GIC alternatives for investors who put safety first. Plus, David Rosenberg’s outlook for 2024 (2024)

High interest rates explain a lot of the money pouring into guaranteed investment certificates these days, and so does the safety factor.

But some conservative investors don’t find GICs to be the ideal fit. One such person got in touch recently for some thoughts on how to park some cash in “something that is very safe and secure right now.” GICs were rejected because of deposit insurance limits. What about treasury bills or exchange-traded funds holding T-bills, this reader asked.

T-bills issued by the federal government are not deposit-insured, but they’re backed by Ottawa’s AAA credit rating from DBRS and the power to increase taxes if needed to meet its debt obligations. Arguably, a T-bill offers a slightly lower risk profile than a GIC because there’s no risk of uncertainty caused by the collapse of a GIC-issuing bank.

The issue with T-bills for investors is that they must be purchased through online brokers who may not offer the best pricing. The more you pay for a T-bill, or bond, the lower the yield you get. One particular online broker had a one-year federal government T-bill available this week with a yield of 4.45 per cent. One-year GICs were available at the same time with yields around 6 per cent.

T-bills do offer better liquidity than traditional GICs, and better rates than cashable GICs. That same online broker’s inventory of one-year cashable GICs paid no more than 3.35 per cent.

One way to squeeze more yield from T-bills is to buy a money market ETF that holds them as well as other short-term borrowings from the corporate sector. Money market ETFs have distribution yields of 4.9 to 5.4 per cent, which reflects the modestly higher risk level of holding debt assets issued by companies rather than governments. As with T-bills themselves, T-bill and money market funds do not offer deposit insurance.

A few other thoughts on T-bills and GICs:

-The minimum GIC purchase can be as low as $500 or $1,000 to $3,500 and up, while brokers typically require a minimum T-bill purchase of $5,000 or $10,000

-Deposit insurance from Canada Deposit Insurance Corp. applies to various eligible accounts held by the same person, so it may extend further than you might think.

-One more alternative to consider is the investment savings account, which is bought and sold like a mutual fund and offers CDIC-protected accounts with yields of 4.55 per cent to 4.75 per cent.

-- Rob Carrick, personal finance columnist

This is the Globe Investor newsletter, published three times each week. If someone has forwarded this e-mail newsletter to you or you’re reading this on the web, you can sign up for the newsletter and others on our newsletter signup page.

Stocks to ponder

Bird Construction Inc. (BDT-T) Year-to-date, this industrial stock is up 51 per cent, making it the 14th-best performing stock out of 247 stocks in the S&P/TSX SmallCap Index. Last week, the company reported better-than-expected third-quarter financial results for the fifth consecutive quarter. As a result, earnings estimates and target prices were revised higher. The stock has a unanimous buy recommendation from eight analysts and a 12-month forecast price return of 22 per cent, not including the 3.5-per-cent dividend yield. For now, the stock trades at a reasonable valuation, relatively in-line with its five-year historical average. Jennifer Dowty delves into the investment case.

Moderna Inc. (MRNA-Q) One glance at its stock chart can tell you the story of the COVID-19 pandemic. It’s all there, starting with the rumblings in the pharma company’s share price in early 2020 as a mysterious flu in Wuhan, China, began to set off red flags. Then the quick emergence of a boom in pharma stocks. Finally, there was a long selloff as the crisis was subsumed into daily life. The rise and fall of Moderna’s share price is not just a remarkable distillation of how a global disaster played out in the stock market. As Tim Shufelt reports, it should also serve as a reminder that investing themes are perishable, even if it feels in the moment like this time is truly different.

Also see: Investors in thematic funds hurt returns by trading too frequently, says Morningstar

Encore Energy Corp. (EU-X) EnCore is an emerging uranium producer with operations in the United States. Year-to-date, the share price has rallied 62 per cent, and as Jennifer Dowty tells us in this review of the investment case, the stock has a couple of near-term catalysts that may lift it even higher.

The Rundown

David Rosenberg on how to invest as 2024 nears

A downdraft in resource prices, the loosening of global supply bottlenecks, and slack re-emerging in the labour market will usher in a further deceleration in inflation that will surprise the legion of bond bears out there, says the famed economist as he looks into his crystal ball. That means buying opportunities in bonds, as interest rates are slashed faster than what the market currently expects. And only certain select areas of the stock market are poised to do well.

Also see:

Billionaire quant Cliff Asness says he is ‘more a bond guy’ at this moment

Stocks to outperform fixed income in 2024, says Barclays

Why debt doom fears are beyond wrong … and bullish for markets

Debt got you down? Are North American governments – and consumers – living on borrowed time? With interest rates up, folks fear a reckoning. But Ken Fisher sees things quite differently. U.S. or Canadian, government or consumer, these debts aren’t near any looming calamity, the billionaire investor says. Markets see this clearly, while most people can’t.

Geopolitical angst more a market feature than shock

Even with two geopolitically risky wars raging and a series of critical elections next year, there’s little in annual outlooks suggesting investors should head for the bunkers. Judging by a torrent of 2024 investment advisories already filling inboxes, anxious geopolitics - turbulent for over five years amid trade wars, a pandemic, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the Israel-Hamas war - is now almost considered a constant to be navigated rather than a reason to go to ground, says Mike Dolan of Reuters.

U.S. high-yield bond market may hold less junk than before

The U.S. high yield bond market is the dog that has rarely barked, never mind bitten, during the Federal Reserve’s most aggressive interest rate-raising campaign in 40 years. The economy’s remarkable resilience to that monetary tightening, and cooling inflation, are the obvious explanations why spreads have remained well behaved. But as Jamie McGeever reports, the ‘junk’ bond market may also contain less junk than it used to.

Others (for subscribers)

Number Cruncher: 11 high-quality U.S. stocks benefiting from the AI trend

Scott Barlow’s Noteworthy: Cheap bank stocks are worth a look and other research highlights

Canadian ETFs: An avalanche of 37 new funds, many with active strategies

Friday’s Insider Report: CEO invests $1.3-million in this dividend stock recently hitting a 52-week high

Friday’s analyst upgrades and downgrades

Thursday’s analyst upgrades and downgrades

Ted Dixon: Petrus Resources CEO and director buy after dividend news

Monica Rizk: Bullish on Onex Corp.

Globe Advisor

Why this $75-billion money manager is adding U.S. assets and selling Canadian banks

This advisor learned early on never to act on a friend’s unproven stock tips

Are you a financial advisor? Register for Globe Advisor (www.globeadvisor.com) for free daily and weekly newsletters, in-depth industry coverage and analysis.

What’s up in the days ahead

David Berman will explain why Teck Resources without coal assets could be an investor’s dream. Plus, Ian McGugan has a reality check on the latest happy mood in markets and John Heinzl provides his latest thoughts on Brookfield Infrastructure and its poor performance of late.

Black Friday is (almost) here: World market themes for the week ahead

Click here to see the Globe Investor earnings and economic news calendar.

More Globe Investor coverage

For more Globe Investor stories, follow us on Twitter @globeinvestor

Compiled by Globe Investor Staff

GIC alternatives for investors who put safety first. Plus, David Rosenberg’s outlook for 2024 (2024)

FAQs

What is the alternative to GICs? ›

That said, there are two competing systems for classifying stocks into sectors and industries: the Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) and the Industrial Classification Benchmark (ICB). Both were designed to provide an accurate and standardized industry definition for use by the global investment community.

Will GICs go up in 2024? ›

Market analysts and senior economists largely anticipate that there will not be further rate hikes, with the first rate drop expected mid-2024. The economy is projected to continue cooling down and bring inflation back to the BoC's 2.0% target by early 2025.

What is the GIC for Canada 2024? ›

It is a liquid investment which is popularly known as a guaranteed Investment Certificate that covers the annual expenses of a student studying in a Canadian university. The increased GIC amount for Canada is 20,635 (INR 12,71,619 Approx) effective from January 1, 2024.

Are GICs a good investment right now? ›

Since 2022, interest rates have been steadily rising1, which makes GICs a favourable investment. Purchasing a GIC now means you can lock in a higher interest rate and earn more money on your investment. GICs offer a greater rate of return than what you would earn from a savings account.

What is a better investment than GIC? ›

After-tax returns for bonds are better than for GICs. In a non-registered account, a discount bond with a YTM similar to that of a GIC can have a higher after-tax return (ATR), because 50% of capital gains are taxable.

What is the downside of a GIC? ›

Disadvantages of GICs

You'll need to lock your money for the entire term if you want to get the full return. The interest rate offered on GICs may not beat inflation.

How can I get 5% interest on my money? ›

You can earn 5% or more with several savings accounts, including the Milli Savings Account, Betterment Cash Reserve, Newtek Bank High Yield Savings Account, and more. You can also earn above 5% with several accounts through Raisin, an online savings marketplace that sets you up with high rates from partner banks.

What is the highest paying 5-year GIC rate in Canada? ›

For GICs with a 5-year term, Hubert Financial and Ideal Savings currently offer the highest rate at 4.75%.

Who has the best 5-year GIC? ›

Best Available 5-Year GIC Rates In Canada*
  • Wealth One Bank of Canada – 4.75%
  • ICICI Bank – 4.75%
  • EQ Bank – 4.55%
  • Hubert Financial and Ideal Savings – 4.50%
  • Oaken Financial – 4.50%
  • Peoples Trust Bank of Canada – 4.45%
  • Achieva Financial – 4.40%
  • Outlook Financial – 4.40%

Are GICs safe in a recession? ›

With a GIC, you're guaranteed to see returns and won't have to worry about the risks of cashing out your investments too early or at the “wrong time” when the market is down.

Is there a 10 year GIC? ›

GIC terms typically range from 30 days to 5 years, although 7 or 10-year terms are also available. That way, you can choose how long to invest. If you're saving for the long-term, consider a long-term GIC.

How long should I get a GIC for? ›

The bottom line

If you need access to your money soon, choose a short-term GIC or a high-interest savings account. If you're in it for the long haul and don't mind committing your cash for several years, GIC terms of up to 10 years are available. A GIC ladder offers a nice balance of the two but takes some maintenance.

Are GICs good for seniors? ›

Many seniors were comforted by higher GIC rates after years of relying on the volatility of stock and bond markets. GICs are relatively simple to buy online or through a local bank branch.

Why is it time to move out of GICs? ›

The bottom line is that GICs still hold considerable appeal for cautious investors. However, GICs have historically not been a great investment. Over the past 20 years, they have barely kept pace with inflation. Right now, other assets seem poised to produce superior returns.

Is 5% a good GIC rate? ›

GICs with terms of one, four and five years should offer the best returns, but that's not the case right now. Five per cent or slightly more is the best you can do from the many alternative players that compete with the big banks. On shorter terms, competition between all banks is fierce right now.

Is it better to buy bonds or GICs? ›

Bonds may offer potentially higher yields (interest rates) but will fluctuate in value. GICs provide a fixed yield because there is no market in which to sell the GICs. Thus, investors in bonds can see values fluctuate before maturity, while GIC investors will not see these fluctuations.

Why not to buy a GIC? ›

You are not able to take advantage of new investment opportunities. You will not lose any of your investment but you are not able to add to it. Some GICs may be purchased as cashable and redeemable but to have that flexibility you must accept a lower interest rate.

Is TFSA or GIC better? ›

GICs, or Guaranteed Investment Certificates, is a low-risk investment that's guaranteed to make interest as long as you leave the money alone. If you have medium-term goals, like getting a car, a TFSA or Tax-Free Savings Account is your best bet. Plus, any money you put away in a TFSA won't get taxed.

Are Treasury bills the same as GICs? ›

GICs are generally non-redeemable before the term is complete. Treasury bills (T-bills) are the safest type of short-term debt instrument issued by a federal government. Ideal for investors seeking a 1- to 12- month investment period, T-bills are highly liquid and very secure.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Cheryll Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 5569

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Cheryll Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-12-23

Address: 4653 O'Kon Hill, Lake Juanstad, AR 65469

Phone: +494124489301

Job: Marketing Representative

Hobby: Reading, Ice skating, Foraging, BASE jumping, Hiking, Skateboarding, Kayaking

Introduction: My name is Cheryll Lueilwitz, I am a sparkling, clean, super, lucky, joyous, outstanding, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.