Best Pet Insurance Quotes for Cats & Dogs – Policygenius (2024)

What is pet insurance?

Pet insurance is like health insurance for your pet. When something bad and unexpected happens to your beloved cat or dog, pet insurance reimburses you for covered expenses like vet bills. Getting pet insurance can help you save on veterinary costs, and it can provide peace of mind when it comes to your pet's health and your budget.

How does pet insurance work?

Here’s an outline of what you do when when you have insurance and your pet needs medical attention:

  1. Go to any licensed veterinarian. Pet insurance doesn't require you to stick to a network.

  2. Pay the vet upfront. Unlike health insurance, the vet doesn't bill the insurance company for the costs.

  3. Submit a claim (a simple form and invoice from your vet) to the pet insurance company.

  4. Wait on the decision. If you've been a careful shopper and read through the policy, you shouldn’t be too surprised by what happens.

  5. Get paid by direct deposit or mail.

Pet insurance doesn’t pay you back for all the money you spent on vet costs though. How much you’re reimbursed will depend on a few key features of your policy.

Reimbursem*nt rate

This is the rate at which the insurance company covers eligible expenses. Most pet insurance policies have reimbursem*nt rates that range from 70-90%. Plans with higher reimbursem*nt rates will cost you more in terms of monthly premium. For example, If you have a claim for $2,000 and your reimbursem*nt rate is 80% you can expect to get back $1,600.

Deductibles

Before your pet insurance coverage applies, you’ll first have to pay a specific amount of money on your own, called the deductible. You’re probably familiar with deductibles from other types of insurance (like health insurance or car insurance).

Let’s say you have a $200 pet deductible. Using the example above, for a $2,000 bill you’ll have to pay $200 out of pocket, and then the pet insurer will reimburse you for $1,440 (80% of the remaining $1,800).

Your pet insurance policy may have an annual deductible, or a per-incident deductible, which means you’ll be responsible for paying the deductible again for every incident that requires veterinary care.

Limits on payouts

Some policies will limit the amount paid in claims for your pet, which means the insurance company will stop paying you back after they’ve reimbursed you for a certain dollar amount. There are also plans with no limits on payouts, which are still reasonably priced and can provide the greatest peace of mind.

Generally, there are five different types of payout limits you may encounter with pet insurance:

  • Per incident – A maximum amount for each separate illness or injury. The limits can go up to $7,000.

  • Per year – The maximum amount for each twelve-month period on your policy. The limits can go up to $20,000.

  • Per lifetime – The maximum amount the insurance company will pay during the lifetime of your pet. Limits can go up to $200,000.

  • Per body system The maximum amount the insurance company will reimburse for a body system, like digestive system, musculoskeletal system, and nervous system.

  • Per schedule of benefits – A maximum based on a listing of allowances for specific health conditions. For example, a maximum allowance for asthma of $500 per year.

The cost of pet insurance

Part of having pet insurance coverage is paying the monthly premium. You must keep paying this recurring cost or else your coverage will terminate (or “lapse,” in insurance terms).

The average monthly costs of pet insurance [1] can range from:

  • $11 to $30 for cat insurance

  • $18 to $50 for dog insurance

The premiums are determined by a few factors, including:

  • Species: Cats cost less than dogs, and smaller pets are cheaper to insure than larger ones

  • Breed: A pet that’s susceptible to certain diseases will warrant a higher premium.

  • Age: Older pets are more expensive to insure than younger ones.

  • Location: Insurance often costs more in larger or more expensive cities

The premium is also affected by policy features — like the deductible and reimbursem*nt rate we mentioned above — as well as the type of coverage you get. A more robust plan that covers more health expenses for your pet will cost more than one that doesn’t.

Learn more about how much pet insurance costs and how to save on premiums.

Types of pet plans & what’s covered

Pet insurance policies can be divided into three types: accident and illness plans, accident-only plans, and wellness plans. The first two are pretty self-explanatory: one covers your pet if they get sick (vomiting or diarrhea, for example) or injured in an accident (like getting hit by a car); the other covers only the latter. A comprehensive accident and illness plan will cost more, but it’ll protect your wallet and pet under many more circ*mstances.

Depending on the pet insurance company you choose, you may be able to combine either type of coverage with a wellness plan, which can cover your pet’s preventive care, like routine screenings, vaccinations, and even dental cleanings.

Accident

Comprehensive

Wellness

Accidental injuries

Yes

Yes

No

Diseases and illnesses

No

Yes

No

Chronic conditions and cancer

No

Yes

No

Pre-existing conditions

No

No

No

Routine care

No

No

Yes

Some insurers may cover additional services not listed above, like behavioral services and alternative therapies.

Learn more about what pet insurance does and doesn’t cover.

Why trust Policygenius?

Our track record. From coast to coast, we’ve helped over 30 million people shop for insurance, and protected our customers with over $60 billion in coverage.

We’ve vetted the top policies. Policygenius puts the best dog and cat insurance options in one place. Every policy has been personally chosen by our experts, because we’re pet owners too.

Real human help. Our licensed advisors deal with the insurer so you don’t have to. No AI bots, no robocalls, no salespeople. Just real human help from start to finish.

FAQs about pet insurance

How do I know which vets accept pet insurance?

You don't have to worry about this! With pet insurance, you can go to any licensed veterinarian. You pay the vet for their services (as you normally would), then submit that bill with a claim form to the insurance company. Any reimbursem*nt you're eligible for will be paid directly to you by the insurer.

This is different from human health insurance, where the insurance company pays the doctor directly (not you). That's why for human health insurance, you need to confirm whether your doctor works with a particular insurance company.

Why doesn't pet insurance cover pre-existing conditions?

Anything that is documented on your pet's medical health record before you get pet insurance will likely be considered a pre-existing condition and will be excluded from coverage (meaning any claim you make on that condition will be denied).

An insurance system that covers pre-existing conditions couldn't last for very long: that would allow pet owners to wait until something happens before they get insurance — and then cancel it after they recover. If everybody did that, no insurance company could afford to exist!

Because pre-existing conditions are always excluded, you should get pet insurance as soon as possible for your pet. The longer you wait, the greater the chance your pet experiences a health issue that would be excluded from coverage.

Isn’t pet insurance a scam?

At Policygenius, we offer only products we believe in, and would buy for ourselves. And that applies to pet insurance. A lot of people think pet insurance is a 'scam' if you don't get back more money than you pay in for it. That's the wrong way to think about pet insurance (and any insurance for that matter). Pet insurance is about having a safety net in the event of major and unpredictable health expenses for your furry best friend.

Want to know more? We talked to Vox magazine about pet insurance and why it's not a ripoff.

Best Pet Insurance Quotes for Cats & Dogs – Policygenius (2024)

FAQs

What is the most cost-effective pet insurance? ›

Based on the evaluation of over a dozen pet insurance providers, Lemonade and ManyPets are the cheapest pet insurance companies. ManyPets is the most affordable pet insurance with an average monthly cost of $23, and the cheapest option for cats at $16.

How do I get the best out of my pet insurance? ›

Make Sure Your Policy Makes Sense For Your Breed, Location, Age, And Any Pre-Existing Conditions. With over 14+ pet insurance provider options, each with various plans, and each ton of policy variations - it can be tricky to find the the perfect fit at the best price.

Which of the following would not be covered under pet insurance? ›

While pet insurance is designed to assist with unexpected medical expenses, it typically doesn't cover routine and preventive care in a standard accident and illness policy. This type of care includes things like vaccinations, flea and tick prevention, and annual check-ups.

How does pet insurance know about pre-existing conditions? ›

How do pet insurers know about pre-existing conditions? Depending on your insurer, when you submit a pet insurance claim, they will typically request your pet's medical records to evaluate the claim and determine if the issue predates your waiting period.

How much does the average person spend on pet insurance per month? ›

We found that, on average, pet insurance costs $66 a month for dogs and $32 a month for cats. However, pet insurance premiums typically range from $15 to $90 a month. Pet insurance is an affordable alternative to paying vet bills out of pocket and can offer financial protection against high-cost emergency vet visits.

Can you claim your pet on your income tax? ›

Unfortunately, pets do not count as dependents in the eyes of the IRS. While many pet owners consider their fur babies to be family members, you cannot claim a pet as a dependent on your tax return. Claiming dependents, like children or elderly parents you support, can reduce your tax burden.

Does pet insurance cost go up with age? ›

Age is typically the primary factor in premium increases. As pets get older, their risk of getting sick or hurt goes up, which means they cost more to insure.

Can you negotiate your pet insurance? ›

Pet insurance, like most consumer insurances, is price-inflexible. While you may be able to reduce the price by removing elements of cover (so in effect, you're buying less insurance), you're unlikely to be able to negotiate the price for the coverage chosen. 1)Research Multiple Providers and compare the quoted prices.

Does Waggle pay out? ›

Can Waggel pay my vet directly? We can definitely pay your vet directly. However, we recommend that you first check that your vet is happy to accept direct claim payments.

What are the three types of pet insurance? ›

Background: Pet insurance companies typically divide their products into 3 main categories: accident-only, accident and illness, and wellness coverages. Each level offers specific services that are covered and excluded and will vary by price. Insurance policies are usually broken down by the type of pet being insured.

What pre-existing conditions are not covered? ›

Health insurers can no longer charge more or deny coverage to you or your child because of a pre-existing health condition like asthma, diabetes, or cancer, as well as pregnancy. They cannot limit benefits for that condition either.

What are the risks of pet insurance? ›

Cons
  • Pet insurance reimburses you for veterinary expenses, meaning you have to pay them upfront.
  • Pet insurance doesn't cover pre-existing conditions, meaning once your pet is sick, it's too late to sign up.
  • Not all health issues are covered by pet insurance.

What voids pet insurance? ›

Some of the most common things pet insurance does not cover are: Pre-existing illness or injury - In general, insurers will not cover illness or injury that your pet had or showed signs of having before the policy started.

What are 4 factors that go into determining your monthly premium for pet insurance? ›

Four factors that affect pet insurance cost:
  • Your location. Veterinary care is more expensive in certain parts of the country. ...
  • Your pet's age. ...
  • Your pet's breed. ...
  • Your deductible and reimbursem*nt level.

What is the typical waiting period for pet insurance? ›

Most pet insurance companies have a 14-day waiting period for illnesses. ASPCA, ManyPets, Pumpkin and Spot have no extended waiting periods for specified conditions such as cruciate ligament issues and hip dysplasia.

What is the average cost of MetLife pet insurance? ›

Compare MetLife to the Competition
CompanyMonthly CostAccident Waiting Period
MetLife Pet Insurance EXPLORE PLANS$25-$402 days
Our Top Pick Lemonade EXPLORE PLANS$15-$302 days
Spot Pet Insurance EXPLORE PLANS$34-$7514 days
Embrace EXPLORE PLANS$39-$732 days
6 more rows
Mar 20, 2024

How much is lemonade pet insurance a month? ›

Compare Lemonade to the Competition
CompanyMonthly CostStar Rating
Our Top Pick Lemonade EXPLORE PLANS$15-$304.8
Spot Pet Insurance EXPLORE PLANS$34-$754.5
ASPCA Pet Health Insurance EXPLORE PLANS$18-$444.8
Fetch Pet Insurance EXPLORE PLANS$45-$904.3
5 more rows
Apr 3, 2024

Do most dog owners have pet insurance? ›

Of the two-thirds (67%) of Americans who are pet owners (defined as those who currently own a cat and/or dog), 24% have pet insurance, according to a new NerdWallet survey conducted online by The Harris Poll among 1,366 pet owners.

Does pet insurance get more expensive each year? ›

Your pet insurance premium is based on a long list of factors, some of which can change from year to year. If your pet insurance premium has increased, one of these factors may be in play. Age: As your pet gets older, they're more likely to have an expensive-to-cover illness or age-related injury.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Laurine Ryan

Last Updated:

Views: 5878

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Laurine Ryan

Birthday: 1994-12-23

Address: Suite 751 871 Lissette Throughway, West Kittie, NH 41603

Phone: +2366831109631

Job: Sales Producer

Hobby: Creative writing, Motor sports, Do it yourself, Skateboarding, Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Stand-up comedy

Introduction: My name is Laurine Ryan, I am a adorable, fair, graceful, spotless, gorgeous, homely, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.