Do I have to sacrifice Melina? (2024)

That's because in order to take Melina's place, you will need to get the Frenzied Flame from Three Fingers. That will break your bond with Melina, but it also means you can travel to the Erdtree and light it yourself, no sacrifice needed.

Does it matter if Melina dies?

She leaves behind a shining, golden tree when she dies in battle that replenishes your health, and the same thing happens if she dies at a Site of Grace. Melina will reappear after this point as if nothing happened and can still be summoned during the Morgott fight.

What happens if you beat Elden Ring without Melina?

Might be possible with wrong warps, but it isn't through normal means. If you do not form an accord with Melina you cannot enter Lyndell no matter how many great runes you have. I don't know if Roundtable is actually required for anything or not.

Can you betray Melina Elden Ring?

And, should the player choose, they can betray Melina and the Maiden in Black. This is directly tied to the bad ending in Demon's Souls , as well as the bad ending in Elden Ring.

Is there any way to spare Melina?

Yes, it is possible to save Melina. In the default ending of Elden Ring, Melina makes the fateful decision to burn the Erdtree. However, the game offers players the possibility to change this fate, therefore, acquiring a different ending. The key to saving her lies in finding the Three Fingers and the Frenzied Flame.

Elden Ring - Melina Sacrifice Scene (4K 60FPS)

How do you get Melina secret ending?

Elden Ring Melina ending

To get this ending, you have to defeat at least two of the demi-gods, Morgott, the Fire Giant, claim the giant's fire to burn the thorns blocking your path, defeat Malekith in Farum Azula, and then beat the final bosses in Leyndell, Ashen Capital.

What is the best ending for Melina Elden Ring?

Spoiler Alert You can achieve an ending called “Age of Order” where Melina does not die and the Elden ring is restored. To achieve this, you must accept frenzy flame, suppress it using item from crumbling Farum Azula, complete the quest from Corhyn.

Is Melina and Ranni the same?

Elden Ring Theory: Melina Is Ranni's Forgotten Sister

Aside from their direct relation to Marika, Ranni and Melina share another - more specific - quality. They are spirits. While Ranni willingly cast aside her flesh and opted to possess a doll's body, it's unclear whether Melina ever had a physical body.

Is Ranni good or evil?

Julianna Swickard of CBR also debated whether Ranni was good or evil, arriving at the conclusion that while she was morally grey as a character, her ending was the "best possible outcome" of all the game's endings.

Are Melina and Ranni connected?

Elden Ring's Queen Marika, mother of demi-gods, is Melina's mother, making Melina a demi-god and, therefore, Ranni's sister. Melina's dialogue heavily implies that Marika is her mother because she says that she was born at the foot of the Erdtree and that her mother is within it.

Can you finish Elden Ring without sacrificing Melina?

Melina is spared from sacrificing herself to this end, I found an alternate way of burning the tree without burning her life away. I complete Millicent's quest line, acquiring the curse ridding needle. I use the needle to rid myself of the frenzied flame curse. I become elden lord.

Can you be maidenless in Elden Ring?

Here's the full line: “You are maidenless. A bit player, fully divorced from the strength of runes.” What the NPC Varré actually means, though it's not immediately clear to the player, is that you need a “Maiden” guide who will allow you to turn the runes you pick up into stat gains.

What happens if I don't talk to Melina?

Refusing Melina's offer in Elden Ring will block your progression in the game. Accepting her offer is the only way to level up in the game, and she's the one who will give you the key item Spectral Steed Whistle, which you can use to summon Elden Ring's horse Torrent.

Can Melina become your maiden?

As Melina says herself, she is not an actual "finger maiden": "I've acted the finger maiden yet I can offer no guidance, I am no maiden."

Should I let Melina be my maiden?

Should you let Melina be your maiden? Refusing Melina's offer in Elden Ring will block your progression in the game. Accepting her offer is the only way to level up in the game, and she's the one who will give you the key item Spectral Steed Whistle, which you can use to summon Elden Ring's horse Torrent.

Who kills Melina?

As a result, jdyhrberg continued burning while resting at the Site of Grace, where they chose the "Talk to Melina" option. Melina appears soon after and is engulfed in flames caused due to the Fire's Deadly Sin incantation. As a result, Melina's HP declines rapidly, and she succumbs to her wounds and dies.

Who is the true villain in Elden Ring?

Every Elden Ring Ending Still Makes The Tarnished A Villain

Elden Ring has multiple story paths, but no happy ending. The Tarnished can choose to defile the world, or burn it all down. They can choose to break the curse of immortality, causing more death than they already have.

Is Ranni the tarnished wife?

Is Ranni married to tarnished? In the Age of the Stars ending, Ranni refers to the Tarnished as her "lord" and her "dear consort", showing that she has not just acknowledged them as being Elden Lord, but also fully acknowledged their own spouse by her side.

Who is the strongest demigod in Elden Ring?

General Radahn is generally considered by most Elden Ring characters as the strongest demigod, except it seems even the strongest don't always win. Because if players watch the intro cinematic again, they'll catch a glimpse of what appears to be Morgott stabbing Radahn in the middle of a battle.

What is the tattoo on Melina eye?

What is the tattoo on Melina's eye? Melina's tattoo is the frenzied flame symbol. They are different characters with different names, but in this game nothing is as it seems, multiple times characters have tricked us or pretended to be something they are not.

Why do Melina and Ranni have an eye closed?

Ergo, Melina's eye could be somehow tied to the Dark Moon, and that could suggest Ranni's eye is tied to the Golden Order. This would be the inverse of their beliefs, explaining why they keep this eye closed.

Why does Melina sacrifice herself?

When the Tarnished is unable to enter the Erdtree, Melina explains that she, with the Frenzied Flame, can sacrifice herself and burn the thorns surrounding the Erdtree, something she greatly desires because of the chaos the Lands Between were plunged into when Marika shattered the Elden Ring: "I have long observed the ...

What does the dung eater ending do?

Dung Eater's ending, the Blessing of Despair, requires the player to finish his questline by giving him Seedbed Curses until he dies and provides a rune that will spread his curse throughout the Lands Between for what will likely be an eternity.

Is Melina the hardest boss in Elden Ring?

Although an obvious inclusion for all those who played Elden Ring, Malenia's status as one of the hardest bosses in any FromSoftware game should not be understated. She is the perfect storm of any individual component that players would claim as challenging from another battle.

Does removing Frenzied Flame bring back Melina?

Does Melina come back after using the needle reddit? By using Miquella's Needle appropriately, they can suppress the Frenzied Flame and achieve another ending for the Lands Between. However – Melina will never return to the PC, even after this is done.