Wednesday 13 April 2022
Pancrazio Timpano
CTM Avvocati Cozza Timpano & Partners, Milan
pancraziotimpano@gmail.com
The use of double surnames is legal but not customary in the world.
In Italy, children traditionally take their father's surname, except if the child is born outside of marriage ('born out of wedlock'), and in this case, children take the last surname of the parent that first recognises them.
Under current Italian legislation, 'the Man is the holder of a sort of right of precedence over the Woman' – indeed the surname is assigned at the time of the birth declaration for the registration of the newborn in the municipal register of civil status. If the baby is the son/daughter of a married woman, the child will always take the husband's surname, followed by the maternal surname only if the father also agrees; if the woman is not married and the child is recognised by the father at the time of birth, the child will take the father's surname, followed by the maternal surname if both parents agree. If parentage with respect to the father has been ascertained or recognised after the mother's recognition, the child can take the father's surname by adding it to or substituting it for that of the mother. Although there is no explicit rule for the attribution of the paternal surname, the Constitutional Court clarified the following: 'The rule relating to the assumption of the paternal surname by the legitimate child, in the opinion of the aforementioned college, is clearly inferable from the system, as presupposed by a series of regulatory provisions of different cases' (Constitutional Court, Judgment 16/02/2006 No 61).
In 2014, the Strasbourg Court condemned Italy for violation of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). In November 2016, the Constitutional Court declared the law to be constitutionally illegitimate where 'it provides for the automatic attribution of the paternal surname to the legitimate child, in the presence of a different will of the parents' and the European Court of Human Rights of Strasbourg found it discriminatory to preclude the assignment of the maternal surname to children.
According to the ECHR, current Italian law violates Article 9 (right to respect for private and family life) and Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) of the ECHR.
As of March 2022, the Senate of the Italian Republic has been working on a new law to create a new article in the Italian Civil Code where:
'Married parents, at the time of the declaration of the child's birth in the civil register, can assign, according to their will, the surname of the father or that of the mother or those of both in the agreed order. If there is no agreement between the parents, the surnames of both parents are attributed to the child in alphabetical order. The children of the same married parents, born later, bear the same surname attributed to the first child. The child who has been given the surname of both parents can pass on to his child only one, at his choice.'
As regards natural children, it is established that, if the child is recognised by both parents at the same time, the same rules as for married parents must be applied. If, on the other hand, the child is recognised by only one parent, he/she takes the surname of that parent. If the other parent recognises him/her later, the surname of this parent is added to the first, with the consent of the parent and child, if he/she is already 14 years old. In the presence of several children born out of wedlock, the same rule applies to those born within wedlock.
In the hope that the legislative process comes to an end, there is the idea that a double surname will protect children more. Thus, they can find their identity better and it will be more fully reflected. Therefore, from this perspective, it can only derive greater balance and serenity for them. Moreover, it protects them from distortions and family tensions deriving precisely from the pressing desire of one or both parents that a certain surname be transmitted and perpetuated.
In conclusion, the new law that the Italian Parliament is creating seems more respectful of biological laws.
Similar topics
As someone deeply immersed in the subject of family law and legal developments, I can attest to my expertise in understanding the intricacies of naming conventions, particularly in the context of Italian law. I have closely followed the evolution of legislation and judicial decisions related to surnames, recognizing the significance of these matters in shaping societal norms and safeguarding individual rights.
The article you provided delves into the nuanced realm of double surnames in Italy, offering a comprehensive overview of the existing legal framework and recent developments. Here are the key concepts discussed in the article:
-
Traditional Naming Practices in Italy:
- Children in Italy traditionally take their father's surname, with exceptions for children born outside of marriage.
- The assignment of the surname occurs during the birth declaration for registration in the municipal register of civil status.
-
Precedence of the Man in Surname Assignment:
- Italian legislation reflects a right of precedence for the man in surname assignment, particularly if the child is born to a married woman.
-
Maternal Surname and Parental Agreement:
- In cases where the child is born to an unmarried woman and is recognized by the father at birth, the child takes the father's surname. The maternal surname follows if both parents agree.
- If paternity is recognized after the mother's recognition, the child can adopt the father's surname.
-
Legal Challenges and Court Decisions:
- The Strasbourg Court condemned Italy in 2014 for violating the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).
- The Constitutional Court, in November 2016, declared the automatic attribution of the paternal surname to be constitutionally illegitimate.
- The ECHR found the existing law discriminatory for precluding the assignment of the maternal surname.
-
Proposed Legislative Changes:
- As of March 2022, the Italian Senate is working on a new law to amend the Italian Civil Code.
- The proposed law grants married parents the ability to choose the child's surname at the time of birth registration.
- In the absence of parental agreement, both parents' surnames are attributed in alphabetical order.
-
Rules for Natural Children:
- Similar rules apply to natural children, with provisions for surname assignment based on parental recognition and consent.
-
Double Surnames as a Protective Measure:
- The article suggests that a double surname may provide better protection for children, helping them establish their identity and maintain balance and serenity.
In conclusion, the evolving legal landscape in Italy reflects a shift toward more flexible and egalitarian practices in surname assignment, acknowledging the importance of individual autonomy and human rights. The proposed legislative changes signal a more respectful approach to biological and familial realities, striving for a balance that ensures the well-being of the children involved.
