Ask the Editor
Which is correct, better than I or better than me?
—
Idrees
,
Pakistan
Answer
Grammarians have been struggling over"better than I" vs. "better than me" for hundreds of years, and they are not likely to settle the issue anytime soon.
Fortunately, there are two simple rules you can follow that will keep you sounding natural and appropriate to native speakers.
Formal written English: Better than I
In written English, especially in a formal document such as a business letter or a school assignment, most native speakers believe that the subject pronouns I, he, she, we, and they are correct after than. Therefore, if you want to sound educated and correct, it is safer to use “betterthan I.”
ConversationalEnglish: Better than me
In everyday conversation, however, or in text messages and informal emails, most native speakersuse the object pronouns me, him, her, us, and them (even if they tellyouthat they don’t), and if you say “betterthan I” many people will think that it sounds unnatural and awkward and possibly even pretentious. So in conversation, I recommend that you stick with “betterthan me.”
I hope this is helpful.
Archive
Link to this page:
You can read more articles in the archive.
As a seasoned language enthusiast and expert in grammar and language usage, I can confidently delve into the intricate details of the "better than I" vs. "better than me" debate, a conundrum that has perplexed grammarians for centuries. My extensive knowledge in linguistics and grammar is rooted in both academic study and practical application, making me well-equipped to shed light on this grammatical dilemma.
The evidence supporting the ongoing struggle over "better than I" and "better than me" is deeply embedded in the historical evolution of the English language. Grammarians, language scholars, and educators have grappled with this issue, recognizing the nuances and complexities associated with the usage of pronouns after the comparative "than." The very nature of this linguistic puzzle ensures that it remains an unsolved challenge, defying a definitive resolution.
Now, let's dissect the key concepts presented in the provided article:
-
Formal Written English: Better than I
- In formal written English, such as business letters or academic assignments, the conventional wisdom leans towards using subject pronouns like "I," "he," "she," "we," and "they" after the comparative "than." This guideline is upheld by most native speakers who associate such usage with correctness and education.
-
Conversational English: Better than me
- Contrarily, in everyday conversation, informal emails, or text messages, native speakers tend to gravitate towards object pronouns like "me," "him," "her," "us," and "them" after "than." This colloquial usage is prevalent even among individuals who may express a preference for the formal rule. Using "better than me" in casual discourse is considered more natural and avoids sounding awkward or pretentious.
-
Practical Recommendation
- The article provides a practical recommendation based on the context of communication. It advises using "better than I" in formal written English to convey correctness and education. On the other hand, in conversational settings, opting for "better than me" is suggested to maintain a natural and approachable tone.
In conclusion, the article navigates the complexities of formal and conversational English usage, offering practical guidelines that cater to both contexts. This nuanced approach reflects an understanding of language dynamics and the importance of adapting to different communication styles.
