Confirmed: 1-Billion-Year-Old Water Tastes 'Terrible' (2024)

Confirmed: 1-Billion-Year-Old Water Tastes 'Terrible' (1)

J. Telling

Last month, a paper published in Nature reported on some water that had been trapped 1.5 miles below the Earth's surface in Canada for a long while. How long? Based on an analysis of the isotopes of natural gases in the water, scientists believe it to be the oldest isolated water ever studied, at least 1 billion years old and maybe as old as 2.64 billion, slightly younger than the rocks that encased it.* For maybe half as long as the Earth's entire existence, this water has been sealed away, unexposed to the atmosphere.

The next question: Is it drinkable? The answer: Not really, but a sip won't kill you. According to an interview in the Los Angeles Times, one of the paper's authors, Barbara Sherwood Lollar, has tasted it, and it was "terrible," she reports. "It is much saltier than seawater."

Her description of its appearance doesn't make it sound very appetizing either:

What jumps out at you first is the saltiness. Because of the reactions between the water and the rock, it is extremely salty. It is more viscous than tap water. It has the consistency of a very light maple syrup. It doesn't have color when it comes out, but as soon as it comes into contact with oxygen it turns an orangy color because the minerals in it begin to form -- especially the iron.

But that didn't stop Lollar. She tasted it anyway -- for science. And because she wanted to know how salty it was. But because she is a lady and a scholar**, she took this one for the team, and did not allow her students to taste it.

Now onto the bigger questions: Is there life in this billion-year-old water? Lollar thinks it's possible. "The water has the same kind of energy that supports the microbial life found near deep-sea vents and in the South African gold mine," she the LA Times's Deborah Netburn, "We have shown these waters are habitable. The next question is whether or not they are inhabited." And if they are, the question will become what's living there and when did it arrive.

Lollar and her team are investigating, but she says it will be about a year before they have results.

*And before you say, isn't all water on Earth billions of years old, the case of the ancient Canadian water is different. This water has been isolated for all that time, never evaporating, never raining down from the skies, with no contact with the outside world, for a billion years, maybe more.

**The phrase "a gentleman and a scholar" is, unhappily, gender-specific, and this was the best equivalent I could come up with :( Sarah Pavis suggests"gentlewoman" or "dame," both of which I like too.

Rebecca J. Rosen is a senior editor at The Atlantic, where she oversees coverage of American constitutional law and government in the Battle for the Constitution series.

Confirmed: 1-Billion-Year-Old Water Tastes 'Terrible' (2024)

FAQs

Why does all water suddenly taste bad? ›

A sudden change in water quality may be a sign of a serious contamination problem. Yes, the presence of coliform bacteria indicates there is a breach in your water system.

Can you drink million year old water? ›

Most people would probably agree that this isn't a liquid for drinking, and is between 1.5 billion and 2.6 billion years old. But apparently professor Barbara Sherwood Lollar isn't most people. As lead researcher, Lollar tried the water and herself and judging by her reaction, it tasted just as nasty as it sounds.

What did the oldest water taste like? ›

She was looking for a salty taste, with saltier water tending to be older. Much to her delight, the water was "very salty and bitter" and "much saltier than seawater." This isn't altogether surprising, given that it had been aged for over 2 billion years. The paper was published in Nature in 2016.

What makes old water taste funny? ›

The acidic flavor from the carbonic acid it what gives your glass of H20 that distinctly stale taste when you sip it after letting it sit out overnight. "When there is an excess of carbon dioxide in drinking water, we taste more carbonic acid, since carbon dioxide is converted to carbonic acid by carbonic anhydrase.

Why do I suddenly not like the taste of water? ›

Everyone is individual and some people can taste more stuff than others.” If you're sensitive to the taste of certain minerals, this might be why you liked — or didn't like — the water you've tried. It's also important to note that certain medications or treatments can also affect your ability to taste.

Does pex pipe make water taste bad? ›

A few types of PEX-pipe may cause prolonged undesirable taste and odour if the water remains in pipes over time. Although the taste and odour usually dissipate with use, water from two of the PEX types still had an unpleasant smell and taste after a year.

How did people drink water 2000 years ago? ›

In ancient times, some people harvested rain in big containers, but many more people used water that had collected naturally in streams, rivers, and in the ground. They could find groundwater rushing by in rivers, or bubbling up from underground through a spring. They could also dig deep into the earth to find water.

Can you drink 1000 year old water? ›

Drinking ancient groundwater

Water that has been underground for a thousand years can taste different, too. It leaches natural chemicals from the surrounding rock, changing its mineral content. Some natural contaminants linked to groundwater age – like mood-boosting lithium – can have positive effects.

What is the oldest untouched water in the world? ›

However, scientists have found water that is a lot older. The water trapped in Ontario's Kidd Creek Mine is more than 2 billion years old!

Did ancient people boil water before drinking? ›

Pictures of apparatus to clarify liquids (both water and wine) have been found on Egyptian walls dating back to the fifteenth century B.C. Boiling of water, the use of wick siphons, filtration through porous vessels, and even filtration with sand and gravel, as means to purify water, are methods that have been ...

What did people drink before drinking water? ›

So instead of drinking water, many people drank fermented and brewed beverages like beer, ale, cider, and wine. Children drank something called small beer. One of the first steps in brewing beer is to boil the water, which kills the germs and bacteria and makes it safe to drink. This first brewing has alcohol in it.

Was water safe to drink in the 1800s? ›

Bitters themselves date from the 18th century, a time when we didn't have medicine as we know it today. The water supply was unsafe to drink. It was not until the 20th century that we had potable, filtered water, so we drank alcohol as a substitute for water.

Why does water suddenly taste bad? ›

Tap water that tastes moldy, musty, or even dirty is usually due to the presence of algal blooms, sediment, or the growth of harmless, naturally-occurring bacteria.

Why does cold water taste better? ›

While this might seem counterintuitive, warm water — especially unfiltered — tends to taste sweeter and more acidic. Cold water, on the other hand, suppresses the sensitivity of our taste buds and quells any impurities that make water taste slightly different.

Why is our drinking water tasting icky? ›

Drinking water may taste stale if faucets have not been used recently. Running the cold water tap briefly will allow fresh water from the water main to your tap.

Why does all water taste different to me? ›

Whatever the source, naturally occurring minerals in the water contribute to its taste and mouthfeel (yes, just like wine), which is why tap water tastes so vastly different depending on the source of the water.

Why does everything taste bad to me suddenly? ›

There are numerous causes of dysgeusia. Some of these are related to changes in the mouth, such as a dry mouth, dental problems, or chemotherapy, while others are based on changes in the neurological aspects of taste sensation, such as pregnancy and migraines. Common temporary causes of dysgeusia include: A cold.

Why is there a bad taste in my mouth when I drink water? ›

Poor oral hygiene or dental health issues such as cavities and gum disease, can contribute to a lingering bad taste. Infection, inflammation, and abscesses may also be involved. Other symptoms of problematic oral hygiene include: bad breath (halitosis)

How do you fix weird water taste? ›

Use a water filter

Using a water filter is often the first (and best!) line of defense when it comes to improving taste. Their entire function is to remove harmful and unwanted contaminants from your water. So, if you choose the right one, you can rest assured that your water's taste will improve instantly.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Msgr. Benton Quitzon

Last Updated:

Views: 5774

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Msgr. Benton Quitzon

Birthday: 2001-08-13

Address: 96487 Kris Cliff, Teresiafurt, WI 95201

Phone: +9418513585781

Job: Senior Designer

Hobby: Calligraphy, Rowing, Vacation, Geocaching, Web surfing, Electronics, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Msgr. Benton Quitzon, I am a comfortable, charming, thankful, happy, adventurous, handsome, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.