A bull figurine in front of a stock chart.©Getty Images
It's not quite a Santa Claus rally, but it's starting to feel like one.Since theS&P 500jumped 9% in November, the benchmark index has tacked on another 3.3% through Dec. 14, soaring after the Federal Reserve indicated it was likely done raising interest rates.
The Fed even forecast three interest rate cuts in 2024 as it gets closer to achieving the "soft landing" it's been aiming for, meaning bringing down inflation without causing a recession. One of the easiest moves investors can make is to buy a broad index fund, such as theSPDR S&P 500 ETF(NYSEMKT: SPY)or theVanguard 500 Index Fund(NYSEMKT: VOO).
Both offer low-cost ways to get exposure to the 500 large-cap U.S. stocks that make up the S&P 500. However, as we get ready to turn the calendar to a new year, there's a better index fund one can own today. Large-cap stocks dominated 2023 as the "Magnificent Seven" were all big winners this year.....Story continues...
By: Jeremy Bowman
Source: 1 No-Brainer Index Fund to Buy for 2024 (Hint: It's Not the S&P 500)
Critics:
Anindex fund(alsoindex tracker) is amutual fundorexchange-traded fund (ETF) designed to follow certain preset rules so that it can replicate the performance ("track") of a specified basket of underlying investments.While index providers often emphasize that they are for-profit organizations, index providers have the ability to act as "reluctant regulators" when determining which companies are suitable for an index.
Those rules may include tracking prominentindexeslike theS&P 500or theDow Jones Industrial Averageor implementation rules, such as tax-management, tracking error minimization, large block trading or patient/flexible trading strategies that allow for greater tracking error but lower market impact costs. Index funds may also have rules that screen for social and sustainable criteria.
An index fund's rules of construction clearly identify the type of companies suitable for the fund. The most commonly known index fund in the United States, the S&P 500 Index Fund, is based on the rules established byS&P Dow Jones Indicesfor theirS&P 500 Index. Equity index funds would include groups of stocks with similar characteristics such as the size, value, profitability and/or geographic location of the companies. A group of stocks may include companies from the United States, Non-US Developed,emerging marketsorfrontier marketcountries.
Additional index funds within these geographic markets may include indexes of companies that include rules based on company characteristics or factors, such as companies that are small, mid-sized, large, small value, large value, small growth, large growth, the level of gross profitability or investment capital, real estate, or indexes based on commodities and fixed-income. Companies are purchased and held within the index fund when they meet the specific index rules or parameters and are sold when they move outside of those rules or parameters.
Think of an index fund as an investment utilizing rules-based investing. Some index providers announce changes of the companies in their index before the change date whilst other index providers do not make such announcements. The main advantage of index funds for investors is they don't require much time to manage as the investors don't have to spend time analyzing various stocks or stock portfolios. Most investors also find it difficult to beat the performance of the S&P 500 Index.
Some legal scholars have previously suggested a value maximization and agency-costs theory for understanding index funds stewardship. As of 2014, index funds made up 20.2% of equity mutual fund assets in the US. Index domestic equity mutual funds and index-based exchange-traded funds (ETFs), have benefited from a trend towards more index-oriented investment products.
From 2007 through 2014, index domestic equity mutual funds and ETFs received $1 trillion in new net cash, including reinvested dividends. Index-based domestic equity ETFs have grown particularly quickly, attracting almost twice the flows of index domestic equity mutual funds since 2007. In contrast, actively managed domestic equity mutual funds experienced a net outflow of $659 billion, including reinvested dividends, from 2007 to 2014.
The first theoretical model for an index fund was suggested in 1960 byEdward RenshawandPaul Feldstein, both students at theUniversity of Chicago. While their idea for an "Unmanaged Investment Company" garnered little support, it did start off a sequence of events in the 1960s. Qualidex Fund, Inc., a Florida Corporation, chartered on 05/23/1967 (317247) by Richard A. Beach (BSBA Banking and Finance, University of Florida, 1957) and joined by Walton D. Dutcher Jr., filed a registration statement (2-38624) with theSECon October 20, 1970 which became effective on July 31, 1972.
"The fund organized as an open-end, diversified investment company whose investment objective is to approximate the performance of the Dow Jones Industrial Stock Average", thereby becoming the first index fund. In 1973,Burton MalkielwroteA Random Walk Down Wall Street, which presented academic findings for the lay public. It was becoming well known in the popular financial press that most mutual funds were not beating the market indices.
John Boglegraduated fromPrinceton Universityin 1951, where his senior thesis was titled: "The Economic Role of the Investment Company".Bogle wrote that his inspiration for starting an index fund came from three sources, all of which confirmed his 1951 research:Paul Samuelson's 1974 paper, "Challenge to Judgment";Charles Ellis' 1975 study, "The Loser's Game"; and Al Ehrbar's 1975Fortunemagazinearticle on indexing. Bogle foundedThe Vanguard Group in 1974; as of 2009 it was the largest mutual fund company in the United States.
Bogle started the First Index Investment Trust on December 31, 1975. At the time, it was heavily derided by competitors as being "un-American" and the fund itself was seen as "Bogle's folly".In the first five years of Bogle's company, it made 17 million dollars.Fidelity InvestmentsChairmanEdward Johnsonwas quoted as saying that he "[couldn't] believe that the great mass of investors are going to be satisfied with receiving just average returns".Bogle's fund was later renamed the Vanguard 500 Index Fund, which tracks theStandard and Poor's 500 Index.
It started with comparatively meager assets of $11 million but crossed the $100 billion milestone in November 1999; this astonishing increase was funded by the market's increasing willingness to invest in such a product. Bogle predicted in January 1992 that it would very likely surpass theMagellan Fund before 2001, which it did in 2000. John McQuown andDavid G. BoothofWells Fargo, andRex Sinquefieldof theAmerican National Bankin Chicago, established the first two Standard and Poor's Composite Index Funds in 1973.
Both of these funds were established for institutional clients; individual investors were excluded. Wells Fargo started with $5 million from their own pension fund, whileIllinois Bellput in $5 million of their pension funds at American National Bank. In 1971,Jeremy Granthamand Dean LeBaron at Batterymarch Financial Management "described the idea at a Harvard Business School seminar in 1971, but found no takers until 1973. Two years later, in December 1974, the firm finally attracted its first index client."
In 1981, Booth and Sinquefield startedDimensional Fund Advisors(DFA), and McQuown joined its board of directors. DFA further developed indexed-based investment strategies. Vanguard started its first bond index fund in 1986. Frederick L. A. Grauerat Wells Fargo harnessed McQuown and Booth's indexing theories, which led to Wells Fargo's pension funds managing over $69 billion in 1989and over $565 billion in 1998. In 1996, Wells Fargo sold its indexing operation toBarclays Bank of London, which it operated under the name Barclays Global Investors (BGI).
Blackrock, Inc. acquired BGI in 2009; the acquisition included BGI's index fund management (both its institutional funds and its iShares ETF business) and its active management. EconomistEugene Famasaid, "I take themarket efficiency hypothesisto be the simple statement that security prices fully reflect all available information." A precondition for this "strong version" of the hypothesis is that information and trading costs, the costs of getting prices to reflect information, are always 0.
A weaker and economically more sensible version of the efficiency hypothesis says that prices reflect information to the point where the marginal benefits of acting on information (the profits to be made) do not exceedmarginal costs. Economists cite theefficient-market hypothesis(EMH) as the fundamental premise that justifies the creation of the index funds. The hypothesis implies thatfund managersand stock analysts are constantly looking for securities that may out-perform the market; and that this competition is so effective that any new information about the fortune of a company will rapidly be incorporated into stock prices.
It is postulated therefore that it is very difficult to tell ahead of time which stocks will out-perform the market. By creating an index fund that mirrors the whole market the inefficiencies of stock selection are avoided. In particular, the EMH says that economic profits cannot be wrung fromstock picking. This is not to say that a stock picker cannot achieve a superior return, just that the excess return will on average not exceed the costs of winning it (including salaries, information costs, and trading costs).
The conclusion is that most investors would be better off buying a cheap index fund. Note that return refers to theex-anteexpectation;ex-postrealisation of payoffs may make some stock-pickers appear successful. In addition, there have been manycriticismsof the EMH.
Related contents:
Reasonable Investor(s), Boston University Law Review, available at:https://ssrn.com/abstract=2579510
^Hirst, Scott; Kastiel, Kobi (2019-05-01)."Corporate Governance by Index Exclusion".Boston University Law Review.99(3): 1229.
^"Can Anybody Beat the Market?".Investopedia. Retrieved2022-01-03.
^Hirst, Scott (2019-09-01)."Index Funds and the Future of Corporate Governance: Theory, Evidence, and Policy".ECGI - Law Working Paper. 433/2018.
^"2014 Investment Company Fact Book". Archived fromthe originalon 2016-06-20. Retrieved2014-11-05.
^Fox, Justin (2011). "Chapter 7: Jack Bogle takes on the performance cult (and wins)".The Myth of the Rational Market. USA: HarperCollins. pp.111–112.ISBN978-0-06-059903-4.
^Burton Malkiel (1973).A Random Walk Down Wall Street. W. W. Norton. pp.226–7.ISBN0-393-05500-0.
^Bogle, John (1950–1951)."Senior Thesis,"The Economic Role of the Investment Company"". Princeton University Library.
^Bogle, John (2006)."The First Index Mutual Fund: A History of Vanguard Index Trust and the Vanguard Index Strategy". Bogle Financial Center. Archived fromthe originalon 2013-05-07. Retrieved2007-08-04.
^"The Economist - World News, Politics, Economics, Business & Finance".The Economist. Retrieved2019-02-04.
^Ferri, Richard (2006-12-22)."All About Index Funds".McGraw-Hill.ISBN9780071423380.
^Bogle, John (1999).Common Sense on Mutual Funds.
^"How This Man Manages $69 Billion".Fortune. 1989.
^Grossman and Stiglitz (1980)
^Jensen (1978)
^Burton G. Malkiel,A Random Walk Down Wall Street, W. W. Norton, 1996,ISBN0-393-03888-2
^Jump up to:ab"High-Frequency Firms Tripled Trades in Stock Rout, Wedbush Says".Bloomberg/Financial Advisor. August 12, 2011. Retrieved26 March2013.
^Siedle, Ted (March 25, 2013)."Americans Want More Social Security, Not Less".Forbes. Retrieved26 March2013.
^Amery, Paul (November 11, 2010)."Know Your Enemy".IndexUniverse.eu. Retrieved26 March2013.
^Salmon, Felix (July 18, 2012)."What's driving the Total Return ETF?".Reuters. Archived fromthe originalon July 20, 2012. Retrieved26 March2013.
^Petajisto, Antti (2011)."The index premium and its hidden cost for index funds"(PDF).Journal of Empirical Finance.18(2): 271–288.doi:10.1016/j.jempfin.2010.10.002. Retrieved26 March2013.
^"Understanding index front running".The Trade Magazine. The TRADE Ltd. Archived fromthe originalon 2008-10-23. Retrieved2009-03-24.
^"The Hugely Profitable, Wholly Legal Way to Game the Stock Market".Bloomberg.com. 7 July 2015.
^Rekenthaler, John (February–March 2011)."The Weighting Game, and Other Puzzles of Indexing"(PDF).Morningstar Advisor. pp.52–56. Archived fromthe original(PDF)on 29 July 2013. Retrieved26 March2013.
^Donnelly, Katelyn Rae; Edward Tower (2009)."Chapter VIII. Time-zone arbitrage in United States mutual funds: Damaging to financial integration between the United States, Asia and Europe?"(PDF).Challenges and Opportunities for Trade and Financial Integration in Asia and the Pacific. Studies in Trade and Investment 67. New York: United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific. pp.134–165.ISSN1020-3516.
^"Market Reactions to Changes in the S&P 500 Index: An Industry Analysis"(PDF). Retrieved2014-07-30.
^"The Price Response to S&P 500 Index Additions and Deletions: Evidence of Asymmetry and a New Explanation"(PDF). Archived fromthe original(PDF)on 2014-06-06. Retrieved2014-07-30.
^"Small-Cap Indexing: Popularity Can Be a Pain". Archived fromthe originalon 2015-04-02. Retrieved2015-03-26.
^Arvedlund, Erin E. (2006-04-03)."Keeping Costs Down - Barron's". Online.barrons.com.
Retrieved2014-07-30.
.
