Homeowners Complaint Composite Report (2024)

50 Large Homeowners Insurers Licensed to Conduct Business in California

Ratio for Complaint Years 2022, 2021, and 2020

TheHomeowners Complaint Composite report is also available as a single pagePDF format.

2022 RankCompany Name2022 Approx. Exposure
Count
Justified Complaint
Ratio
Number of Justified Complaints
202220212020202220212020
1Garrison Property and Casualty Insurance Company115,0660.00.93.0013
282,7490.03.20.0020
3Safeco Insurance Company of Illinois58,4020.00.01.8001
4Century National Insurance Company55,0450.00.02.7001
5AMCO Insurance Company45,0970.08.812.4058
6Interinsurance Exchange of the Automobile Club865,4330.92.02.681621
7California Automobile Insurance Company638,3470.91.81.36118
8First National Insurance Company of America100,8371.06.20.0160
9Foremost Insurance Company Grand Rapids, Michigan277,1741.11.62.8346
1079,2191.35.01.2141
11ASI Select Insurance Corp.71,5531.44.96.1133
12State Farm General Insurance Company2,293,7181.42.21.4335031
13USAA General Indemnity Company122,5831.61.62.5223
14Safeco Insurance Company of America301,4751.72.40.7572
15USAA Casualty Insurance Company228,0871.82.61.8464
16Fire Ins Exch911,2961.81.41.4161314
17Stillwater Insurance Company107,8031.92.58.0225
18Wawanesa General Insurance Co.51,1892.03.70.0120
19American Modern Insurance Company50,1402.00.04.0102
20Kemper Independence Insurance Company45,1512.28.27.3144
21CSAA Insurance Exchange621,9842.32.75.8141736
22Integon National Insurance Company84,2442.44.614.42415
23American Security Insurance Company 79,7722.58.12.7262
24Homesite Insurance Company of California236,9572.52.74.2668
25General Insurance Company of America192,7022.63.72.6564
26The Standard Fire Insurance Company326,2752.81.38.4921
27United Services Automobile Association207,0642.92.30.9652
28California Capital Ins Co60,1833.310.937.82727
29American Bankers Insurance Company 231,3723.56.42.98146
30Allstate Insurance Company717,2603.55.73.4254024
31American Family Connect Property and Casualty Insurance Company109,1243.77.91.2471
32CSE Safeguard Insurance Company49,9944.04.71.4231
33Liberty Insurance Corporation240,3204.23.62.61097
34Mid Century Ins Co224,1344.50.85.910216
35Farmers Ins Exch403,0564.52.31.41884
36Lemonade Insurance Company327,3054.99.06.1162513
37Farmers Direct Property and Casualty Insurance Company39,1305.12.62.7211
38Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company214,0125.111.31.611253
39Residence Mutual Insurance Company52,9145.71.80.0310
40Pacific Specialty Insruance 191,3016.36.33.912128
41Homesite Insurance Company of the Midwest57,6896.911.36.5452
4249,3608.111.210.2466
43Amica Mutual Insurance Company36,5828.28.12.7331
44California Cas Ind Exch60,6798.29.91.6561
45QBE Insurance Corporation47,1628.58.44.0442
46American Modern Property and Casualty Insurance Company105,0289.517.211.2102011
47Zurich American Insurance Company64,68013.99.35.7952
48Universal North America Insurance Company46,99321.37.06.01044
49Spinnaker Insurance Company107,95321.34.20.02330
50AMGUARD INSURANCE COMPANY49,29226.429.813.313123

Note: Complaint Ratio is based on the number of Justified Complaints to 100,000 Earned Exposures. Exposures include renters, mobile homes, and condos.

Other Complaint Composite Reports:

  • Individual Life Complaint Composite Study
  • Automobile Complaint Composite Study

If the company does not appear on the composite report, please do the following:

  1. Go to Company Profile.

  2. Type in the company's name in the field provided and select "Get Company".

  3. Select the company that you want information on. This will take you to the company's profile.

  4. On the left hand column under "Consumer Complaint," please select "Company Performance & Comparison Data".

  5. The next web page will display the company's performance and comparison data.

If you have any questions regarding this web page or composite report, please contact the Department's Data Analytics and Reporting.

Back to Top

Homeowners Complaint Composite Report (2024)

FAQs

Why would a home insurance claim be denied? ›

A claim could be denied due to lack of coverage, homeowner negligence, missing a filing deadline or not having enough documentation.

How to negotiate a homeowners insurance claim? ›

When negotiating with the adjuster, be prepared to advocate for yourself. Be polite and professional, but don't be afraid to push back if you think the settlement offer is too low. Provide evidence to support your position, and be willing to compromise to reach a mutually acceptable agreement.

What is the justified complaint ratio? ›

The justified complaint ratio is based on the number of justified complaints per 100,000 policies or exposures. For those companies without a ratio, ranking is done by the policy or exposure count.

What insurance company has the most complaints? ›

United Automobile Insurance

What not to say to a home insurance adjuster? ›

Admitting Fault, Even Partial Fault.

Avoid any language that could be construed as apologetic or blameful.

How do you argue with a home insurance adjuster? ›

Once you've compiled evidence to support your case, submit an appeal in writing to your insurance company. Explain your point of view, include supporting documentation, and request that the adjuster review the claim.

How do you respond to a lowball offer from an insurance company? ›

If you have determined to respond to a low settlement offer yourself, consider the following:
  1. Stay polite and professional. We understand it's a frustrating and emotional process. ...
  2. Ask questions. ...
  3. Offer the facts. ...
  4. Put your response in writing. ...
  5. Don't be bullied.

How to negotiate a higher settlement? ›

How to Negotiate the Best Deal on Your Settlement Agreement
  1. Prepare Well for the Settlement Agreement Negotiation. ...
  2. Decide which negotiation tactics to use. ...
  3. Ask for a Protected Conversation with your Employer. ...
  4. Don't ask for too much. ...
  5. Don't ask for too little. ...
  6. Find out how the settlement payments will be taxed.

How many claims before homeowners insurance cancels? ›

More than two claims in a five-year period may make it difficult to find coverage.

What is a normal complaint rate? ›

A "normal" complaint rate is considered to be 0.02% - 1 complaint per 4000-5000 emails delivered. The highest threshold we recommend is 0.1% - 1 complaint per 1000 emails delivered.

What is the resolution of a complaint? ›

Complaint resolution refers to the process wherein complaints are recognized, and the parties concerned agree on an acceptable end for the situation. Complaints indicate a gap between consumer expectations and delivery.

What makes a complaint justified? ›

Justified complaint: This is a complaint when one has a good reason for lodging a complaint. It is complaint that has good defendable basis and can easily defend with all confidence. Example is delivery of goods if faulty or damaged.

What insurance company denies the most claims? ›

Claim denial rates by insurance company
CompanyClaim denials
UnitedHealthcare32%
Anthem23%
Aetna20%
CareSource20%
1 more row
Apr 24, 2024

Which company got the fewest complaints for home insurance? ›

Erie Insurance, Amica, and Nationwide are the three best insurance companies for home insurance claims satisfaction in J.D. Power's 2023 Property Claims Satisfaction study, the most recent.

Which insurance company has the fewest complaints? ›

Best Car Insurance Companies of May 2024
Best car insurance categoryCompany winner
Best insurance company for having few customer complaintsAmerican Family
Best insurance company for financial strengthAuto-Owners
Best insurance company for discountsAmica
Best insurance company for customer satisfactionState Farm
4 more rows
6 days ago

How often do home insurance claims get denied? ›

Homeowners insurance claims are denied every day — sometimes legitimately, sometimes in error, and sometimes for reasons no one understands.

What makes an insurance company deny a claim? ›

Insurance claims are often denied if there is a dispute as to fault or liability. Companies will only agree to pay you if there's clear evidence to show that their policyholder is to blame for your injuries.

Which insurance company denies most claims? ›

Claim denial rates by insurance company
CompanyClaim denials
UnitedHealthcare32%
Anthem23%
Aetna20%
CareSource20%
1 more row
Apr 24, 2024

How does making a claim affect my home insurance? ›

Filing a claim increases your risk in the eyes of your insurance provider, and as your risk goes up, so do your premiums. You can expect to see a rate increase of 9% to 20% per claim, though this number varies by the type of claim and the number of claims you've filed previously.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Golda Nolan II

Last Updated:

Views: 6254

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (78 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Golda Nolan II

Birthday: 1998-05-14

Address: Suite 369 9754 Roberts Pines, West Benitaburgh, NM 69180-7958

Phone: +522993866487

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Worldbuilding, Shopping, Quilting, Cooking, Homebrewing, Leather crafting, Pet

Introduction: My name is Golda Nolan II, I am a thoughtful, clever, cute, jolly, brave, powerful, splendid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.