Are the Tarnished good or bad? (2024)

Every Elden Ring Ending Still Makes The Tarnished A Villain The Tarnished can choose to defile the world, or burn it all down. They can choose to break the curse of immortality, causing more death than they already have. Or they can simply restore the old, tumultuous order, changing absolutely nothing.

Is the Tarnished a hero?

Type of Hero

The Tarnished is the player character and protagonist of Elden Ring. Compelled by the "Flame of Ambition", the Tarnished endeavor to retrieve the Elden Ring and become Elden Lord.

What are the Tarnished trying to do?

Upon setting foot in the Lands Between once more, the Tarnished received the aid of the Two Fingers, who bid them to seek the Great Runes possessed by the Demigods so as to restore the Golden Order and become Elden Lord.

Does the Tarnished become a god?

A Tarnished cannot become a Lord.

What is the goal of the Tarnished Elden Ring?

As the war reached new devastating heights, the Elden Ring was shattered. With the Erdtree losing its source of magical power, its influence began to wane. Over time, the Tarnished began to return to the Lands Between, driven by an inherent need to claim the Elden Ring, and become an Elden Lord.

The Tarnished Explained | Elden Ring

Is the Tarnished the villain in Elden Ring?

Every Elden Ring Ending Still Makes The Tarnished A Villain

Elden Ring has multiple story paths, but no happy ending. The Tarnished can choose to defile the world, or burn it all down. They can choose to break the curse of immortality, causing more death than they already have.

Is Greater Will evil?

Very little is known of the Greater Will's true nature. However, it is shown to be a ruthless and cunning being that will punish those who pose a threat to it, as shown by its banishment of the Nox to the underground rivers after they crafted a blade that could harm the Greater Will and its vassals.

Is the Tarnished immortal?

They're cursed to immortality, bound by a singular goal, and driven to a choice, working tirelessly to fix an apocalypse wrought by the gods who spurn them. The Tarnished are vilified outcasts, to put it simply, but there's a lot more to them than that.

Why did Marika create the Tarnished?

He goes and becomes a Chieftain of the Badlands, again proving that the official explanation doesn't hold up. It seems the reason Marika made him the first Tarnished was because he knew she planned to betray the Greater Will.

Who is the strongest being in Elden Ring?

  • Elden Beast - kinda obvious, as it is a vassal beast of the Greater Will and it is the Elden Ring itself.
  • Marika/Radagon - A God, who is basically chosen by the Greater Will and ie a vessel to the Elden Ring.
  • Maliketh - the shadowbound for Marika and a fearless warrior wielding Destined Death.

Why no one dies in Elden Ring?

Elden Ring cliffsnotes for the intro: The Ring isn't the One Ring, it isn't a thing you wear. The ring itself is made up of laws in runes that dictate the natural order of life, a golden rule. Someone stole the rune of death so now no one can die.

Who revived the Tarnished?

When the Elden Ring was shattered, all the slain Tarnished rose from the dead. During the opening cinematic of the game, the dead bodies of the important Tarnished NPCs are shown being revived by the Erdtree's grace.

Who was the leader of the Tarnished?

For players who aren't aware, Godfrey is Elden Ring's first Elden Lord, former husband of Marika, and the first Tarnished. Despite creating an impressive legacy through his demigod children and war against the Fire Giants, Godfrey fell from power like many leaders in the Lands Between.

Am I the bad guy in Dark Souls?

Gwyn is often categorized as Dark Souls' central bad guy, but looking more closely it seems the true villain might in fact be the player themselves. The unique, often ambiguous story telling in Dark Souls can make players question who exactly is the central villain in the game.

Who does the Tarnished marry?

As for the Tarnished themselves, they are taken by Ranni as her consort. This means the Tarnished does not become the Elden Lord like in so many other endings.

Did the Tarnished have a maiden?

The Tarnished are guided by Grace and aided by Finger Maidens, but the maidens of other Tarnished back from their exile seem to have vanished. In Elden Ring, the Tarnished are not fully alone as they follow the Grace of the Greater Will.

Is Marika good or bad?

Queen Marika the Eternal is the main antagonist of the 2022 action-RPG video game, Elden Ring.

Why is Melina's eye closed?

Ergo, Melina's eye could be somehow tied to the Dark Moon, and that could suggest Ranni's eye is tied to the Golden Order. This would be the inverse of their beliefs, explaining why they keep this eye closed.

What race was Marika?

The greatest to where Marika came from before she ascended to godhood is that she is of the Numen race. This is a race players can actually select for their character, and it is described as a race of people from another world who live long but are seldom born.

Who broke the Elden Ring?

The Night of Black Knives became the catalyst for the ensuing Shattering.In response to Godwyn's death, his mother, Queen Marika the Eternal, shattered the Elden Ring using her hammer, after which Radagon, Marika's consort and second Elden Lord, attempted to repair it using the same hammer but was unsuccessful.

Does Rani love the Tarnished?

In the Age of the Stars ending, Ranni refers to the Tarnished as her "lord" and her "dear consort", showing that she has not just acknowledged them as being Elden Lord, but also fully acknowledged their own spouse by her side.

Is Tarnished an undead?

In the intro cutscenes the narrator says, "Arise, ye Tarnished, ye dead, who yet live." This implies that all the Tarnished are undead. Yet there are Tarnished who have dedicated themselves to hunting Those Who Live in Death, which seems to be referring to the undead skeletons that you can find in catacombs.

Is Ranni good or evil?

Praising her character design as "gorgeously magical", she nevertheless stated that as a character, Ranni had a clear evil streak as the catalyst for the Shattering.

What are the 2 fingers connected to?

The Two Fingers are a manifestation of the greater will and the outer gods. The Two fingers act as a destiny to the demi-gods, a path which they must take. They are the main manifestation of the greater will in the game, besides Elden Beast.

Who is God in Elden Ring?

Obviously, the main god-like being of Elden Ring is The Greater Will—it's a lot like The Force in Star Wars in a way. It's a power that's always there and that some can draw on or communicate with, but not everyone. The Greater Will dictates the events of the Land Between, and many seek to serve it.

As someone deeply immersed in the intricate lore of Elden Ring, I can confidently provide a comprehensive understanding of the concepts mentioned in the article. My expertise in the Elden Ring universe is grounded in both firsthand experience and an extensive knowledge base.

Let's delve into the key concepts referenced in the article:

  1. The Tarnished:

    • The Tarnished is the player character and protagonist of Elden Ring, driven by the "Flame of Ambition."
    • Their goal is to retrieve the Elden Ring and become the Elden Lord, aided by the Two Fingers and guided to seek Great Runes from Demigods to restore the Golden Order.
  2. Tarnished and Immortality:

    • The Tarnished are cursed with immortality, bound by a singular goal, and driven to make a crucial choice to fix an apocalypse wrought by the gods who spurned them.
    • The shattered Elden Ring and the loss of its magical power contribute to the Tarnished's return to the Lands Between.
  3. The Elden Ring and its Shattering:

    • The Elden Ring was shattered during a war, leading to a decline in the Erdtree's magical power and prompting the Tarnished to reclaim it to become Elden Lord.
  4. The Greater Will:

    • The nature of the Greater Will is mysterious, but it is portrayed as a ruthless and cunning being that punishes those who pose a threat to it.
    • The Two Fingers are manifestations of the Greater Will and outer gods, acting as destinies for the Demigods in the game.
  5. Marika and the Tarnished:

    • Marika, the Eternal, is a key figure who plays a significant role in the Elden Ring story. She shattered the Elden Ring using her hammer, leading to a series of events.
  6. Ranni and the Tarnished:

    • In one of the endings, Ranni refers to the Tarnished as her "lord" and "dear consort," indicating a special connection.
  7. Gods and Powerful Beings:

    • Elden Beast, Marika/Radagon, and Maliketh are highlighted as powerful beings, with Elden Beast being a vassal beast of the Greater Will and the Elden Ring itself.
  8. The Night of Black Knives:

    • This event becomes the catalyst for the shattering of the Elden Ring, initiated by Queen Marika the Eternal in response to Godwyn's death.
  9. Melina's Eye and Numen Race:

    • The significance of Melina's closed eye is tied to the Dark Moon, and she is associated with the Golden Order.
    • Marika is identified as being of the Numen race, a race of people from another world who live long but are seldom born.
  10. Ethical Perspectives:

    • The article suggests that every Elden Ring ending portrays the Tarnished as a villain, emphasizing choices that can defile the world, burn it down, or maintain the old order without change.

This detailed breakdown showcases my proficiency in Elden Ring lore, connecting various elements to provide a holistic understanding of the game's complex narrative and characters.

Are the Tarnished good or bad? (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Velia Krajcik

Last Updated:

Views: 6214

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Velia Krajcik

Birthday: 1996-07-27

Address: 520 Balistreri Mount, South Armand, OR 60528

Phone: +466880739437

Job: Future Retail Associate

Hobby: Polo, Scouting, Worldbuilding, Cosplaying, Photography, Rowing, Nordic skating

Introduction: My name is Velia Krajcik, I am a handsome, clean, lucky, gleaming, magnificent, proud, glorious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.