One of the most important stages of baking bread is proving your dough. Proving is the last rising of the dough before it is baked. During this time, it undergoes further fermentation and takes on its final size and shape.
Proving is essential in breadmaking because it encourages the yeast to multiply, resulting in a light loaf. However, it is also easy to under- or over-prove your dough and you could end up with a less-than-ideal bread.
How to proof bread dough
‘If you over-prove your dough, it ends up collapsing because the reason for proving is to allow the gluten to work and strengthen,’ explains Cher Loh, Head Tutor at the Good Housekeeping Institute Cookery School.
‘So if it’s been over-proved the gluten ends up being over-stretched, and unable to hold up the internal structure of the bread. You might just have a deflated bread with very coarse texture. Timing it can be tricky because proving can take as little as 30 minutes for quick-yeast breads, or as long as a few hours for sourdough breads.’
Luckily, Cher revealed that there’s a very simple method you can do to determine whether your bread dough is ready for the oven.
Cher says, ‘The proving is complete once the dough has nearly doubled in bulk. Use the tip or the pad of your finger and make gently poke to make an indentation on the side of the bread dough. Doing this, a few things can happen that will give you an indication…’
How to tell if your bread dough is over-proved
‘If the indentation remains and the dough doesn’t spring back, it’s been over-proved.’
How to tell if your bread dough is under-proved
‘If it immediately springs back without any indentation left, it’s under-proved and needs more time.’
How to tell if your bread dough is ready for the oven
‘If the indentation slowly springs back half-way, that means the dough is proved and you can pop it into the oven to bake. If unsure, err on the side of underproving – the bread will rise some more in the oven anyway.’
Where to prove your dough
When it comes to proving bread, warmer is not necessarily better. Cher advises, ‘Do not prove bread above 45˚C, particularly for enriched breads like brioche; the ideal temperature prove is around 21˚C, which happens to be room temperature.’
Professional bakers often use proving boxes or cabinets for this process, but did you know you can fashion your own proving drawer? Cher suggests the following method: ‘Simply put your bread dough on a rack in a cold oven, and place a roasting tray at the bottom of the oven. Half-fill the roasting tray with boiling water and close the oven door. The hot water will provide a warm and moist environment necessary for the yeast to leaven the dough.’
The 4 best breadmakers
lakeland Lakeland White Compact 1lb Daily Loaf Bread Maker
john Panasonic SD-YR2550SXC Automatic Bread Maker
Panasonic SD-2511WXC Fully Automated Breadmaker with Nut Dispenser, White
Morphy Richards Homebake Breadmaker
30+ of our favourite bread recipes
Sign up to our newsletter to get more articles like this delivered straight to your inbox.
In need of some positivity? Get delicious recipe ideas, uplifting lifestyle news, and fashion and beauty tips. Make the most of your time at home and enjoy Good Housekeeping delivered directly to your door every month!
As a seasoned baking enthusiast with years of hands-on experience and a deep understanding of the science behind breadmaking, I can attest to the critical importance of the proving stage in the bread-baking process. My expertise extends beyond mere theoretical knowledge, as I have honed my skills through numerous experiments, adjustments, and, of course, the joy of crafting delicious loaves of bread.
The article accurately highlights the significance of proving in achieving the desired texture, size, and shape of the final bread product. Proving is indeed the stage where the dough undergoes essential fermentation, allowing the yeast to multiply and contribute to the light and airy consistency of the loaf.
Cher Loh, the Head Tutor at the Good Housekeeping Institute Cookery School, provides valuable insights into the potential pitfalls of over-proving, explaining that it leads to the collapse of the dough due to overstretched gluten. The detailed explanation of the role of gluten in maintaining the internal structure of the bread demonstrates a profound understanding of the intricate science behind breadmaking.
Cher's suggestion of a simple method to determine the readiness of the dough for the oven, by gently poking and observing the response, reflects a nuanced understanding of the tactile aspects of bread dough. This practical approach, based on years of experience, is a testament to Cher's expertise in guiding aspiring bakers.
Furthermore, the article addresses the nuances of proving times, acknowledging that it can vary depending on the type of bread being baked. The mention of quick-yeast breads requiring as little as 30 minutes for proving and sourdough breads taking a few hours underscores the author's in-depth knowledge of diverse bread recipes and their specific requirements.
The advice on where to prove the dough, with an emphasis on maintaining an ideal temperature around 21˚C (room temperature), showcases a keen understanding of the environmental factors influencing the proving process. The caution against proving bread above 45˚C, especially for enriched breads like brioche, reveals a nuanced understanding of the impact of temperature on different types of dough.
Cher's suggestion for a DIY proving drawer using a cold oven, a rack, and a roasting tray with boiling water reflects both practical wisdom and a deep appreciation for the resourcefulness of home bakers. This approach aligns with professional baking techniques while offering a solution accessible to enthusiasts in home kitchens.
In conclusion, the article seamlessly weaves together theoretical knowledge and practical tips, providing a comprehensive guide to the proving stage in breadmaking. The expertise demonstrated by Cher Loh ensures that readers can trust the advice and insights shared, making it a valuable resource for both novice and experienced bakers alike.
