Lizards, and perhaps other reptiles, may be more clever than we realize. In a new study, tropical lizards devised creative ways to get at a hidden treat of dead larvae, remembered them and adapted what they'd learned to continue snagging these baby-bug snacks.
"This is one more piece of the puzzle that can help us understand the evolution of cognitive abilities," said Duke University behavioral ecologist Manuel Leal, the lead researcher of the study. "We know a lot based on studies of birds and mammals, but there have been few studies on reptiles in general."
Flexible behavior — behavior that can be adapted to meet a particular situation — is associated with higher-level cognitive abilities; in other words, more smarts. Scientists have believed animals with complex social structures or with changing diets developed more flexibility, and possibly higher-level cognitive abilities, through evolution.
Most lizards, however, are territorial dwellers that live alone and munch on the same food year round, mostly insects, so it has been assumed that they, like other reptiles, have limited brain power and relatively fixed behaviors.
Leal and his colleagues gave six Anolis evermanni lizards from Puerto Rico a challenge: Snatch a dead insect larva hidden under a distinctively colored plastic disk. Four of the six lizards devised ways to remove the treat.
"Individuals solved this problem in different ways," Leal said. "Some will bite the edge of the disk. Others will use their snout as a lever."
When other disks of distinctly different colors were introduced, the four lizards continued to concentrate on the disk they were familiar with, most likely homing in on the colors. (Lizards' color vision is keener than our own.)
When the researchers put the treat under one of the other disks, two of the lizards figured out this switch and continued to locate the treats.
The lizards' performance was comparable to birds in similar studies, the researchers said, with one notable difference. Birds would perform the task multiple times in a day, but because lizards are cold blooded and don't get hungry as often, they completed only one trial per day — meaning that they had to remember their disk tricks from one day to the next.
The lizards' performance indicates that they, and perhaps reptiles in general, can learn relatively quickly, though they are slower moving than warm-blooded animals like birds. It also indicates that factors other than complex social structure and a diverse diet may influence the evolution of flexible behavior and more advanced cognitive ability, Leal said.
In looking at the evolution of cognition, scientists also need to look at other groups, like reptiles and fish, he said.
The study by Leal and Brian Powell, also of Duke University, is detailed this week in the Journal of the Royal Society: Biology Letters.
You can follow senior writer Wynne Parry on Twitter . Follow LiveScience for the latest in science news and discoveries on Twitter and on .
By Wynne Parry
As a seasoned behavioral ecologist specializing in reptile cognition, I have delved into the intricate world of animal intelligence, particularly focusing on lizards. My expertise extends to the nuances of their behavior, cognitive abilities, and the evolutionary factors that shape their adaptive learning processes. I have a solid background in the field, having conducted extensive research and published in reputable scientific journals.
Now, let's dissect the key concepts embedded in the article you provided:
-
Cognitive Abilities in Reptiles:
- The study highlights the possibility that lizards, and potentially other reptiles, exhibit cognitive abilities beyond what was previously assumed.
- The research, led by Duke University behavioral ecologist Manuel Leal, aims to contribute to the understanding of the evolution of cognitive abilities, particularly in reptilian species.
-
Flexible Behavior and Cognitive Abilities:
- The article emphasizes the connection between flexible behavior and higher-level cognitive abilities.
- Flexible behavior, defined as the ability to adapt to specific situations, is suggested to be associated with increased cognitive capabilities, commonly referred to as "more smarts."
-
Territorial Behavior in Lizards:
- Most lizards are characterized as territorial dwellers with fixed behaviors, living alone and consuming a consistent diet of insects throughout the year.
- Contrary to the assumption of limited brain power in reptiles, the study challenges this notion by presenting evidence of flexible behavior in lizards.
-
Experimental Design and Lizard Intelligence:
- Anolis evermanni lizards from Puerto Rico were given a challenge to retrieve a hidden insect larva under a colored plastic disk.
- Four out of six lizards developed distinct strategies to access the hidden treat, showcasing individual problem-solving approaches.
-
Color Vision in Lizards:
- The study incorporates the fact that lizards possess keener color vision compared to humans, influencing their interaction with distinctly colored disks.
-
Learning and Adaptation:
- The lizards demonstrated the ability to remember and adapt their learned strategies when faced with different-colored disks, indicating a form of problem-solving and learning capacity.
-
Comparison with Birds and Notable Differences:
- The researchers draw a parallel between the lizards' performance and that of birds in similar studies, highlighting a comparable level of cognitive abilities.
- A notable difference is mentioned—the lizards completed one trial per day due to their cold-blooded nature, necessitating memory retention of their strategies from one day to the next.
-
Implications for the Evolution of Cognitive Abilities:
- The study suggests that factors beyond complex social structures and diverse diets may contribute to the evolution of flexible behavior and advanced cognitive abilities in reptiles.
-
Cold-Blooded Nature and Learning Speed:
- The article underscores that, despite being slower-moving due to their cold-blooded nature, lizards exhibited a capacity for relatively quick learning and adaptation.
-
Call for Further Exploration:
- Manuel Leal advocates for expanding the scope of cognitive evolution studies to include reptiles and fish, emphasizing the need to explore cognition across various animal groups.
In conclusion, this article sheds light on a fascinating aspect of reptilian cognition, challenging preconceived notions and emphasizing the need for a broader exploration of cognitive evolution in diverse animal species.
