’m maxing out my 401(k) at my current job, which also offers an 8% match. Would you please advise what I should do for my children and for my retirement? Also, do you think I should convert my old 403b into a Roth IRA?

Ah yes.

These are the types of questions that a Certified Financial Planner drools over.

Why?Because there’s so much going on in this person’s situation it justifieswhy people need financial planners.

If I were meeting with this client in my office or over Skype, this is how I would go about the meeting.

Should She Use Her Roth IRA for College Savings?

It’s a little-known fact that you can actually use a Roth IRA to pay for college-related expenses.Most people think of Roth IRAs as a retirement savings vehicle, which it is, but you can pull out any gains to pay for education without incurring any tax or penalty.

Even though that’s the case, I’m typically not a big fan of co-mingling retirement savings with college savings.

I have a lot of clients who are parents who are very ambitious in saving for their kid’s college and don’t do a good job of saving for their own retirement.

They do so with good intentions of trying to prevent their child from incurring an exorbitantamount of student loan debt, so what happens is that if they don’t save enough for their own retirement.

Then later on in life, they’re going to be dependent on their kids because they don’t have enough savings.I’m all about trying to help your kid; pay for your kid’s college, if you’re so inclined, but not at the sacrifice of your own retirement. I discussed this in a previous video:

In this person’s case, I would suggest that she look into setting up a 529 college savings plan. I mentioned in a previous post the four ways that you can save for college; the 529 college savings plan is what we are using for our three boys currently.

It operates much like a Roth IRA in the fact that any distributions, as long as they are for college-related expenses, are completely tax-free. Which is freakin’ sweet!

The other huge benefit of the 529 plan is that the parents, or in this case, the mom, will be in control of the money even afterthe child turns 18.

If the child decides they don’t want to go to college, they want to cash out to start their own rock band, they won’t have the ability to do so because Mom’s in control. Parental control is a beautiful thing. 🙂

What About Converting a 403(b) to a Roth IRA?

That’s the million-dollar question, and it’s a very difficult one to answer.

First, we need to get an idea of what we’re actually investing into so that after the conversion, the investment has to grow; what’s our current tax rate, how much tax will we pay on the amount that we convert; and how long is it going to sit into the account?

For a Roth IRA conversion to make sense, you don’t want to have to pay a lot of tax on the conversion, and you need ample time for the investments to grow to offset how much tax you had to pay to convert.

It’s not a clear-cut answer, and based on the lack of information I have in this situation, it’s hard for me to make that recommendation.

Typically,when people realize they have to pay the tax out of pocket for it to make sense to do the conversion, it usually doesn’t make sense for the client’s current income needs.

With the old 403(b), I would suggest that she roll it into an IRA to have better control of the investments.

It doesn’t sound like she’s reviewed the investments in a while, so it definitely would help to have a financial planner review those investments and make sure that they are still in line withher current goals.

If you’re not sure if your risk tolerance is in line with your goals, fill out this questionnaire that will take you less than 3 minutes to find your risk number.

Make Sure She Reviews Her 401(k) Annually

I love the fact that she’s maxing out her 401(k) and getting that match.Free money is sweet, and saving for her retirement is even sweeter.

I would want to encourage her to make sure that she reviews her 401(k) at least annually.I have a 401(k) review service, because I feel it’s extremely important that people go over their 401(k)s.

I’ve seen too many instances where people are investing blindly into these retirement accounts, and they have no clue of what they’re actually investing into.

Making small tweaks in that 401(k) can yield tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of dollars more waiting for retirement.Hire a financial planner to review your 401(k) annually, as well as your other investments.

What About Life Insurance?

Although this wasn’t asked, one immediate thought that I had was having three young children, I hope that this mother has life insurance on herself.

It sounds like she’s very determined to help pay for her kids’ college, so taking out a 20-year term policy, that would be enough to pay all her debts and have a good amount to pay for all three kids’ college, would be highly suggested.

Just to give you an idea, a 20-year term policy for $500,000 on a 45-year-old female would cost roughly $625 per year.

That’s it. Here’s a look at the top companies with the cheapest rates:

Find the Right Answer for Your Situation

The one standard that holds true in all situations in regard to financial planning is that there isn’t one right answer.Every situation is different, and as you can see by the example above, there are many different scenarios that we can go with.

My biggest situation for this individual is that they take the time to sit down with a financial planner to make sure that they’re doing things right. Make that a priority, and review their plan at a minimum on an annual basis.

Do you have a question like this? Feel free to “Ask Jeff” and I’ll do my best to get back to you in 24 hours.

The Bottom Line – Reader Question: What Is the Best Thing to Do With an Old 403(b)?

There’s rarely a one-size-fits-all solution. When it comes to dealing with an old 403(b) account, it’s crucial to consider your individual goals and circ*mstances.

Prioritizing your retirement savings should generally take precedence over funding your children’s education to avoid jeopardizing your own financial security.

While converting a 403(b) to a Roth IRA can be advantageous, it’s a decision best made after consulting a financial professional. Periodic review of your 401(k) is essential, and life insurance is crucial when you have dependents.

Ultimately, seek personalized advice to craft a strategy that aligns with your unique financial journey.