401(k)s: Why a Millennial avoids them, keeps savings in trading accounts instead (2024)

Tanisha A. Sykes

Market traders like James Pollard don’t always play by the traditional rules of investing.

401(k)s: Why a Millennial avoids them, keeps savings in trading accounts instead (1)

For instance, Pollard, 24, a marketing consultant and owner of TheAdvisorCoach.com, which helps financial advisers attract new clients, prefers easy access to his hard-earned cash.

“I’d rather have access to my money using stock trading accounts like Robinhood instead of tying it up in a 401(k) or IRA.”

401(k)s: Why a Millennial avoids them, keeps savings in trading accounts instead (2)

While he takes a lot of heat for such comments, he’s not your typical brash, fast-talking trader.

Learn more: Best current CD rates

“I’ve been trading since 2011, after reading several books on the subject,” says Pollard, a University of Delaware alum. His favorites include Secrets for Profiting in Bull and Bear Markets by Stan Weinstein and Technical Analysis of the Financial Markets by John J. Murphy.

Before making any significant trades, he stockpiled his cash. That strategy, combined with running a company that is on track to earn six figures by year’s end, helped him shore up his funds.

“I actually save 60%-70% of my income per month into various dividend stocks,” says Pollard. “Whenever a dividend poses a good deal, I buy.”

More:Millennials: Here's how to save and invest when you're just getting by

More:Just 21 years old, he's already saved over $100,000

More:This 30-something investor isn't freaking out about her 401(k) — she's catching up

In addition, as the owner of his Newark, De.-based advisery firm, he has more than two years of emergency expenses set aside. “Knowing that I have a good amount saved up helps me to manage the ‘what ifs’,” he says.

What’s more, he is not trading incessantly throughout the day, but does pull the trigger at least twice weekly. His investments fluctuate, although he keeps a steady mix of blue chips — high-quality businesses that have steady profits and reliable dividends — such as Exxon, GE and AT&T.

“When I make an investment, I don’t go in with a naked trade, I’m prepared to hold,” says Pollard. “Mentally, I have a stop loss, but I don’t want to risk having a bad investment so I will ride the market out.”

He also dabbles in more speculative activity, investing in products like Bitcoin and Ethereum. The price of both digital currencies has soared since last year. Bitcoin prices increased to almost $5,000 in mid-October from $635 a year ago, according to CoinDesk Inc., a news and information firm that tracks the currencies.

To date, Pollard states that he has lost and won thousands in a single day. To fund his trading activities, he keeps at least $25,000 in liquid assets in a brokerage platform with money earmarked for trading. “I only trade with 5% of my trading capital at any given time,” he says. “It isn’t income or pay, it’s 5% of the money I set aside to use for trading.”

He never worries about “going all in” because as he points out: “I’m extremely disciplined that way, and I’ve seen too many people lose a lot of money deviating from their own rules.”

Despite his pension for market trading, Pollard offers this advice to other Millennials: “It definitely shouldn’t be considered your entire retirement strategy,” he says. “If you learn what you have to do, then wait for the opportunity, you can make it work.”

Carlos Dias Jr., a wealth manager and financial adviser at MVP Wealth Management Group and Excel Tax & Wealth Group in Orlando, Fla., says as a passive investor, James is buying and holding the right companies such as AT&T and Walmart. However, as a day trader, price fluctuations and transaction fees can be problematic.

“You can make some real money trading, but you really have to know what you are doing,” says Dias, who has previously purchased penny stocks. “James sounds like he is more of a buy-and-hold investor focusing on large companies that provide stability, through dividends, but he has to think about how to save some money for the future.”

For investors considering market trading, Dias has this advice:

Set up a 401(k). As an entrepreneur, James can set up his own retirement plan such as a Simple 401(k) or Simple IRA. Dias explains: “These plans are good for employers who have less than 100 employees and received at least $5,000 in compensation for the previous year.” When you have the money to set aside, it’s important to save for the future, he says.

Beware of keeping too much cash. If Pollard were ever sued, a litigant could come after his cash accounts. “James’ biggest liability is keeping his money in non-qualified accounts, meaning non-retirement accounts, and that leaves that money available to collection,” Dias says.

Protect your portfolio. James reserves 5% of his trading portfolio for investments, which is good, but Dias advises new traders to beware of going overboard. “Don’t just look at the profits you can make, look at how much you can lose on one transaction or multiple transactions,” he says. Instead of chasing returns, set aside a small amount of money to invest.

401(k)s: Why a Millennial avoids them, keeps savings in trading accounts instead (2024)

FAQs

Why are millennials not saving for retirement? ›

By some measures, millennials lag on retirement preparedness and net worth relative to older generations such as Gen X and baby boomers. There are many reasons for this, such as a shift away from pensions toward 401(k) plans and high student debt burdens.

Why 401k instead of savings account? ›

With a traditional 401(k), you make contributions with pre-tax dollars, so you get a tax break up front, helping lower your current income tax bill. Your money—both contributions and potential earnings—grows tax-deferred until you withdraw it. At that time, withdrawals are taxed at your current tax rate.

Why don't wealthy people have 401ks? ›

High Fees and Low Control

The unfortunate truth is that 401(k) plans come with high management fees. This eats into your earnings in the long run. These fees are oftentimes hidden among legal jargon, according to the Rich Dad team. Fees can be but aren't limited to transaction fees, legal fees and bookkeeping fees.

What does Robert Kiyosaki say about 401k? ›

“Rich Dad Poor Dad” author Robert Kiyosaki isn't a fan of traditional retirement savings plans because he doesn't think they are a safe place to park your money. In a recent tweet, he predicted that 401(k) plans and IRAs will soon be “toast,” and shared that his previous predictions have usually come to fruition.

Do 66% of millennials have nothing saved for retirement? ›

More specifically, the analysis finds that 66 percent of working Millennials have nothing saved for retirement, and the situation is far worse for working Millennial Latinos. Some 83 percent of Latinos in this generation have nothing saved for retirement.

What percent of millennials have no retirement savings? ›

According to the National Institute of Retirement Security, 66% of working millennials have nothing saved for retirement. Instead, they're busy paying down debt and covering their general living expenses, while saving for retirement is pushed to the bottom of their priority list.

Why should you not use a savings account as your retirement account? ›

Because savings accounts tend to earn lower interest than investment accounts, your earnings won't likely keep pace with inflation. Compounded interest. This is the way that financial institutions calculate the interest earned an account.

Should you have more in savings or 401k? ›

And a recent Personal Capital survey found building an emergency fund is a top priority for 2023. “It's always a balance,” said certified financial planner Catherine Valega, founder of Green Bee Advisory in Boston. While maxing out your 401(k) should be the goal, your emergency savings are also important, she said.

Is it better to save in a bank or 401k? ›

The Bottom Line. A 401(k) plan can be a powerful tool for building wealth and the sooner you start saving, the more time you have to capitalize on compounding interest. A savings account, meanwhile, can offer liquidity and flexibility.

How many Americans have $1000000 in their 401k? ›

All told, there were 422,000 retirement savers in Fidelity 401(k) plans sporting balances of seven figures and beyond as of Dec. 31, up from 349,000 at the end of September and 299,000 at the end of 2022. There were also 391,562 IRA millionaires on Dec.

What is the average age of a 401k millionaire? ›

The average age of the 401(k) millionaires is 59, but their wealth accumulation isn't just a function of time — it also stems from good investing practices.

How many Americans are 401k millionaires? ›

Fidelity also reported that the number of 401(k) accounts with balances of at least $1 million rose in the fourth quarter by 20%, to 422,000 accounts; and by 41% for the whole year.

What is the 401k trap? ›

What is the 401(k) trap? To start, you cannot take your money out of a 401(k) until you are 59 ½ years old without a penalty and taxes on your withdrawal. It's in a “lockbox” where you lose control of your money, generational wealth transfers, cost segregation, depreciation, and other tax benefits.

What 401k does Dave Ramsey recommend? ›

Contacting your 401(k) plan manager, according to Ramsey Solutions, allows you to find out whether you have the option to choose pre-tax or after-tax contributions. Their recommendation is to take advantage of the Roth option, if your plan offers it.

What is the rich man's retirement plan? ›

Unlike Roth IRAs, the Rich Person Roth has no contribution limits, allowing individuals to plan for essentially unlimited amounts. Tax-free income in retirement is a significant advantage, and the strategy is suitable for those already maxing out other retirement accounts.

Why millennials are struggling financially? ›

Many factors are at play, including income, debt, dwindling savings, and poor financial choices. Close to 75% of millennial women and 70% of all those surveyed say they struggle to make ends meet with their current salary. The average income for millennials surveyed is $74,106, roughly $35 an hour.

Why do millennials have so little wealth? ›

Researchers claim the distribution of wealth among millennials is so uneven because the economic rewards for middle and upper-class lifestyles have increased, while those for the working class have either remained the same or declined.

Are millennials worried about retirement? ›

Four in 10 millennials and Gen Zers believe they will live to age 100–twice the proportion of baby boomers who think the same. That extra time will cost money–and they know it. In fact, individuals in their 20s said think they need to save $1.2 million to retire.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dong Thiel

Last Updated:

Views: 5926

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dong Thiel

Birthday: 2001-07-14

Address: 2865 Kasha Unions, West Corrinne, AK 05708-1071

Phone: +3512198379449

Job: Design Planner

Hobby: Graffiti, Foreign language learning, Gambling, Metalworking, Rowing, Sculling, Sewing

Introduction: My name is Dong Thiel, I am a brainy, happy, tasty, lively, splendid, talented, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.